The solar system once had five giant gaseous planets rather than the four it has today. That’s the conclusion from a computer simulation of the solar system’s evolution, which suggests the fifth giant was hurled into interstellar space some 4 billion years ago, after a violent encounter with Jupiter. Astronomers have struggled for decades to explain the solar system’s current structure. In particular, Uranus and Neptune couldn’t have formed where they are today – the disc of gas that congealed into the planets would have been too thin at the edge of the solar system to account for the ice giants’ bulk.
A more likely scenario is that the planets were packed close together when they formed, and only spread out when the disc of gas and dust from which they formed was used up. The tighter orbits of extrasolar planet systems support this idea.
But the great gravitational bullies of the solar system, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune, would not have gone quietly to their new homes. Previous simulations show that at least one planet, usually Uranus or Neptune, should have been ejected from the solar system in the shuffle.
“People didn’t know how to resolve that,” says David Nesvorny of the Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, Colorado.
Now Nesvorny proposes a solution: a sacrificial ice giant between Saturn and Uranus that takes the fall for its planetary siblings.
Five planets to four
“If you start with five gaseous planets, then you see again that you lose one planet,” he says. “In a large fraction of cases, you end up with a good solar system analogue.”
Nesvorny ran a total of 6000 computer simulations with four or five gas giants in various initial positions around the sun. His simulated runs started shortly after the gas disc dissipated and lasted for 100 million years, long enough for the planets to settle into their final orbits.
All but 10 per cent of the four-planet simulations wound up with only three left, he says. But in half the five-planet simulations, they ended with the four in a solar system that looks remarkably like our own. The best results occurred when the fifth planet started off between Saturn and Uranus and ended up being ejected after an encounter with Jupiter. His work has been accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters.
The five-planet scenario solves a few other mysteries as well. For the inner rocky planets to survive intact while the outer gas giants jockeyed for position, some previous simulations show that Jupiter must have “jumped” from a position closer to the sun to its current orbit.
Music: Sundown by Dhruva Aliman
https://dhruvaaliman.bandcamp.com/album/hello-moon
http://www.dhruvaaliman.com/
Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/artist/5XiFCr9iBKE6Cupltgnlet
A more likely scenario is that the planets were packed close together when they formed, and only spread out when the disc of gas and dust from which they formed was used up. The tighter orbits of extrasolar planet systems support this idea.
But the great gravitational bullies of the solar system, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune, would not have gone quietly to their new homes. Previous simulations show that at least one planet, usually Uranus or Neptune, should have been ejected from the solar system in the shuffle.
“People didn’t know how to resolve that,” says David Nesvorny of the Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, Colorado.
Now Nesvorny proposes a solution: a sacrificial ice giant between Saturn and Uranus that takes the fall for its planetary siblings.
Five planets to four
“If you start with five gaseous planets, then you see again that you lose one planet,” he says. “In a large fraction of cases, you end up with a good solar system analogue.”
Nesvorny ran a total of 6000 computer simulations with four or five gas giants in various initial positions around the sun. His simulated runs started shortly after the gas disc dissipated and lasted for 100 million years, long enough for the planets to settle into their final orbits.
All but 10 per cent of the four-planet simulations wound up with only three left, he says. But in half the five-planet simulations, they ended with the four in a solar system that looks remarkably like our own. The best results occurred when the fifth planet started off between Saturn and Uranus and ended up being ejected after an encounter with Jupiter. His work has been accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters.
The five-planet scenario solves a few other mysteries as well. For the inner rocky planets to survive intact while the outer gas giants jockeyed for position, some previous simulations show that Jupiter must have “jumped” from a position closer to the sun to its current orbit.
Music: Sundown by Dhruva Aliman
https://dhruvaaliman.bandcamp.com/album/hello-moon
http://www.dhruvaaliman.com/
Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/artist/5XiFCr9iBKE6Cupltgnlet
Category
🗞
News