Is The A.I. Story Real Or Are We In A Bubble? Todd Gordon, Founder of Inside Edge Capital
Benzinga's PreMarket Prep is the #1 go-to source for everything you need to know before the market opens! Join our expert hosts as they break down the latest market trends, analyze key indicators, and provide actionable insights to help you navigate the trading day ahead.
Transcript
00:00 Todd Gordon, inside edge capital.
00:03 Todd, are you in a new environment?
00:06 Yeah, I moved the office.
00:09 It's a write-off.
00:10 How about that?
00:11 That's beautiful.
00:12 I love it, Todd.
00:13 Thanks, man.
00:14 Todd, this market relentlessly to the upside.
00:17 You've been bullish for a while, correctly here, Todd.
00:21 Let's just start with-- we're 5,000.
00:24 That's a P5,000.
00:25 Can we go to 6?
00:26 It's a big deal.
00:27 And bid.
00:28 And bid.
00:29 And bid.
00:30 Yeah.
00:32 Yeah, I mean, where do you want me to start?
00:34 It's an unbelievable move.
00:36 I think we have clarity on sort of the macro front.
00:40 I think the last two years have been very Fed and rate policy
00:45 driven.
00:46 I think the focus is a little bit more on consumer.
00:48 And I think this tech innovation we're in is real.
00:53 I hate to be a rah-rah table-pounding bull,
00:55 because I'm not.
00:56 Like you guys, I'm a trader just like you guys,
00:58 running money.
00:59 Like I can close everything in an hour and be short.
01:02 But I don't think that's the play here.
01:05 No, it doesn't feel like the play.
01:06 And people have been trying to call the tops in all these AI
01:09 stocks relentlessly here.
01:11 NVIDIA, I heard it back when it was 500.
01:13 Well, that's it.
01:14 It's going back to 100.
01:15 Then it was 600.
01:16 Then it's going back to 500.
01:18 Now it's 700.
01:19 But it's going back to 600.
01:20 I sense a pattern forming here.
01:22 And I am long NVIDIA.
01:24 And I'm like, usually I'm not participating
01:26 in all these fake people.
01:27 But I've said before, the valuations is not insane here.
01:30 So NVIDIA, SMCI has just been rocket ship mode.
01:33 AI stocks have just gone fire.
01:35 I mean, Arm hasn't--
01:37 Arm isn't even really an AI company,
01:38 but it's got a piece of AI.
01:40 And then they just grab it and run with it.
01:42 This AI-- is this a bubble, or is this real?
01:45 I mean, I don't--
01:48 OK, so let me ask you this.
01:50 When did the uptrend start?
01:53 According to you and Joel, when did we officially
01:56 go into bull market?
01:57 In this AI?
01:59 Let's call it the NASDAQ.
02:00 Like, when did we--
02:01 Oh, the NASDAQ was 2023, early 2023.
02:04 The whole-- you're 14 months into the bull market,
02:08 I would say, 2023.
02:09 It was the calendar turn in 2023.
02:12 Now, the IWM and the other stocks
02:13 really just started picking up in October of 2020.
02:17 So you have the tail of two markets.
02:18 And they really haven't even picked up that much.
02:20 I mean, it's been the tail of two markets.
02:22 The tech, which has just been killing it,
02:23 and then everything else has just kind of been,
02:25 just kind of like, not that great.
02:27 So, OK, so I mean, like, I would take the other side
02:32 and say it's hard to say a bull market started 14 months ago
02:36 when, like, I was on Twitter, like, vehemently
02:39 defending being bullish.
02:40 It's hard to say when so many were convinced
02:42 we're going into recession and sell all stocks that, in fact,
02:45 the bull market was starting.
02:47 I mean, maybe you'd look at it-- and this is a stupid argument,
02:49 because nobody knows the answer.
02:50 It's very subjective.
02:51 But maybe it's when we just broke out.
02:53 So maybe this thing is two, three weeks old.
02:57 So if you look at--
02:59 how do I share screen?
03:00 I mean, can I-- do you guys mind if I--
03:02 Yeah, you can have--
03:03 --shut it down.
03:03 OK.
03:04 I mean, I just like to be just simple with the NASDAQ, right?
03:08 I don't want to get super crazy.
03:10 But I mean, just look at the advances
03:14 that we've seen, post-tech crash.
03:16 Here's the GFC.
03:18 Here's recovery in the GFC.
03:20 And I mean, you don't need to overcomplicate it.
03:22 Like, the first move off of the 2002 low up into the housing
03:27 was 182%.
03:29 The next one was 1,500%.
03:31 Right now, what are we up?
03:32 Probably 60% right now, maybe, from the lows, which, again,
03:38 many were telling us that we're going
03:39 into recession or depression.
03:41 And we're only up 68% from there.
03:45 So I think there's a lot of good things going.
03:48 I mean, I think the valuations that everyone's
03:52 struggling with, traditional valuations,
03:54 are being challenged with the fact
03:56 that we have four-decade high inflation, rates are higher,
04:01 real cost of capital is a little higher, real rates are higher.
04:05 We have incredible efficiency happening in these companies.
04:08 And the technologies they're putting out
04:09 are going to be widespread, applicable across so
04:12 many different industries.
04:14 I think it's really premature to say this thing is long
04:18 in the tooth and even say bubble dentists.
04:20 It's just my humble opinion.
04:22 And again, people want to keep comparing.
04:25 I see it on Twitter all the time.
04:26 This is just like the 1999-2000 tech bubble.
04:29 But the big difference was, I can remember at Microsoft,
04:31 it was trading 85 times earnings, Todd.
04:34 What--
04:35 [INTERPOSING VOICES]
04:36 --32 times.
04:36 You said it earlier.
04:37 And I'm sorry to interrupt.
04:38 I almost interrupted you last time.
04:39 I interrupted you now.
04:40 That's OK.
04:41 What's Ford valuation on Nvidia right now?
04:43 35 times.
04:44 35.
04:45 And what's Eli Lilly for?
04:47 Oh, crazy.
04:48 Lilly will be--
04:49 It's like 50 or 60 maybe?
04:52 Yeah, it'll be 60 probably.
04:54 I haven't looked at it for a while.
04:55 But again, those projections are hard to do on Lilly
04:58 because we just don't know how many people are going to
05:01 actually go out and buy this drug.
05:03 So Lilly's a little harder to project.
05:05 So maybe it's going to be way more.
05:06 Maybe that's what the market's saying.
05:07 It's going to be way more.
05:08 Ford P, Benzinga Pro's got it 58 right now on Lilly.
05:11 Ooh, 58 times.
05:13 OK.
05:14 It's not cheap.
05:15 But again, that's a hard one to project.
05:17 Nvidia's a little bit easier.
05:18 But again, projections-- and people will argue with me,
05:21 Todd, about forward projections.
05:22 You can't look at those.
05:23 You have to look at trailing.
05:24 Because forward projections, those are just--
05:27 the companies are guessing.
05:28 But companies usually pretty much know
05:30 their business pretty well.
05:32 They often hit the forward projections.
05:34 That's what the market's trading on here, Dennis.
05:36 Would you agree with that?
05:37 It's not so much what the current EPS revenues are,
05:40 margins, et cetera.
05:40 It's all about the guidance.
05:42 It's all about guidance.
05:43 And forever, for the last two years, we were all--
05:46 in my opinion, CEOs going out there in an under promise,
05:50 then over-deliver.
05:51 Set the bar super low, beat it, just do it again.
05:54 And I think that jig is kind of up, so to speak.
05:56 I mean, now I think it's all about--
05:58 I think they have to have good, strong guidance going forward.
06:02 And analysts are now--
06:03 the markets are trading based on analyst expectation
06:05 with the CEOs putting on guidance.
06:07 So I think that's starting to improve.
06:09 We have-- on the rate front, maybe
06:12 we can stop all being macro, global macro traders
06:16 and fawning all over the yield curve, which
06:18 was the key driver of growth value rotation
06:21 over the last two years.
06:22 Rates are finally going quiet, thank goodness.
06:25 Like, we can just get a 10-year at 4 and 1/4, 4/2,
06:29 stay in a range, like, OK, good.
06:32 I think that'd be an ideal scenario.
06:34 And I think we can live with 4, 4 and 1/2 percent 10-year
06:38 yields.
06:39 The real yield is, what, 1, 1 and 1/2 percent.
06:43 I saw that inflation revision just came out.
06:45 We're still running 3, 3.3.
06:47 So I think we're in a really good place right now.
06:52 I like where the market's at.
06:53 I think there's a lot of bearish sentiment out there,
06:56 still under-participated.
06:57 I don't know what the short figures are.
06:59 But I feel like there's more money coming in.
07:01 And trust me, I am not a long-owned--
07:04 I love trading, like you, 20, 25, 30 VIX markets.
07:07 Like, those are super fun.
07:09 But I don't know.
07:10 I don't see it here.
07:11 Where do you think we can go?
07:12 We're 5,000 here on the S&P.
07:15 And again, it's hard.
07:15 You're a trader.
07:16 So given making price targets here,
07:18 you're not an analyst here.
07:19 I'm not going to throw you under the bus and say,
07:20 give me your 12-month price.
07:21 No.
07:22 But where can we--
07:24 is there any-- can you use your technical analysis skills here
07:27 and give us any type of projections on where
07:29 this S&P might be going?
07:31 I didn't even bring up my technicals just for this,
07:34 for a reason.
07:35 And I can bring it up in a sec.
07:36 It's so simple right now, it's scary.
07:40 I'm an Elliott Wave guy.
07:41 For better, for worse, I'm thinking
07:43 about just going in the closet, not talking about it,
07:46 just do it.
07:47 I'm sick of defending it because there's so many people giving--
07:49 Right.
07:51 But if you look at Microsoft, you look at S&P,
07:54 you look at NASDAQ, you look at even Bookings.
07:57 I was just listening to you on Bookings, BKNG.
07:59 There's so many simple five-wave moves up
08:03 from either the late 22 or the early 23 low.
08:07 I'm literally up at night thinking about,
08:11 how are we going to escape this?
08:13 And it's such a simple, obvious five-wave move,
08:16 which was given to us by Charles Dow.
08:19 He's the grandfather of technical analysis, markets
08:21 moving three primary advances, accumulation, widespread
08:25 participation, then distribution.
08:27 This is going back to Charles Dow.
08:29 So the model says we're in the distribution phase off
08:33 of that 23 rally.
08:35 I'm really curious to see how the market handles this.
08:38 Guys, I've been saying this for every morning video
08:42 that I do for clients and investors.
08:45 I can't remember a time I've been so short-term bullish,
08:48 but near, beyond short-term medium to longer-term concern
08:53 for a 10% to 15% drop.
08:55 And I'm not going to sit by and give these profits back.
08:57 I'm going to go to work hedging, but I just
08:59 don't want to take it off because if the most
09:02 obvious pattern, which I just described, is wrong,
09:04 this thing's going to freaking ramp.
09:07 I want to talk about rotation here, too.
09:09 Sure, sure, sure.
09:10 And it was asked in the chat.
09:11 And the people waiting for this IWM, you and I
09:15 have had great discussions on this on the At the Close show.
09:18 And you kind of took the attitude of, well,
09:21 does it have to go?
09:23 Do these companies--
09:24 But why is it--
09:26 Why-- listen, I've only been doing this for 20 years.
09:30 Would somebody please tell me why a four-decade high
09:35 environment in terms of interest rates
09:37 requires fundamentally unsound leveraged companies who
09:41 don't have access to funding?
09:43 Why do they need to participate?
09:46 800 of the 2,000--
09:49 Russell's 2,000s are not profitable companies,
09:52 and they have questionable value.
09:54 Tell me why this index needs to participate.
09:56 I really would like to know.
09:58 I mean, you look at Children's Place here today,
10:00 case in point here.
10:01 I mean, smaller company here, their, obviously, interest
10:06 rates have probably been an issue here for a while.
10:09 It's down 55% this morning.
10:10 I mean, how many other companies are--
10:12 the banks, IWM is very heavily the banks.
10:15 They've had some problems with it, too.
10:16 So I mean, I think you're right.
10:18 I mean, there's a reason why these companies and the IWM
10:23 just hasn't participated, and that is rates.
10:25 Right, right.
10:26 But there's two stories to the small cap.
10:27 Take a look at the S&P 600 small cap.
10:30 They put a fundamental filter on there.
10:33 Much different story.
10:34 Look at the CALF, the CAF ETF, the top 100 fee cash flow
10:38 small cap companies at highs.
10:40 So I'm not buying it.
10:43 We've seen this before.
10:45 We've seen this before.
10:46 I love the rotation.
10:47 There's a lot going on here, and I'll just kind of break--
10:50 this is great.
10:51 Julius de Kempenaar came up with a great way
10:54 to visualize rotation.
10:55 What I'm doing is taking the best performing industries
11:00 within technology.
11:02 They are obviously going to be semis in green,
11:05 semi material and equipment, tech hardware, which
11:08 SMCI and Apple actually go in there,
11:11 system software, application software, and tech
11:13 distributors.
11:15 So what I'm doing is I'm going to start the rotation.
11:18 This is November of '23.
11:20 Here's the turn of the year.
11:22 What you'll see, obviously, no surprise,
11:24 semis are going to rip up into the right.
11:26 No surprise.
11:27 Huge move in semis.
11:29 Now, this rotation is happening on a clockwise basis,
11:34 and the benchmark is the S&P 500.
11:37 So as you're moving up, top of the right,
11:38 semis are up for me.
11:39 No surprise.
11:41 Semi materials and equipment are there.
11:43 But the problem is the breadth, even within tech,
11:46 is getting a lot less.
11:47 We're losing system software, application software.
11:51 Forget about hardware.
11:53 I mean, Apple is-- you know where Apple is.
11:55 I don't mind--
11:56 Yeah, it hasn't done much.
11:57 But the software stocks, which were so strong back here
12:00 at the end of '23, here was the rotation.
12:03 I know it's hard to see.
12:04 You've got to kind of get used to it.
12:05 But see the move in system software, application software
12:08 like Cadence, Synopsys, Manhattan, ServiceNow,
12:12 like CRM, Adobe.
12:13 Those things were ripping.
12:14 But now they're taking a pretty good backseat.
12:18 And I'm a little concerned because breadth--
12:21 even though we're getting health care and there's
12:23 different names moving up to new highs,
12:26 breadth is deteriorating.
12:27 And it's increasingly the weight's
12:29 going on the shoulder of semis.
12:30 And that's another reason, thinking back
12:32 to my simple five-wave move off the '23 lows,
12:34 like is health care going to lead it?
12:37 I don't think so.
12:38 So that's my question that I'm really contemplating.
12:42 So what makes you--
12:44 and obviously, you're holding.
12:45 You said you don't want to sell your holding.
12:47 What's the sell signal?
12:48 What are we looking for that would say, hey,
12:51 we just topped out.
12:52 Let's get it to cash.
12:53 What is that signal?
12:55 The magic signal.
12:57 I mean, I'm watching bonds.
12:58 30-year bonds would just bid on that number
13:00 and they just gave it all back.
13:03 So what's the sell signal?
13:06 I think there's still too much bearishness out there.
13:09 I don't think these kind of bull markets die from boredom.
13:12 I think we need some exuberance.
13:14 But it all depends on the time frame.
13:16 I mean, if you're talking a 10% to 50% pullback
13:19 that I'm talking about, if we don't get follow-through,
13:24 if the bearishness persists, we are coming
13:28 into a seasonally weak period.
13:30 The lack of participation on the upside,
13:33 we might just have to take some profits here.
13:36 I don't know.
13:37 I don't know the answer to that question.
13:38 Don't we need some consolidation first?
13:42 Yeah, I mean, at least see some consolidation.
13:45 Right now, you're doing your levels.
13:47 Support keeps moving up.
13:49 You're making higher lows.
13:50 You're making higher lows.
13:51 You're making higher highs.
13:52 You're having higher closes.
13:54 At least, I mean, until you try and call a turn on this,
13:57 at least you got to see some kind of consolidation
14:00 before that and not seeing that today.
14:03 That's a good point, Joel.
14:04 And here's a study I'm looking at, percent distance
14:07 from the moving averages.
14:09 So let me go to the weekly--
14:10 I was asked about that yesterday.
14:12 Yeah.
14:13 OK, but what were you asked?
14:15 I mean, do we have to go-- like, Nvidia is so far away
14:19 from its moving averages.
14:20 Don't we have to go back there?
14:22 And my response is, we don't have to do anything.
14:25 We don't have to do anything.
14:27 So let's look at that.
14:28 So this is a kind of squished in weekly chart.
14:32 I want to look at the weekly NASDAQ.
14:34 So the 50-week is the dotted gray,
14:38 and the 200 is right there.
14:41 So distance from the 200-week currently is 31%.
14:46 And I would say, on first blush, if I just
14:49 looked at this, the optics of price from the 200-week,
14:54 I would say, yeah, it's pretty stretched.
14:56 We probably need to come back.
14:57 But then when you put it on this chart
14:59 and you actually quantify it, we're
15:01 only 31% above the 200-week.
15:03 And there's plenty of precedence to be 60%, 70%.
15:08 Wow.
15:09 We seem to-- from 2012, '14, '15, '18, '19,
15:14 when they first started to hike rates a touch,
15:17 we were hanging at 40% to 50% above the 200-week.
15:19 So I think longer-term, Joel, it's a really good point
15:22 you make.
15:23 We're way from overbought on the 200-week.
15:26 The 50-week near-term, to your point on consolidation,
15:31 I think--
15:32 I'm listening to myself.
15:33 I'm monitoring myself.
15:34 I'm like, oh, huge move higher or lower.
15:36 All right, calm down.
15:38 So maybe it is consolidation, because if you
15:40 look at the 50-week kind of hidden in gray,
15:43 distance from price of the 50-week,
15:46 you look over the right scale, about 28%, 18%, 20%.
15:51 So we're there.
15:53 We're at 17%.
15:54 But we're not-- 2020, we're not at 30%, 25%.
16:00 So maybe it is consolidation.
16:03 If you think about it, if we go sideways for a while,
16:05 because big earnings are mostly out of the way,
16:08 and we don't have a Fed meeting until May,
16:10 and we won't even get any--
16:12 March, I'm already thinking March is a no.
16:14 Nothing's going to happen.
16:15 Like, maybe price consolidates, giving the 50-week moving
16:20 average time to catch up as price goes sideways,
16:23 sort of backing that off.
16:24 And maybe that's the consolidation we need.
16:26 Like, I'm so long NVIDIA.
16:28 I got stock up the wazoo.
16:30 I got options.
16:30 I got options sparring today.
16:32 I've got call spreads up top.
16:34 That's a nice place to be.
16:35 But it makes you nervous when this thing just
16:37 goes parabolic.
16:38 And then you're like, oh, should I ring the register on some?
16:41 Should I just keep holding?
16:42 What's the sell signal on NVIDIA?
16:44 When do you get out of that?
16:45 Well, I've got technical levels at 740,
16:48 and I've been that way for a while.
16:51 I have a lot of my net worth in NVIDIA,
16:55 a lot more than it should be.
16:56 But I'm in from a very good price,
16:59 so it's a ton of cushion.
17:01 So we increased holdings in the wealth management NVIDIA.
17:07 So maybe the greatest pain trade, guys,
17:10 is maybe just sideways.
17:11 As I'm watching NVIDIA screw around the 700 level,
17:14 I mean, I'm having flashbacks in NVIDIA from 500, right?
17:19 I mean, how long--
17:19 Yeah, I am too.
17:20 It did not pause at 600.
17:22 500--
17:23 500 was--
17:24 500 was monthly.
17:25 Yeah, look how many times it like 500, 500, 500, 500.
17:30 And then it wasn't until the fifth attempt.
17:33 Now, 600, if you took that philosophy at 600,
17:37 you got absolutely rolled over.
17:39 700, I mean, it's hard to say that it's
17:42 going to be the 500, at least at this point.
17:45 The other thing I want to add is that with the data
17:49 that we got today, do we have to worry about the CPI and PPI
17:53 next week, right?
17:55 We got that data coming out.
17:56 So there's a lot of things here.
17:58 Todd, we're coming up against the clock.
18:00 Todd Gordon, inside Edge Capital, joining us here.
18:04 You want to give one more play?
18:05 I got so much more to say to you guys.
18:07 Two things.
18:07 I know.
18:08 I'll get off.
18:09 I promise.
18:09 What happens if 24, if the phrase goes from how much is
18:13 the Fed going to cut this year is, well, thankfully,
18:16 they're not going to raise?
18:18 Maybe, right?
18:19 And then the other thing I'll put in front of you,
18:21 I want to put in front of you, consumer discretionary
18:23 is lagging.
18:24 I get it.
18:24 But look at the numbers from Amazon, specifically Prime,
18:28 adding subscribers, advertising numbers strong.
18:30 Look at Spotify, adding huge numbers.
18:33 People are advertising.
18:34 And then the other one I had to note-- oh, my god,
18:37 it was Amazon, it was Spotify, and Netflix.
18:39 The growth there on their ad tiers, ads are big right now.
18:44 And I think companies wouldn't be investing in advertising
18:47 if the consumer was truly on unstable footing.
18:51 So maybe-- I don't think we're going to get as many rate cuts
18:54 as they think this year.
18:55 That's going to be the realization process
18:57 markets are going to have to go through.
18:58 All right.
18:59 Thanks for having me.
19:00 Do what you need to do, Todd Gordon, inside Edge Capital,
19:02 joining us here on Pre-Market Prep.