独中要筹款没问题 但搞出“班级排行榜”怪怪的？校方“道德绑架”不太妥当？
▐ 全民来讲讲▐ 独中建校募款设排行榜，促捐款额垫底的班级再“加油”冲刺，近期成了网络上热议话题！“加油榜”是一种隐形的霸凌？妥妥的“道德绑架”？民众怎么看？
热点站主 ｜@Jazkee界錤
#独中 #华文学校 #筹款 #加油榜 #建校基金
#发射热点 #84hotspot #热点短视频 #全民来讲讲
更多新闻资讯看这里 ▹ https://xuan.com.my/hotspot
热点站主 ｜@Jazkee界錤
#独中 #华文学校 #筹款 #加油榜 #建校基金
#发射热点 #84hotspot #热点短视频 #全民来讲讲
更多新闻资讯看这里 ▹ https://xuan.com.my/hotspot
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 I feel stressed because there's a ranking system
00:02 If you reveal it, it'll be like
00:03 "Oh, I'm embarrassed"
00:03 "Hidden bullying"
00:05 No matter if it's moral or anything else
00:07 it's definitely wrong
00:08 You can't morally kidnap people
00:10 For many Chinese students
00:12 it's not surprising that they help
00:14 schools raise funds on the streets
00:17 But recently, a piece of news
00:18 has caused a heated discussion
00:19 A KPI for encouraging students
00:21 to raise funds
00:23 was shown in the campus
00:24 for the achievement of each class' fundraising
00:26 It implies that there are some classes
00:28 that are surrounded by students
00:30 and they need to work harder
00:31 Some people think that students pay for their classes
00:33 and their parents sometimes donate money
00:35 Why do the school need to raise funds?
00:37 Some people also question
00:38 if this is not the job of the board
00:40 Does raising funds on the streets
00:42 make us go out of class
00:44 and get in touch with the society
00:45 or is it just a way to show off?
00:48 In today's episode of "The Untamed"
00:49 let's hear from the public
00:50 how they see the school's approach
00:53 If we use this ranking system
00:56 to those who can only donate RM2
00:59 they will feel embarrassed
01:00 or they will be despised
01:02 I personally don't think it's correct
01:04 to do this
01:05 I think it's voluntary
01:08 If you want to compare
01:11 I think it's better
01:13 This will make others compare each other
01:16 Because how much you want to donate
01:18 depends on your own will
01:20 It's not like you have this board
01:22 and you donate more
01:24 Donating is voluntary
01:26 Donating is not like you have a credit card
01:28 You can't talk about the price
01:30 If you donate RM50, I will accept it
01:32 Every family has a different life
01:34 and different income
01:36 My mum is a middle school student
01:38 She has said that
01:40 she wants this every year
01:41 She said they are enjoying it
01:43 Although they will meet some bad people
01:45 like scolding you
01:47 but she said
01:48 it's a different experience
01:54 We have a draw every year
01:57 like charity
01:58 It will set a number
02:01 If you don't have this number
02:03 you have to find a way to raise the money
02:05 Usually, we will raise the money ourselves
02:08 I remember it was RM300
02:09 for charity
02:10 and RM400 for graduation ceremony
02:12 RM400 or more
02:13 It's better to be higher than that
02:14 It's the minimum limit
02:16 You have to help
02:17 RM50, RM100
02:18 Then you have to find a friend to help you raise money
02:20 You have to get it out
02:21 You don't have to worry about giving him money
02:24 Is it like that?
02:26 It's everywhere
02:30 It's everywhere
02:32 Not only in Penang
02:34 but also in other places
02:35 We have a lot of money
02:36 RM5, RM10, RM3
02:39 Sometimes we will donate
02:40 It's not real
02:41 I feel that the public will be annoyed
02:44 Why?
02:44 I have already raised the money
02:45 Why do you come again?
02:46 I am afraid that
02:47 people will think that
02:48 the school is always asking for money
02:49 I think this draw
02:50 is necessary for students to know
02:53 why I am raising money for this
02:56 Instead of saying every day
02:57 I want to build these buildings
02:59 and I didn't see it
03:01 So I think the board and the school should discuss
03:03 When I was organizing some donation activities in my school
03:06 My good friends
03:08 will always ask me
03:09 Why does the school need to raise money all the time?
03:12 Because a lot of things are back-and-forth
03:13 Lights, fans, everything is good
03:15 Everything is used and it will be bad
03:18 And the number of times we use
03:19 The degree of damage is definitely
03:21 worse than the general use of the family
03:23 The number of times to replace will be more
03:24 The cost will definitely be more
03:26 What if I give it to someone else halfway?
03:31 I give people 5-6 punches
03:33 I go back or I fall
03:34 Or give people a gun
03:35 How about beating the gun?
03:36 So people are responsible for this
03:37 I can accept it
03:38 Actually, it's just their safety
03:40 Must be considered first
03:42 Because there is no limit to the draw
03:43 If the time is not enough, I have to go to the draw
03:44 I feel a little stressed
03:46 If I go to the restaurant with a group of friends
03:48 It's fun to walk around
03:50 I think if it's school students
03:51 They shouldn't go out
03:52 They should ask their school board of governors
03:55 and parents
03:56 They don't have the resources to collect donations
03:59 Young people should let them go
04:00 This is the case
04:02 It's not a foreign matter
04:03 There is no way for the school to be rational
04:05 It's impossible to quarrel with the school
04:08 Can't be too close
04:09 Just once
04:10 I think it's to let them experience
04:12 Our Chinese education is not easy
04:14 Otherwise, they don't understand
04:15 They think
04:16 I want air conditioning
04:18 I want computers
04:19 I want interactive TV
04:22 Is there anyone donating?
04:23 They think it's very simple
04:25 At least let them understand
04:27 The school's draw to set up a ranking list
04:29 To cheer up the students
04:31 It caused a fierce discussion on the Internet
04:33 But most of the people in the family video community
04:36 Most people think
04:37 There is no problem with the school's draw
04:39 Just don't need to set up this ranking list
04:41 Or set the minimum amount of money
04:44 This will cause stress to students
04:46 At the same time, it also has the meaning of moral kidnapping and humiliation
04:49 What do you think?
04:50 For the school's long-term draw
04:52 Is there a better alternative?
04:54 Welcome to leave a message
04:55 Remember to share it
04:56 Let more people join the discussion
04:58 (music)