The atrocities of war are difficult to portray. Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we’re counting down portrayals of battles, strategies and soldiers in the Second World War that put a premium on authenticity and realism.
Category
🎥
Short filmTranscript
00:00 James Francis Ryan?
00:02 Yes, sir. How'd you guess that?
00:04 Welcome to Watchmojo and today we're counting down portrayals of battles, strategies, and soldiers in the Second World War that put a premium on
00:12 authenticity and realism with a focus on including some lesser-known or recently less heralded gems. If I go first,
00:19 I'll wait for you there
00:23 on the other side of the dark waters.
00:28 Number 10, A Walk in the Sun.
00:30 Was the enemy 50 miles away?
00:32 Was he just behind the beachhead?
00:35 Waiting. Set during the Italian campaign of World War II, A Walk in the Sun is a poignant study of an American platoon
00:43 tasked with securing a farmhouse in the Italian countryside.
00:45 What sets it apart is its meticulous attention to the psychological state of the soldiers, each grappling with the immediate horrors of battle and the
00:54 quieter internal struggles they face.
00:56 I wish he'd cut out that groaning. He ain't too bad. He's just working for his purple heart.
01:00 I don't like the responsibility. You're stuck with it.
01:03 It all unfolds almost in real time, offering a granular view of the soldiers' interactions and the tactical decisions
01:09 they must make under duress. The dialogue, often introspective, adds layers to the characters, making their experiences deeply resonant. The
01:17 understated approach eschews sensationalism, favoring the complexity of human emotion. Crying because you're wounded.
01:25 You don't have to be bleeding to be wounded. You've just had one battle too many.
01:28 Number nine, Fury. Wait until you see.
01:32 See what?
01:35 What a man can do to another man.
01:39 Set in April 1945, as the Allies make their final push into Nazi Germany, Fury captures the claustrophobic
01:46 intensity and grimness of tank warfare. Director David Ayer focuses on the psychological strain and moral complexities
01:54 faced by the crew, offering a gritty,
01:56 unromanticized view.
01:59 I see our dead bodies. How do you know they're dead? Are you a doctor? Hit 'em!
02:01 But they're dead. Why would I shoot them if they're already dead?
02:04 The action is punctuated with intense, close-quarters fighting sequences that emphasize the brutal efficiency of tank battle. The technical
02:12 details of the tank, the authenticity of the combat tactics, and the raw emotional performances contribute to a palatable sense of urgency and danger,
02:21 underscoring the sacrifices and ethical dilemmas inherent in such a conflict. I'm sorry.
02:26 Okay, I'm trained to type
02:29 60 words a minute.
02:31 I am not trained to machine gun dead bodies. I'm trying my very best.
02:35 Number eight, Battle of Britain. This afternoon, the Prime Minister, Mr. Churchill, said,
02:41 "What General Vegard called the Battle of France is over. The Battle of Britain is about to begin."
02:48 This riveting movie excels in its detailed reenactment of the 1940 struggle, where the Royal Air Force
02:54 defended the UK against massive aerial attacks by the German Luftwaffe.
02:58 It captures these strategic intricacies and the dire stakes with a somber tone,
03:03 focusing on the experiences of both high command and the fighter pilots. We don't need a big wing or a small wing.
03:10 We need pilots. The use of actual Spitfires and Messerschmitts adds an unparalleled level of
03:18 specificity to the aerial scenes, enhancing the historical accuracy. The depiction of tactical decision-making,
03:23 combined with the visceral sense of danger in the cockpits, reflects the intense pressure of the fight that was crucial in preventing Nazi invasion.
03:31 What happened to Harvey?
03:34 He got a 109, then ran into trouble, but he's all right.
03:37 No mistake. I saw him bail out. Number seven, Midway. I'm convinced Yamamoto's target is Midway.
03:44 If you're wrong, Admiral,
03:47 if you send our carriers into a Japanese ambush,
03:50 the entire West Coast and the White Island will be wide open for invasion.
03:54 Fully aware of that, Captain.
03:55 This epic chronicles the pivotal World War II battle that shifted the naval power balance in the Pacific theater.
04:02 It meticulously recreates the events of June 1942,
04:05 focusing on the strategic decisions made by both American and Japanese naval commanders.
04:10 It features an ensemble cast who portray the high-stakes environment of naval warfare with a focus on both the American and Japanese
04:18 perspectives. At any rate, we must not break radio silence and risk letting them know where we are.
04:23 Sir, the element of surprise is one of the most important aspects of our attack.
04:29 Using actual footage,
04:31 Midway provides a compelling look at the tactical genius and gambles taken by Admiral Nimitz and his counterparts. The interplay of
04:39 intelligence breakthroughs, aerial dogfights, and ship maneuvers are portrayed with a dedication to historical accuracy,
04:46 emphasizing the tactical ingenuity that led to a decisive American victory. Were we better than the Japanese or just luckier?
04:54 Number six, The Longest Day. We're on the threshold of the most crucial day of our times.
05:00 Three million men out there,
05:03 keyed up,
05:05 waiting for that big step off.
05:09 Reconstructing the D-Day invasion, The Longest Day offers a meticulously detailed chronicle of June 6th,
05:14 1944. Viewed through the lenses of both Allied and German forces, the narrative spans multiple viewpoints,
05:21 from American paratroopers and British beach raiders to French resistance fighters and German commanders,
05:27 highlighting the varied and vital roles each played. The use of black-and-white
05:31 cinematography and precise reproductions of military tactics and environments achieve a striking level of realism.
05:39 "One click is to be answered by two clicks.
05:42 And if you don't get that answering click,
05:47 hit the dirt, open fire." The dialogue and interactions are steeped in military detail,
05:54 avoiding dramatization to focus on operational details and the palpable tension of the uncertain outcome.
06:00 The movie stands out for its careful balance of broad strategy and individual heroism,
06:06 effectively capturing the enormity and complexity of the Normandy landings. "We came here to take St. Marys-Eglise.
06:12 We're gonna take it and hold it." Number five, A Bridge Too Far. "The plan,
06:18 like so many plans in so many wars before it, was meant to end the fighting by Christmas
06:25 and bring the boys back home."
06:28 Set during the ill-fated
06:31 Operation Market Garden in September
06:33 1944, A Bridge Too Far intricately details one of the boldest plans
06:37 executed by the Allies in an attempt to hasten the end of the fighting by capturing key bridges in the Netherlands. The plot focuses
06:44 on the ambitious yet flawed operation from the perspectives of the American, British, Polish and German troops involved.
06:52 "I'll have to risk it. It's halfway through the morning and things aren't getting any better."
06:55 "So, how is it?" "Sir,
06:57 we can't clear the streets, sir. Enemy strength keeps increasing and it's just impossible to get through to the bridge."
07:03 Director Richard Attenborough employs a painstaking approach to the military strategies and logistical challenges,
07:08 blending large-scale action sequences with intimate soldier stories. This focus works to underscore the
07:15 operational complexity and the high human cost of this strategic gamble. "I'd lose all my men for nothing.
07:21 There's God knows how many lying out there already." "You mean it's over, sir?" "I didn't say that, did I?
07:26 We've paid for that bridge and we're going to collect, but to do it, I need tank support."
07:31 Number four, Guadalcanal Diary. "Each of us has an assigned task. Let each vow to perform it to the utmost of his ability
07:39 with added effort for good measure. Good luck and God bless you.
07:43 God favors the bold and the strong of heart." Made during the war,
07:47 this is an intimate on-the-ground look at the early stages of the Pacific campaign,
07:52 specifically focusing on the experience of a group of Marines during the Battle of Guadalcanal.
07:58 Adapted from real-life accounts, it avoids glorification,
08:01 instead presenting a straightforward, almost journalistic view of daily life and combat on the island. "Heads,
08:07 legs bandaged,
08:09 clothes torn,
08:11 unlit cigarettes dangling from their lips,
08:13 all before their times." The Marines' camaraderie, the grueling jungle fighting, and their interactions with the local
08:21 environment are depicted in detail.
08:23 Director Lewis Seiler emphasizes the harsh conditions, the sporadic yet intense encounters with Japanese forces, and the
08:30 psychological toll on the soldiers, providing viewers with a visceral sense of the challenges faced during one of the most critical campaigns.
08:38 "Three men out of the entire patrol remain alive.
08:41 The others,
08:43 to many of whom Guadalcanal was not even a name a few short months ago,
08:46 now lie dead in their shallow foxholes,
08:50 over which an indifferent sea is already beginning to roll." Number three, "The Thin Red Line." "In this world,
08:56 a man himself
09:00 is nothing."
09:02 Stylized but deeply realistic,
09:04 Terence Malick's "The Thin Red Line" also explores the conflict at Guadalcanal, but through a more philosophical and introspective lens that
09:12 diverges from traditional soldier narratives. The film delves deeply into the inner lives of several soldiers,
09:19 portrayed by a star-studded ensemble cast, as they grapple with the nature of existence and the morality of war.
09:25 "Guadalcanal may be the turning point in the war.
09:27 It'll cost lives, Starrows. Is that what's troubling you?" Malick's direction is characterized by lush, sweeping visuals of the island
09:37 juxtaposed against the brutal nature of combat, creating a stark contrast that highlights the intrusion of violence into a seemingly
09:45 idiosyncratic setting. The dialogue often takes a poetic turn,
09:49 reflecting the soldiers' internal conflicts and their interactions with both their environment and the enemy. "And if we were stalled before reaching the top,
09:57 well, Jesus Christ, that's just a hell of a lot more than I could stand!
10:00 I've waited all my life for this!"
10:04 Number two, "The Big Red One." "You know how you smoke out a sniper?
10:08 You send a guy out in the open and you see if he gets shot.
10:12 They thought that one up at West Point." Directed by Samuel Fuller, who drew upon his own World War II
10:18 experiences, "The Big Red One" is a raw portrayal of the 1st Infantry Division's trials throughout the European theater.
10:25 Centered on a tight-knit squad led by a battle-hardened sergeant, "The Big Red One"
10:30 captures the essence of infantry life, from the beaches of Normandy to the liberation of a concentration camp.
10:36 "Sergeant!"
10:39 "Corporal Kolowitz,
10:41 can't you read that sign says 'private party'?"
10:44 "Lieutenant Stocko wants your squad on that double." Fuller focuses on the personal dynamics within the squad, showing how shared
10:51 experiences forge a bond that becomes their greatest survival tool. His storytelling combines gritty action sequences with moments of
10:59 introspective downtime, highlighting the cyclical nature of tension and relief for soldiers. "I'm not gonna tell you again.
11:06 No lights at night." "Sergeant, war is over!"
11:10 "Look,
11:12 nobody's firing at us." Before we continue, be sure to subscribe to our channel and ring the bell to get notified about our latest
11:18 videos. You have the option to be notified for occasional videos or all of them. If you're on your phone,
11:24 make sure you go into settings and switch on your notifications.
11:27 Number 1 - Saving Private Ryan
11:31 "First wave! Ineffective! We do not hold the beach day again! We do not hold the beach!"
11:38 This iconic movie is renowned for its stark and unflinching
11:41 depiction of the Omaha Beach assault on D-Day and its aftermath. It begins with one of the most visceral sequences ever filmed,
11:48 capturing the terrifying chaos and sheer carnage of the landing.
11:52 Directed by Steven Spielberg, the film follows a group of soldiers tasked with finding and bringing home Private James Ryan
11:59 after his three brothers are killed in action. "You know, if going to Rommel and
12:04 finding him so he can go home, if that earns me the right to get back to my wife, well then...
12:08 then that's my mission."
12:12 Spielberg uses a blend of intense, shaky camera work and sound design to immerse viewers in the tumult of killing and dying,
12:19 emphasizing the random and brutal nature of war.
12:23 Everything from the uniforms and weapons to the tactics and soldier dialogue adds depth to this poignant exploration of duty and sacrifice.
12:33 "You're going home.
12:35 Our orders are to bring you back."
12:38 "Bring me back."
12:43 We know there are numerous other realistic depictions of World War II ranging from Dunkirk to Stalingrad,
12:49 so tell us what should be included in the next version of this list.
12:52 "Yes, it is.
12:55 Quite a view."
12:58 Did you enjoy this video? Check out these other clips from WatchMojo, and be sure to subscribe and ring the bell to be notified
13:04 about our latest videos.
13:06 [Music]
13:08 [Music]
13:11 [Music]
13:13 [MUSIC PLAYING]
13:17 you