Balitanghali Express: September 9, 2024

GMA Integrated News

Narito ang maiinit na balita sa Balitanghali Express ngayong Lunes, September 9, 2024:   -Pastor Apollo Quiboloy at 4 pang akusado, nakakulong sa PNP Custodial Center sa Camp Crame/ PNP: Quiboloy at 4 pang akusado, sumuko kasunod ng ultimatum ng pulisya/ PNP: 3 sa mga akusado, tumaas ang blood pressure; nagpapahinga sa kani-kanilang selda   -Sen. Risa Hontiveros, naniniwalang abot-kamay na ang hustisya matapos bumagsak sa kamay ng pulisya si Pastor Apollo Quiboloy   -Dismissed Mayor Alice Guo, dumating na sa pagdinig ng Senado ukol sa mga ilegal na POGO   -Alice Guo, nasa Senado na   -PNP Officers na nagbabantay sa KOJC Compound, umalis na kasunod ng pagsuko ni Pastor Apollo Quiboloy/ Sitwasyon sa KOJC Compound, kalmado na; mga taga-KOJC, nag-prayer rally/ KOJC Legal Counsel: Sumuko si Pastor Quiboloy para matigil na ang karahasan sa KOJC Compound   -WEATHER: 2 LPA, binabantayan sa loob at labas ng PHL Area of Responsibility   -Mga taga-NBI at Immigration na nag-selfie kasama si Alice Guo, pinagpapaliwanag ng DOJ   -DILG Sec. Abalos: Ex-Rep. Arnie Teves, sunod na target pabalikin mula sa Timor-Leste/ DOJ: Extradition kay Teves, posibleng maasikaso pagkatapos ng papal visit sa Timor-Leste sa Sept. 11   -San Beda Red Lions, Benilde Blazers, San Sebastian Stags, at EAC Generals, wagi sa kanilang unang laban sa NCAA Season 100 Men's Basketball   -Kokoy de Santos, itinanghal bilang ultimate runner ng "Running Man Philippines" Season 2   -PBBM: Walang special treatment kay Pastor Apollo Quiboloy   -Oil price rollback, ipatutupad bukas   -64-anyos na lalaki, tinulungan ng mga kapitbahay matapos mahulog umano sa baha   -Pagkatay sa ilang aso sa Benguet, nakuhaan ng video   -60 preso at 20 tauhan ng San Mateo BJMP, sugatan sa riot; code red, ipinatutupad sa bilangguan/   Sunog sumiklab sa isang storage at industrial facility; 2 sasakyang nakaparada, nadamay   -LIVE SENATE HEARING: Pagdinig ng Senado kaugnay sa mga isyu sa POGO/ Alice Guo, dumalo sa pagdinig ng Senado   For Kapuso abroad, subscribe to GMA Pinoy TV (http://www.gmapinoytv.com/) for GMA programs, including the full version of Balitanghali.  Balitanghali is the daily noontime newscast of GTV anchored by Raffy Tima and Connie Sison. It airs Mondays to Fridays at 10:00 AM (PHL Time).  #GMAIntegratedNews #KapusoStream  Breaking news and stories from the Philippines and abroad: GMA Integrated News Portal: http://www.gmanews.tv Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/gmanews TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@gmanews Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/gmanews Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/gmanews

Transcript

00:00:00🎵

00:00:24Magandang Tanghali po!

00:00:26Oras na para sa maiinit na balita!

00:00:28Unahin na po natin ang balita tungkol kay Pastor Apollo Quibuloy.

00:00:33Nakakulong po ngayon si Pastor Quibuloy at apat na kapwa niya akusado

00:00:37sa PNP Custodial Center sa Camp Krames sa Quezon City.

00:00:40Doon sila dinala mula sa Kingdom of Jesus Christ Compound sa Davao City

00:00:43matapos sumuko kasunod ng ultimatum ng mga otoridad.

00:00:47Balita natin ni James Agustin.

00:00:52Bantay sarado ng mga polisang convoy na sakay si Pastor Apollo Quibuloy

00:00:56at apat na iba pang kapwa niya akusado na lumabas sila sa Villamore Airbase sa Pasay.

00:01:00Pasado las 9 kagabi na dumating ang convoy sa Camp Krames sa Quezon City

00:01:04at dumireto sa PNP Custodial Center.

00:01:07Nasundan ito ng kumpirmasyon ng PNP na sumuko sa KOJC Compound sa Davao

00:01:12si Pastor Quibuloy at apat na iba pa.

00:01:15Kinukumpirma po natin, nahawak na po natin si Pastor Quibuloy,

00:01:20si Jacqueline Roy,

00:01:22si Ingrid Canada,

00:01:24si Cresente Canada,

00:01:26at si Silva Semanes po.

00:01:28Nakuha po natin yung custody po nila around 5.30.

00:01:32Mga bandang 6.30 po ay nilipad po natin sila mula po sa Davao

00:01:36at papunta po dito sa Villamore po tayo lumabas.

00:01:40Ayon sa PNP, alauna y medya ng hapon kahapon

00:01:43na magkaroon ng negosasyon para sa pagsuko ni Pastor Quibuloy.

00:01:47Kasunod ito na ibinigay na 24 oras na ultimatum ng polisya.

00:01:51Nagkaroon po ng negosasyon,

00:01:53ang PNP na kinatawan po ng Intelligence Group at ISAP,

00:01:59pinagtulungan po ito,

00:02:00that led to the peaceful surrender po ni Pastor Quibuloy at apat pa.

00:02:04Sa tanong na kung saan nga ba nagtago si Pastor Quibuloy,

00:02:07sabi ng PNP,

00:02:08I don't have at liberty to reveal that.

00:02:11Ang importante po sa ngayon ay nasa custodial po ng PNP po ito.

00:02:15Pagdating sa custodial center,

00:02:16isinilbi ang mga warrant of arrest laban kay Pastor Quibuloy at apat niyang kasamahan.

00:02:20Kay Pastor Quibuloy po, yung child abuse po,

00:02:23yung sexual abuse,

00:02:25at yung qualified trafficking.

00:02:28Binasahan po sila ng mga kaso po nila

00:02:31at nakahagap ang kanilang abugado po.

00:02:33At pagkatapos po noon,

00:02:34binasahan din po sila ng kanilang mga Miranda Rights at mga kakapatan po.

00:02:39Isinailalim din sila sa booking procedures,

00:02:41physical and medical examination.

00:02:44Tatlo sa kanilang tumasang blood pressure.

00:02:46Pero tumanggi ang polisya na tukuyin kung sino-sino.

00:02:49Nag-okay naman na po.

00:02:50Binigyan po sila ng gamot ng ating mga doktors,

00:02:53particularly yung pagkapusa sa pagtaas po ng BP.

00:02:57After a few minutes naman po,

00:02:59ay inexamine po sila uli ng mga doktors and nurses

00:03:03at okay na po sila.

00:03:04Natapos na po yung booking.

00:03:05Natapos na po yung inspection ng mga gamit nila.

00:03:11Kaya kami ay aalis na dahil magpapahinga na po sila

00:03:14at dinalan na po sila doon sa mga kwarto na intended po para sa kanila.

00:03:18Tinanong din namin ang polisya,

00:03:19kaugnay sa selda kung saan nakapiit ngayon si Pastor Kebuloy at apat na iba pa.

00:03:23Basta ang masasabi ko lang po,

00:03:25nandun na po sila ngayon sa area kung saan po sila

00:03:30magpapahinga pa ka ngayong gabi po.

00:03:32Inihanda na ng CIDG ang mga dokumento

00:03:34para sa isasagawang return of warrants sa Quezon City RTC at Pasig RTC.

00:03:39James Agustin nagbabalita para sa GMA Integrated News.

00:03:44Ngayong hawak na ng polisya si Pastor Apolo Kebuloy,

00:03:46naniniwala si Senador Rizal Antiveros na mananagot sa batas ang pastor.

00:03:51Ayon si Antiveros,

00:03:52abot kamay na ang justisya para sa mga dating miyembro ng Kingdom of Jesus Christ

00:03:56na naging biktima umano ni Kebuloy.

00:03:58Patuli raw ang investigasyon ng kumiting pinamumunuan niya.

00:04:01Git naman ang abogado ng KOJC na si Atty. Israelito Torion,

00:04:05At the same time,

00:04:06sumuko si Kebuloy para matigil ng anyag karahasaan sa KOJC compound.

00:04:10Patuli raw ang mga legal hakbang ng mga abogado ni Kebuloy

00:04:13kaugnay ng mga hinaharap niyang kaso.

00:04:21Update po tayo sa sitwasyon sa Senado.

00:04:23May ulat on the spot.

00:04:24Si Sandra Aguinaldo.

00:04:26Sandra?

00:04:27Yes, Connie.

00:04:28Narito na nga tayo sa Padilla Room ng Senado

00:04:31at kapapasok lang nito si Dismissed Mayor Alice Goh.

00:04:35At sa ayan, nakaupuna sa harapan at agiliran ng resource person at senador.

00:04:48Ilang upuan lang mula sa kanya.

00:04:50Nandun naman si Sheila Goh.

00:04:52Ito yung inakala ng marami na kapatid niya pero dinlarify nila later on

00:04:57na hindi sila blood-related.

00:04:59Pero lumaki sila na parang magkapatid yan.

00:05:03Sinasabi daw ni Sheila kahapon sa kanyang abogado na excited siya.

00:05:08O sinabi ni Alice Goh kahapon sa kanyang abogado na excited siya na makita si Sheila.

00:05:13Pero nung sila magkita dito ay nagtinginan lang sila.

00:05:17Hindi sila ikang naglapit o nagyakapan.

00:05:22At sila ay tahimik na nakaupu lamang sa kanilang mga upuan.

00:05:28Naka-mask po si Alice.

00:05:30Nung dumating siya kanina dito, maaga pa lang, 8.30 am-9.00 am, dumating siya.

00:05:37Siya ay naka-kevlar helmet, naka-bulletproof vest, naka-balot yung kanyang kamay.

00:05:43Nang-team na parang jacket.

00:05:45Indikasyonal, naka-contact siya.

00:05:48Tapos din siya sa holding area.

00:05:51Ngayon parang nanatili siya halos ng oras.

00:05:54At saka siya dinela ngayon dito sa loob ng Padilla Room.

00:05:59Pero ang nakikita natin dito, hindi na siya nakaposas.

00:06:02Yung kamay na nakapasok lang doon sa kanyang bolsa at hinakausap niya ang kanyang mga abogado.

00:06:11So, na-completo na rin yung mga senador.

00:06:13Narito yung chairperson ng subcommittee.

00:06:15Nasa-senador Arisa Ontiveros.

00:06:17At sina-senador Gingoy Estrada.

00:06:21Villanueva, ABA Harris dito.

00:06:23Sherwin Gatchal yan.

00:06:25So far yun yung natatanaw natin mula sa ating vantage point.

00:06:28Connie?

00:06:29Yes, Sandra. Ano ba ang nakikita natin ngayon na mood naman itong si dismissed na Tarlac kabambang mayor Alice Guo?

00:06:36Unlike dun sa mga naunang nakita natin na medyo parati sya nakangiti.

00:06:41Of course, di natin makikita dahil naka-facemask siya.

00:06:44Pero yung kanyang overall na demeanor, kamusta?

00:06:47Ayan, ibang-iba, Connie. Ibang-iba doon sa ating nakita.

00:06:52Nung ikaw nga na sunduin sa Indonesia na parang napaka-cozy, parang nasaya.

00:06:56Ngayon, masasabi natin na tahimik siya.

00:06:59Most of the time, nakatungo. Maliba nalang kung kinakausap ng kanyang kabugado.

00:07:04Ito, Connie, nagkisimula na yung pagdining.

00:07:07Connie?

00:07:08Alright. Marami salamat, Sandra Aguinaldo.

00:07:13Kasunod ng pagsuko ni Pastor Apollo Q. Buloy, kalmado na ngayon ang sitwasyon sa KOJC compound sa Davao City.

00:07:19Umalis na ang mga polis na naka-duty sa pagbabantay roon habang nagsagawa naman ng prayer rally ang membro ng KOJC.

00:07:26Balita ng atid ni Jandi Esteva ng GMA Regional TV.

00:07:32Nang hawak na ng mga otoridad, si Kingdom of Jesus Christ, founder Pastor Apollo Q. Buloy kahapon.

00:07:38Ito na yung mga kapulisan. Dahandahan na po silang nagpo-pull out.

00:07:45Nag-alisa na ang mga nakadeploy na mahigit 2,000 polis.

00:07:50Kabilang sila sa mga nagbantay sa KOJC compound sa Davao City mula pa noong August 24 para silbihan ng warrant of arrest si Pastor Q. Buloy

00:08:00at apat pa na akusado para sa kasong human trafficking at child at sexual abuse.

00:08:06Naging kalmado na ang sitwasyon sa loob at labas ng KOJC.

00:08:10Nagsagawa rin ng thanksgiving prayer ang mga membro ng KOJC.

00:08:15Sa larawan mula kay Department of Interior and Local Government Secretary Benhur Abalos,

00:08:20makikita si Pastor Q. Buloy kasama si Atty. Israelito Turion na Chief Legal Counsel ng KOJC

00:08:26at si Police Brigadier General Romeo Macapas, ang chief ng PNP Intelligence Group.

00:08:31Sa panayam naman ng GMA Regional TV 1 Mindanao kay Police Brigadier General Nicolas Torre III,

00:08:37director ng Police Regional Office 11, wala pa siyang ideya kung saan ba nahuli si Pastor Q. Buloy.

00:08:45I really do not know the details. Pakitanong niyo na lang si SILG kasi siya talaga ang nakakaalam noong mga detalye nito.

00:08:54Ngayon pa man, masaya raw siya na sa wakas ay hawak na ng otoridad si Q. Buloy matapos ang ilang linggong pagkahanap.

00:09:01Handa raw si Torre na harapin ang mga kaso laban sa kanya ng KOJC.

00:09:10Samantala, sa Facebook post ni Atty. Turion, ipinaliwanag niya na sumuko umano si Pastor Q. Buloy

00:09:16dahil naaawa na umano siya sa nangyayari sa kanya mga miyembro sa KOJC,

00:09:21lalo na sa anyay pagsira ng kanilang compound.

00:09:25Pinasalamatan din ni Atty. Turion ang ilang opisyal ng pamahalaan, Philippine Army,

00:09:30at Philippine National Police na tumulong daw sa pagsuko ng Pastor.

00:09:34Ako si John D. S. Esteban ng GMA Regional TV, nagbabalita para sa GMA Integrated News.

00:09:422. LPA

00:09:46Dalawang low-pressure area ang binabantayan po sa loob at labas ng Philippine Area of Responsibility.

00:09:51Huling namataan ng pag-asa ang unang LPA, 1,155 km east-northeast ng extreme northern Luzon.

00:09:59Ang ikalawang LPA naman ay nasa 2,810 km silangan ng eastern Visayas at nasa labas ng PAR.

00:10:07Wala pang direkt ang epekto sa lagay ng ating panahon ang mga nasabing LPA,

00:10:11pero may chance sa mga ito na maging bagyo.

00:10:14Mababa naman ang posibilidad ng mga nabanggit na LPA na mag-landfall sa bansa.

00:10:19Sa ngayon, hanging habagat ang magpapaulan muli sa malaking bahagi ng Luzon.

00:10:23Sa mga susunod na oras, uulanin po ang halos buong northern at central Luzon

00:10:28base sa rainfall forecast ng metro weather.

00:10:31Posible ang heavy to intense rains na maaring magdulot ng baha o landslide.

00:10:35Asahan din po ang ulan sa ilang panig ng southern Luzon kasama ang Metro Manila, Visayas at Mindanao.

00:10:42Nakataas po ngayon ang thunderstorm advisory dito sa NCR, Tarlac, Pampanga, Nueva Ecija,

00:10:48Batangas, Bulacan, Rizal, Quezon at sa ilang panig ng Zambales, Bataan, Cavite at Laguna.

00:10:56Tatagal ang thunderstorm advisory hanggang 10.30 ngayong umaga.

00:11:01Pinagpapaliwanag ng Department of Justice, ang mga taga National Bureau of Investigation

00:11:06at Bureau of Immigration na nagpakuha ng letrato kasama si Dismissed Mayor Alice Guo.

00:11:12Umani ng iba't ibang komento at reaksyon ng mga selfie dahil tila naging instant celebrity raw si Guo

00:11:18nang sunduin siya sa Indonesia matapos maaresto.

00:11:21Sabi ni Justice Secretary Jesus Crispin Remulia, kapag naulit pa ito, ay sususpindihin na sila.

00:11:27Nag-sorry ang isa sa mga immigration officer na nasa letrato.

00:11:57Matapos maaresto ni na-Alice Guo at Pastor Apollo Kibuloy,

00:12:16si dating Negros Oriental 3rd District Representative Arnulfo Tevez Jr. naman

00:12:20ang sunod na target mapabalik ng mga otoridad sa Pilipinas.

00:12:23Sabi yan ni Interior and Local Government Secretary Bernard Abalos

00:12:26sa pagharap niya sa Pinoy community sa Dubai, United Arab Emirates, kagabi oras sa Pilipinas.

00:12:31Nitong Sabado, sinabi na ng Department of Justice na gusto raw ni Timor-Leste President Jose Ramos Horta

00:12:37na ma-extradite na si Tevez.

00:12:39Umaasa ang DOJ na maasikaso ang pagbabalik kay Tevez

00:12:42pagkatapos ng PayPal visit ni Pope Francis Doon sa September 11.

00:12:46Si Tevez ang itinuturong mastermind sa pagpatay kay Noe Negros Oriental Governor

00:12:51Roel Digamo at siyam na iba pa noong March 4, 2023.

00:12:55Dati na niyang itinanggi ang mga akwasasyon.

00:13:03Exciting court action naman ang hatid ng nagbabalik na NCAA Season 100 Men's Basketball Competition.

00:13:09Sa opening game, victory para sa Season 99 Defending Champions na San Beda Red Lions

00:13:14kontra sa Season 100 Host School na LPU Pirates sa score na 79-63.

00:13:21Pinatumba naman ng Benil Blazers ang Mapua Cardinals sa score na 78-65.

00:13:27Win number one din para sa San Sebastian Stags vs. LeTron Knights, 91-84.

00:13:35Nagpakitanggilas naman sa overtime ang EAC Generals para talunin ang Arellano Chiefs sa score na 87-80.

00:13:44Ngayong NCAA Season 100, naniniwala si GMA Network Chairman Attorney Felipe Algozon

00:13:49na muling mangingi babaw ang tiyaga at katatagaan ng student-athletes.

00:13:57The resilience and perseverance are marks of the true spirit that shape the human being.

00:14:05The pillars of strength that define NCAA, the first athletic league of our country, established in 1924.

00:14:20Monday latest tayo mga mari at pare from Boy Cabado to Boy Panalo.

00:14:25Meet your running man Philippines Season 2 Ultimate Runner, Kokoy DeSantos.

00:14:32Tapos na ang gera.

00:14:35Sina lalo?

00:14:38Ang nanalo?

00:14:41PISNA!

00:14:43Si Buboy?

00:14:44Ay!

00:14:45Ano yan? Ikaw na nakakuha?

00:14:47PISNA!

00:14:48TIGIL NA ANG GERA DAHIL ANG NANALO!

00:14:50WALANG IBA!

00:14:52KUNDE SI KOKOY!

00:14:54Yan ang big reveal ni na Kokoy at Buboy Villar matapos dumaan sa intense one-on-one match

00:15:00sa nametag-ripping mission ng high-rating reality game show na payakap at talon pa sila sa saya.

00:15:07Chika ng Ultimate Runner kakaiba ang feeling dahil first time niyang manalo ng solo since Season 1.

00:15:14Ang avid supporters ng show to the ship sa team Jekoy, Kokoy at Angel na anilay perfect match.

00:15:21Sigaw tuloy ng netizens more Jekoy chemistry sa Season 3.

00:15:26Kagabi present ng cast at crew sa watch party ng season finale ng Running Man Philippines.

00:15:31Congrats, paring Kokoy!

00:15:37Iginiit ni Pangulong Bongbong Marcos na hindi bibigyan ng special treatment si Pastor Apollo Kibuloy

00:15:42na hawak na ng pulisya matapos sumuko kagabi.

00:15:48There is no special treatment. Although he is a very prominent person, so we will treat him like any other arrested person.

00:15:59We will go through the process. The process will be transparent. Everyone who is involved will be accountable.

00:16:06We will demonstrate once again to the world that our judicial system in the Philippines is active, is vibrant and is working well.

00:16:19At Trades Management Summit sa Taguig, sinabi rin ng Pangulo ng mga Korte na ang bahala tungkol sa mga kaso ng Pastor.

00:16:25Nahaharap si Kibuloy sa mga kasong qualified human trafficking at child and sexual abuse na dati na niya ang itinanggi.

00:16:32Bukod pa rin ang patong-patong na kaso niya sa Amerika gaya ng sex trafficking, fraud and coercion at bulk cash smuggling.

00:16:39Ayon sa Pangulo, wala pang extradition request ng Amerika para kay Kibuloy.

00:16:43Mga kaso sa Pilipinas muna raw ang unang kailangang harapin ng Pastor.

00:16:54Sa ating mga motorista, paalala po, may rollback bukas sa mga produktong petrolyo.

00:16:58Sa anunsyo ng ilang kumpanya, may 1 peso and 55 centavos na bawa sa kada litro ng gasolina.

00:17:041 peso and 30 centavos naman para sa diesel.

00:17:07At 1 peso and 40 centavos naman para sa kerosene.

00:17:15Ito ang GMA Regional TV News.

00:17:20Tinulungan ng mga residente ang isang lalaking senior citizen matapos mahulog umanaw sa baha sa Dagupan, Pangasinan.

00:17:29Nanginginig at naninigas na sa lamig ang lolo ng matagpuan ng mga kapitbahay niya sa barangay Bunuan, Gueset.

00:17:38Ayon po sa mga residente roon, 5 buwan na raw na nakatira doon ang 64 na taong gulang na lalaki.

00:17:45Kinukup-kup lamang siya ng ilang residente pero hirap silang alagaan ng lolo dahil sa kanyang sakit.

00:17:51Sa ngayon, naayos na ang kanyang silungan para hindi mabasa ng ulan.

00:17:57Minomonitor na ng barangay ang kalagayan ng lolo.

00:18:00Nanawagan naman ng mga otoridad sa sino mang nakakakilala sa lolo na makipag-ugnayan sa kanila.

00:18:08Pasintabi po sa mga sensitibong balita,

00:18:10nabibiyuhan ng isang concerned citizen ang pagkatay sa ilang aso sa barangay Buyagan sa La Trinidad, Banguet.

00:18:16Sa video, makikita ang isang aso nakasama ng isang lalaki na tila na mamasyal lang.

00:18:21Papunta pala sila sa lugar kung saan isinasagawa ang pagkatay sa mga aso.

00:18:26Kita sa video ang isa pang aso na duguan at patay na pero pinalo pa ng isang lalaki.

00:18:31Ang puting aso naman ang sunod na hinila ng lalaki.

00:18:34Hindi na nakuhan na ng video pero isinunod daw na kinatay ang puting aso.

00:18:39Madalas daw na nagkakatay ng aso roon at ginagawang pulutan.

00:18:43Nay-report na raw sa otoridad ang insidente na kinukundina ng mga animal lover.

00:18:48Magsasampan ng reklamo ang isang animal rights group laban sa mga sangkot sa insidente.

00:18:54Ito na ang mabibilis na balita.

00:19:00Nakataas pa rin ang Code Red sa Bureau of Jail Management and Penology sa San Mateo, Rizal matapos ang riot noong biyernes.

00:19:0760 persons deprived of liberty at 20 tauhan ng San Mateo BGMP ang nagtamu ng minor injuries.

00:19:13Ilang gamit din ang nasira.

00:19:15Ayon sa pulisya, 7 PDL ang nag-noise barrage sa kulungan bilang pagtutol sa cashless policy na ipatutupad noon.

00:19:23Coupons na kasi ang gagamitin sa mga transaksyon sa binangguan sa halip na pera para maiwasan daw ang korupsyon.

00:19:29Nakipagkasundo ang BGMP sa mga PDL na hindi muna ipatutupad ang cashless policy at pag-uusapan munang mabuti.

00:19:39Sumiklabang sunog sa isang storage at industrial facility sa Barangay Potrero sa Malabon kahapon.

00:19:44Ayon sa BFP, pasado alas 3 ng hapon sumiklabang apoy na umabot sa ikatlong alarma.

00:19:49Naging pahirapan ng pagapula dahil hindi makapasok ang mga bumbero sa facility na nakakandado.

00:19:55Damay sa sunog ang dalawang sasakyang nakaparada sa harap.

00:19:58Napula ang sunog alas 5 ng umaga kanina.

00:20:01Wala namang naiulat na nasawi o sugatan.

00:20:04Inaalam pa ang sanin ng apoy at halaga ng pinsala.

00:20:07Sa puntong ito gumugulang na po ang pagdinig ng Senado Kaugnay sa mga issues sa Pogo kung saan nakasalang si Dismissed Bambantan Lak Mayor Alice Guo.

00:20:19Panuorin po natin yan live.

00:20:38At nabanggit yan ni Alice Guo during one of the hearings.

00:20:44Sheila, sorry Sheila Guo na sumakay sila sa maliit na boat kulay puti and then nagtransfer sa isang fishing vessel.

00:20:54So maaring ganun yung ginamit na roll yung video.

00:21:01And ipapakita po natin kung papaano na hindi na niya kailangan pang sumampa from boat to boat.

00:21:10Dahil sinag din po namin from July 1 to July 20, yung route na binanggit ni Sheila Guo ay medyo rough ang dagat, medyo maalon, habagat.

00:21:24Kaya impossible basta basta na lang sila makapagsampa without the aid of that fishing vessel that I showed.

00:21:31Wala ba tayo moving? Mabilis lang?

00:21:55Today, Madam Chair, with the help of our resource speakers from the Coast Guard, Immigration, KAAP, and other relevant agencies,

00:22:03I would like to identify the weak points in our border control.

00:22:07Madam Chair, our country's borders is very complicated.

00:22:11Every shoreline could serve as an exit point.

00:22:14And this makes the Philippines a potential hub for transnational crimes.

00:22:21We have to review our border control and transportation regulations policies.

00:22:25Wala po sa mga commercial modes of transportation ang problema.

00:22:28Kasi ang kriminal hindi naman po sasakyan ng MRT.

00:22:32Usually, sarili niyang motosiklo or heavily tainted na van.

00:22:36Ganun din po sa sea and air transport.

00:22:39Ang kriminal na may pera ay may ibang paraan ng paglalakbay.

00:22:43On another matter, Madam Chair, I would like also for us to look into the process and protocol in extracting fugitives in our country.

00:22:52This is not our first fugitive extraction.

00:22:55We have undergone this process before.

00:22:57But what was the reason why there seemed to be a different protocol with Alice Go'o's extraction?

00:23:04Usec Raul Vasquez said that it was just an immigration to immigration issue.

00:23:10Si Alice Go'o tulad ni Sheila Go'o at Cassandra Ong ay hinuli ng Indonesian authorities.

00:23:17Dahil sa immigration violation.

00:23:19Dahil dalawa ang passport at hindi proper ang entry documents.

00:23:24That was the process that was followed because it's fast, efficient, and least expensive dahil nga immigration to immigration lang.

00:23:34Exclusion removal on their side and extraction on our side.

00:23:39In fact, for the two ladies, Sheila Go'o and Cassandra Ong, there was just two immigration officers and two NBI officers who processed their extraction and they took a regular commercial flight.

00:23:54What was the thought process behind the alternate protocol in the case of Alice Go'o?

00:24:01The Senate arrest order was issued prior to the warrant issued by the Kapas, Kapas-Tarlac RTC.

00:24:08I want this to be clarified in this hearing.

00:24:11And finally, was the dismissal of Alice Go'o from being mayor a scheme for the filing of the case in Kapas-Tarlac?

00:24:18Would it not be better if this case was filed in a court outside the jurisdiction of Tarlac, which Alice Go'o treated as her playground?

00:24:29Of course, we assume that there is a regularity in our court processes.

00:24:33But maybe we should realign our policies to ensure that it cannot be manipulated.

00:24:39Because let's face it, kung may natutunan tayo dito sa kwento ni Alice Go'o, basta't may pera ka, walang imposible.

00:24:48Salamat po Madam Chair.

00:24:49Salamat din po Sen Rafi. Kung wala na pong ibang opening statements, may I request COMSEC i-acknowledge yung ating mga resource persons at pagkatapos i-administer yung oath sa mga hindi pa nakapanong pa noon.

00:25:06Good morning everyone. The committee would like to acknowledge the presence of the following resource persons.

00:25:11From the Department of Justice, we have Assistant Secretary Francis John L. Pijano.

00:25:18Attorney Marielle Francisco.

00:25:21Attorney Hannah Lizette Manalili.

00:25:24Attorney Benjamin Samson.

00:25:28Then from the Office of the Solicitor General, we have Assistant Solicitor General James Kondangan.

00:25:36State Solicitor June Abigail de la Cruz.

00:25:41Then from the Philippine National Police, we have Police Colonel Isagani Fetasanan.

00:25:52Then we have, still from the Philippine National Police, CIDG, Police General Raul Takaka.

00:26:04Then Police Colonel J. Di Maandal.

00:26:13From the Department of Information and Communications Technology, we have Maricar Magpili.

00:26:21Okay, from the Department of Foreign Affairs, we have Director Lailani Feliciano.

00:26:33Director Von Ryan Pangwi.

00:26:39Then from the Department of Interior and Local Government, we have Assistant Secretary Romeo Benitez.

00:26:45From the Department of Transportation, we have ASEC Enrique Antonio Esquivel.

00:26:52From the Presidential Anti-Organized Crime Commission, we have Undersecretary Gilberto Cruz.

00:26:59We have Director Winston John Cascio.

00:27:03Then from the Interagency Council Against Trafficking, we have Undersecretary Mariella Garcia.

00:27:10Then from the Interagency Council Against Trafficking, we have Undersecretary Nicholas Felix T.

00:27:19From the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation, we have the Chairperson, Mr. Alejandro Tenko.

00:27:28Together with General Raul Villanueva.

00:27:32Attorney Josephine Pagdanganan.

00:27:35Attorney Aliyah Kumagul.

00:27:38Then from the Anti-Money Laundering Council, we have Attorney Adrian Arpon.

00:27:46We have Attorney Arnold Cabanglit.

00:27:51From the Bureau of Internal Revenue, we have Attorney Iskraton Orculio.

00:27:59Attorney Edgar Alan Reyes.

00:28:02Then from the Bureau of Immigration, we have Commissioner Norman Tancinco.

00:28:09Together with Fortunato Manahan, Jr.

00:28:14Attorney Arvin Cesar Santos.

00:28:17From the Immigration Regulations Division, we have Chief Rogelio Guevara, Jr.

00:28:25From the National Bureau of Investigation, we have Judge Jaime Santiago.

00:28:32Then from the Philippine Statistic Authority, we have Engineer Marisa Grande.

00:28:40We have Attorney Eliezer Ambatali.

00:28:44From the Manila International Airport Authority, we have the General Manager, Mr. Eric Jose C. Ines.

00:28:54From the Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines, we have Attorney Roberto Martin Venaventura.

00:29:02From the Maritime Industry Authority, we have Attorney Mary Margaret Espino.

00:29:10Then from the Philippine Coast Guard, we have Vice Admiral Rolando Lizor Ponsalan, Jr.

00:29:19We have Captain Oliver Tanseco.

00:29:24We have Captain Jabelino Sali.

00:29:27We have Commander Maria Gloria Bermudo Salcedo.

00:29:36And then we have Bernadette Gutierrez.

00:29:42From the Philippine Navy, we have Rear Admiral Jose Maria Ambrosio Espeleta.

00:29:50Then Captain Marco Buena.

00:29:52We have Captain Isilito Lagadia, Jr.

00:29:55From the Securities and Exchange Commission, we have Attorney Gerardo F. Del Rosario.

00:30:02Then we have Ms. Cheryl Medina, the Executive Assistant of Mayor Kalugay.

00:30:11Then we have Mr. Jose Antonio T. Feliciano, the former mayor of Bambantarloc.

00:30:17Then we have Ms. Alice Guo, alias Gua Haping.

00:30:22Then Ms. Sheila Guo, alias Sangmir.

00:30:26Then we have Attorney Elmer Galicia.

00:30:30Attorney Stephan Eldavid.

00:30:33Ms. Rosaline Baterna, the Corporate Secretary of Locket South 99.

00:30:40That's all, Madam Chair.

00:30:41We also invited Mayor Kalugay, but he sent his letter of regrets.

00:30:48This is the second time that Mayor Kalugay is absent.

00:30:53When the committee first invited them, they said that they have a stomach ache.

00:30:59This is the second inability to honor the invitation of the committee.

00:31:04So at the proper time, I will invite Mayor Kalugay.

00:31:09I will move now that we issue a subpoena, Madam Chair, to this Mayor, Mayor Kalugay.

00:31:18Madam Chair, of Fasual Pangasinan.

00:31:21So move, Madam Chair.

00:31:23Yes, the Chair.

00:31:25I second the motion.

00:31:27Thank you very much.

00:31:29On the motion of Sen. Joel, as seconded by the Senate President Pro Tempore, Sen. Gingoy.

00:31:34The Chair rules that the committee issue a subpoena for the good Mayor.

00:31:40They need to be able to attend the next hearing.

00:31:43Madam Chair, may I also ask if we were able to invite the Secretary of Mayor Kalugay,

00:31:49a certain Cherry, which is here.

00:31:53Thank you, thank you, thank you, Madam Chair.

00:31:56Thank you, Sen. Joel.

00:31:57Thank you, Madam Chair.

00:31:59Thank you, Sen. Joel.

00:32:01Also, Comsec, I heard the name Cassandra Lee Ong.

00:32:05Is she here again?

00:32:07Or is she already here with us?

00:32:09Madam Chair, she is still at the hospital.

00:32:14But we sent a letter to the Speaker requesting the presence of Ms. Cassandra Ong here.

00:32:21But there's no reply from the office of the Speaker.

00:32:25Well, the committee hopes that there will be a reply forthcoming from the office of the Speaker.

00:32:29Yes, Comsec?

00:32:31There's a reply.

00:32:33If I may read.

00:32:35This is a request of your committee to allow Ms. Cassandra Lee Ong to attend the public hearing on September 9, 2024 at the Senate.

00:32:44Please know that this request has been approved by the Joint Justice Committee.

00:32:48However, please be informed that Ms. Ong is still confined at the hospital in Taguig.

00:32:54The latest update is that she may be discharged from confinement either tonight or Tuesday, tomorrow.

00:33:01That's good to know, Comsec.

00:33:03And thank you for the reply from the office of the Speaker.

00:33:06We have that in writing, not just on the cell phone.

00:33:10Okay.

00:33:12And it's right that she will be discharged tonight.

00:33:15Because actually, what we know is that last time, on Thursday, she was only allowed to rest for 2 to 3 days by the doctor of the house.

00:33:21So she should really be here at the next hearing.

00:33:25Yes, San Joel?

00:33:27Yes, Madam Chair.

00:33:29Following the opening statements a while ago of Senator Rafi, and I think it's very important that we set the record straight when it comes to the contempt powers of the Senate, the jurisdiction, and the pending court cases.

00:33:43And I can see two brilliant legal luminaries here in this August chamber.

00:33:49Madam Chair, just for the record and for the sake of clarification, is it correct that Ms. Alice Guo is still under contempt for her failure to attend the two hearings of this Senate committee, June 26 and July 10 hearings?

00:34:05Is that an affirmative, Madam Chair?

00:34:07That is correct, San Joel.

00:34:09Alice Guo or Guo Huaping is still subject to the citation of contempt of this committee and the Senate.

00:34:15So this is still live, Madam Chair.

00:34:19Second, the jurisdiction.

00:34:21May we know the committee's position as to the jurisdiction and the period of imprisonment under the inherent contempt powers of the Senate, Madam Chair?

00:34:32San Joel, those are actually among the questions that not only the Chair but I'm sure the colleagues will be raising during this hearing.

00:34:41And by the end of the hearing, I would really like to form a ruling, the Chair and the committee, regarding this important discussion.

00:34:50Because it is very important to the committee and the entire Senate that the powers and rulings of the Senate are respected by the resource persons.

00:35:02In the same way, we give equal respect to the co-equal branches of government.

00:35:07Before the Chair asks the COMSEC to administer the oath to our resource persons, I will call on the Majority Leader and then we will proceed to the administering of the oath.

00:35:21Yes, Sen. Francis.

00:35:23Madam Chair, good morning. Germane to the statement given by Senator Joel Villanueva.

00:35:29At the proper time, I will file a motion directing this committee to take cognizance of Ms. Alice Goh.

00:35:42And this is where we will first look at the Senate.

00:35:46Thank you.

00:35:48I serve notice, Madam Chair. I have with me bags of jurisprudence to back up my claim.

00:35:54Thank you very much, Majority Leader. The Chair will welcome that motion at the proper time and will rule on it accordingly.

00:36:06Yes, Sen. Joel.

00:36:08Thank you very much, Madam Chair. And I would like to thank our Majority Leader for raising that up because that is precisely what we wanted to tackle, Madam Chair.

00:36:16Because let me just put into the records of this August Chamber the landmark case of Arnold v. Nazareno.

00:36:24This is a landmark case. It was stated that obedience to its process may be enforced by the Senate Committee if the subject investigation before it was within the range of legitimate legislative inquiry.

00:36:38Accordingly, Madam Chair, as you mentioned, our contempt citation against Alice Goh is live.

00:36:46As long as there is legitimate legislative inquiry, then the inherent power of contempt by the Senate may be properly exercised.

00:36:53Conversely, Madam Chair, once the legislative inquiry concludes, the exercise of the inherent power of contempt ceases and there is no more genuine necessity to penalize the detained witness.

00:37:05I was about to ask that question, Madam Chair, before the Majority Leader made that statement of his intention.

00:37:14And it's also the intention of this representation to make a motion, Madam Chair, because the question will be, will Ms. Goh's presence here today not interfere with her pending cases in court?

00:37:27I would say no. And that is the position of this humble representation and we wanted also to know the position of this committee.

00:37:37Madam Chair, I don't think that the mere filing of a criminal complaint before a court should not automatically bar the conduct of legislative investigation.

00:37:49And Senator Ginggoy already knows this because Regis Romero II versus Senator Ginggoy Estrada were included in the decision.

00:37:59The power of legislative inquiry cannot be made subordinate to a criminal or administrative investigation.

00:38:07And so I remain steadfast with that position, Madam Chair, and let me place it into the records that we have jurisdiction, Madam Chair.

00:38:20Considering also that we were the first one who issued the warrant of arrest, Madam Chair.

00:38:25And last but not the least, before we start, I know everyone wanted to ask questions.

00:38:28I wanted to raise this and considering that we have Senator Francis Tolentino and Senator Rococo Pimentel with us here today.

00:38:36If you look at RA number 100660, this is an act strengthening further the functional and structural organization of the Sandigan Bayan, further amending Presidential Decree number 1606.

00:38:51It states there, Madam Chair, Section 5, if I'm not mistaken, Madam Chair, that the original trial court shall have exclusive original jurisdiction where the information does not allege any damage to the government or any bribery.

00:39:17Letter B, alleges damage to the government or bribery arising from the same closely related transactions or acts in amount not exceeding to one million pesos.

00:39:29So that's what happened. But Madam Chair, it should not be the Kapas Regional Trial Court but a different court should handle the case of Ms. Alice.

00:39:41Under Republic Act number 100660, Madam Chair, it states there that cases, and we talked about it on the sidelines with our minority leader.

00:39:53It says there, cases falling under the jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court under this section shall be tried in a judicial region other than where the official holds office.

00:40:07So I submit to the wisdom of this committee and again, I wanted to put that into the records. Thank you, Madam Chair.

00:40:15Thank you also, Sen. Joel. Of course, that is a substantive question already.

00:40:19So the question about the criminal jurisdiction, we will surely discuss it later in this hearing.

00:40:27But the predicates laid out for the motion that Majority Leader Sen. Francis and Sen. Joel will pass later,

00:40:37and as I said earlier, because the Senate was the first to issue a warrant in favor of Alice Guo and triggered manhunt for her,

00:40:47the Chair will welcome that motion and whatever will be the ruling of the Chair, it will be coordinated and it will be coordinated

00:40:57if this comes to the court which has jurisdiction of her detention at the moment.

00:41:04So thank you very much, colleagues, for this first round of exchanges.

00:41:11Comsec, please ask those who have not yet asked.

00:41:15May I request those who have not taken their oath during the previous hearings to please stand up, raise your right hand, and repeat after me.

00:41:28I, please state your name, do solemnly swear that I will tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, to this committee.

00:41:42Thank you. You may now take your seat.

00:41:46Thank you, Comsec.

00:41:48Ms. Sheila, I noticed that you swore again. I hope you don't need to because you already swore earlier.

00:41:56But you remain under oath, so that is fine.

00:41:58Alright, so I will start with the questions to Ms. Alice.

00:42:03So after months of evading the Senate, now you are here.

00:42:07You have answered the question of the whole truth to our committee

00:42:12because our committee properly treats those who tell the truth to us and respects our committee and the Senate.

00:42:23Did you understand that, Ms. Alice?

00:42:26Yes, Madam Chair.

00:42:28Alright, so can you finally confirm before this committee, are you the one who is swearing?

00:42:36And before you invoke the right against self-incrimination,

00:42:41you are not the one who filed your late registration of live birth, right?

00:42:46So you are not incriminating yourself.

00:42:49So are you the one who is swearing?

00:42:52Madam Chair, there are cases that were filed against me in court, so I cannot answer them to you now.

00:43:02I don't think my question has anything to do with your case,

00:43:07especially that there is evidence established by the NBI and another agency

00:43:12comparing the fingerprints of Guo Huaping and your fingerprints as Alice Guo,

00:43:18and they both said that they are the same person.

00:43:21So for your own sake and for the sake of our committee,

00:43:27just one last time on this very simple fundamental question,

00:43:31are you Guo Huaping?

00:43:34Madam Chair, I am not confirming.

00:43:37There are cases that were filed against me, and I will answer them to the court.

00:43:42Well, yes and no, one related question.

00:43:45May I invoke, Madam Chair, may I invoke?

00:43:47I am not going to invoke or raise a point of order,

00:43:50but may I invoke section 19 of our Senate rules,

00:43:54which states the privilege against self-incrimination.

00:43:56A witness can only invoke his right or her right to self-incrimination, Madam Chair, only,

00:44:03only when a question which tends to elicit an answer that will incriminate him or her is propounded to her.

00:44:13However, Madam Chair, the witness or the resource person may offer to answer any question in an executive session.

00:44:22So I would just like to invoke that, Madam Chair,

00:44:26because the chairperson already stated that it will not in any way incriminate her, Madam Chair.

00:44:32Just to put that on record.

00:44:34Thank you, Sen. Joel. Exactly.

00:44:36So again, what I told you earlier,

00:44:39you cannot incriminate just by asking who you are.

00:44:43And the addition, unless we ask for an executive session,

00:44:48we will move to another room so you can answer who you really are

00:44:55or the chair will ask all these people to come out for an executive session.

00:45:00And before I proceed, I would just like to recognize the presence of Sen. Loren.

00:45:05Thank you, Sen. Loren, for your invitation.

00:45:08Good morning, Madam Chair.

00:45:09Good morning.

00:45:11Ms. Alice, I would like to remind you that according to the Supreme Court,

00:45:16in the case of Office of the Court Administrator v. You,

00:45:20quote, the right to self-incrimination does not prohibit legitimate inquiry in non-criminal matters.

00:45:27So the question, who are you? Are you the perpetrator?

00:45:31That is not a criminal matter.

00:45:33That should not be cited in the case.

00:45:36Identity questions are within the purview of the committee.

00:45:40The Senate has a right to know who we are talking to.

00:45:44Is that the real person we are talking to or someone else?

00:45:47The Senate has the right to ascertain who the resource persons are,

00:45:52who you say that you are.

00:45:55Okay, I will just rephrase.

00:45:57Do you have something to say at this point, Ms. Alice?

00:45:59Yes, Madam Chair. I am Alice Goh.

00:46:01Well, we have already proven that you are not Alice Goh.

00:46:07You are the real Goh Huaping.

00:46:09It is not only the committee that came to this conclusion,

00:46:13but also the NBI and another agency.

00:46:16If you insist not to answer if you are Goh Huaping,

00:46:20I will rephrase my question.

00:46:22Your father is Goh Jianzong and your mother is Lin Wenyi. Is that correct?

00:46:29My father is Goh Jianzong, Madam Chair.

00:46:32And?

00:46:34And my mother is Lin Wenyi.

00:46:36Ms. Alice, you are reversing what you said in a previous hearing.

00:46:40You are listing this bank document because this is your bank document.

00:46:46You listed Lin Wenyi as your mother.

00:46:50So, it is reversed.

00:46:51And you falsified the bank document that you submitted in your statement that you are not Lin Wenyi's mother.

00:46:59You were born in China, not in Tarlac. Is that correct?

00:47:03As far as I know, I was born in Tarlac, Tarlac, Madam Chair.

00:47:07Your childhood, let's say from 0 to 12 years old, was in China. Is that correct?

00:47:13That is why you can't remember or tell us anything about your childhood in Tarlac, right?

00:47:20Madam Chair, I know this is your opening statement.

00:47:26He already gave an oath, but it is clear that he is lying about where he was born.

00:47:32So, I bring that to the body. It is just the opening and he is already lying.

00:47:37We all know that there are government agencies that gave birth certificates and they admitted the PSA to foreign countries and he is included in those.

00:47:47So, from the beginning, he insisted that he was forced to be born in Tarlac.

00:47:54No one will believe that. We already know that.

00:47:57So, I'm just putting that on record.

00:47:59How can we extract the truth if the first question, there is no question, is already a lie?

00:48:06Thank you, Sen Loren.

00:48:08So, thank you.

00:48:10And the emotion of the Majority Leader and Sen Joel is getting stronger and stronger at the proper time.

00:48:15Madam Chair, thank you.

00:48:17Yes, Sen Rafi, for one related question.

00:48:20On May 22, this year, I asked Alice Go, if she's willing to undergo a dye detector test.

00:48:30Until now, are you still okay, Ms. Alice Go?

00:48:33Are you still willing to undergo a dye detector test so that we can know what you said and we can report it to our people.

00:48:40Are you still willing?

00:48:42Ms. Alice.

00:48:44Madam Chair, can I consult first?

00:48:48Who will you consult?

00:48:50I will consult a lawyer first.

00:48:52All right, you can do that during this hearing.

00:48:54We will return to your question during this hearing.

00:48:57Madam Chair, this is related.

00:48:59Yes, Sen Joel, a related question.

00:49:01Very related. Madam Chair, obviously, in the Senate,

00:49:06there is still no consensus to speak the truth to us, Madam Chair.

00:49:14Your simple question earlier, Madam Chair, is she Gua Hua Ping?

00:49:19Even if she lied, she did not answer, whatever she said to us, Madam Chair,

00:49:26the NBI itself had fingerprints of Alice Go and Chinese National Gua Hua Ping.

00:49:33And a match was established between the same person, Gua Hua Ping and Alice Go.

00:49:43So the question is, Alice, do you believe in the match made by the NBI between Gua Hua Ping and Alice Go, i.e. one person?

00:50:01Yes.

00:50:03Ms. Alice.

00:50:05Madam Chair, honestly, I do not know how it happened to me.

00:50:10I know that I am Alice Go.

00:50:12And I am sorry if you do not believe what I am saying.

00:50:18As much as possible, I want to tell you all, and to those who will be your questions later,

00:50:26I will also take into consideration my own safety.

00:50:28Well, I will also ask you about your safety later.

00:50:34But it also means that all our questions now, because the time is short,

00:50:40your window of opportunity is closed, all our questions are for you to speak the truth

00:50:46and not to lie to this committee.

00:50:49Now, Ms. Alice.

00:50:51Madam Chair, short interjection.

00:50:53Yes, Senator Roy, for one related question.

00:50:55May I ask from the Chair if we can make it clear to him what is the safety consideration that he is saying?

00:51:03So that we can be clear.

00:51:05Because if he always invokes safety, we do not know what safety he is saying.

00:51:09If there is someone who is interested in his life, a big syndicate,

00:51:14that he will be silenced or what safety he is saying, Madam Chair?

00:51:20Ms. Alice, I will also ask you that later.

00:51:23But briefly, start by answering Senator Roy's question.

00:51:27What is the safety that he is saying?

00:51:29Sen, it's about my personal safety.

00:51:34Okay.

00:51:36What safety? What threat are you seeing?

00:51:41So that we can help you.

00:51:43There is a death threat.

00:51:45Who is the threat?

00:51:47I will not discuss this in public.

00:51:51Why don't you discuss it in public?

00:51:53The people ought to know about it.

00:51:56There is a death threat.

00:51:58Who is the threat to you and your life?

00:52:02If you don't want to answer now, Ms. Alice, you cannot escape that question.

00:52:07I will also ask you there.

00:52:09Madam Chair, I don't have a plan to escape the question.

00:52:14However, there is also a safety concern to me, a security concern, a death threat to me.

00:52:24That's why I cannot discuss it in public.

00:52:26Madam Chair.

00:52:28Sen SP Pro Temp.

00:52:30Ms. Alice, when you met Secretary Avalos, the first thing you said to Secretary Avalos was to help me because I have a death threat.

00:52:39Who is the threat to you?

00:52:41Answer it directly, Ms. Alice.

00:52:45Sen, I'm sorry, I cannot say it in public because I have a safety problem.

00:52:51Madam Chair, that answer is unacceptable.

00:52:55It is unacceptable, Sen.

00:52:57Sen Joel.

00:52:59It's like the whole committee is against his safety.

00:53:02We don't know if you are trying to fool us here.

00:53:05You will answer us like that when you have a death threat and you cannot say where your death threat came from.

00:53:15You cannot say if it's here in the Philippines or abroad.

00:53:17Ms. Alice, I'm reminding you, you never raised security concerns to the committee before.

00:53:24This is the only time you were arrested and transferred here.

00:53:26I will still ask you about the death threats that we just heard.

00:53:32Let me go back first.

00:53:34The prejudicial question for us is your identity.

00:53:38You entered the country as Guohuaping in 2003, correct?

00:53:43You were only 12 or 13 years old then, correct?

00:53:47Madam Chair, I don't have a record of that.

00:53:50Oh, speaking of records, have you ever had a Chinese passport?

00:53:54As far as I know, Madam Chair, I have a Filipino passport.

00:53:58Filipino passport.

00:54:01As far as we know, you had a Chinese passport.

00:54:04You just didn't renew it.

00:54:06It lapsed.

00:54:08So, Alice Guoh, alias Guohuaping, are you Filipino?

00:54:13Yes, I am Filipino, Madam Chair.

00:54:16Yes, and Lauren, for one related question.

00:54:19Thank you.

00:54:21Since you said that she has a Philippine passport,

00:54:27let's be fair.

00:54:29Who gave her the Philippine passport?

00:54:32Who issued her Philippine birth certificate?

00:54:36If you said that, we can protect you.

00:54:39If you told the truth, how did you become Filipino?

00:54:42How did you get the passport?

00:54:44Then, you're answering us properly.

00:54:47We can perhaps protect you.

00:54:49If you keep on lying to us,

00:54:51you will sink in a web of lies.

00:54:53We cannot protect you from the syndicates that are after you.

00:54:57I think just to answer that,

00:54:59how did she get her Philippine birth certificate

00:55:02from the PSA or the Satellite Office,

00:55:05and how she acquired her Philippine passport from the DFA?

00:55:09We have to find out the syndicates in the government agencies.

00:55:13Madam Chair, for the record,

00:55:14for the benefit of everyone,

00:55:16and this has already come out in the previous hearings,

00:55:20there is a birth certificate that was obtained

00:55:23through late registration of live birth,

00:55:25but the PSA,

00:55:27I'm sure that Engineer Grande will confirm this later, Engineer Mariza,

00:55:31the PSA itself said that the birth certificate is irregular.

00:55:35That's why they told the Office of the Solicitor General

00:55:39to cancel this.

00:55:40But apparently,

00:55:42while she was still holding that irregular birth certificate,

00:55:45she used it to obtain her Philippine passport.

00:55:48But as far as our committee knows,

00:55:51Ms. Alice, you obtained a Chinese passport.

00:55:55For all these questions so far,

00:55:58why don't you want to answer?

00:56:00There is no self-incriminating in these questions.

00:56:03You are only being asked,

00:56:05in fact, you are only being asked

00:56:07about your previous answers to the committee.

00:56:10About the previous documents that you submitted to the banks

00:56:13that we obtained.

00:56:15So please stop being evasive.

00:56:18Stop being evasive.

00:56:20Before this committee,

00:56:22we flashed again

00:56:24the dactyloscopy report of the NBI.

00:56:27Result of examination,

00:56:29after a thorough examination and analysis,

00:56:32fingerprints of Guo Huaping, Yilin,

00:56:35and fingerprints of Guo, Alice Ileal,

00:56:37were found identical.

00:56:38Opinion, NBI to,

00:56:40in view of the foregoing,

00:56:42fingerprints of Guo Huaping, Yilin,

00:56:44and fingerprints of Guo, Alice Ileal,

00:56:47were affixed by one and the same person.

00:56:50Isang tao lamang.

00:56:52Yan yung unang-unang tanong ko sa inyo,

00:56:54pero nagsinungaling pa rin kayo.

00:56:58Now, once and for all,

00:57:01Alice Guo, Alice Guo Huaping,

00:57:04I am giving you the opportunity

00:57:06to explain

00:57:08why you should not be cited in contempt

00:57:11for lying before this committee

00:57:14and for providing untruthful

00:57:17and evasive testimony.

00:57:20Huh, Miss Alice?

00:57:22Madam Chair,

00:57:24lumaki po ako,

00:57:26alam ko po ako ay po isang Filipino.

00:57:29One minute suspension.

00:57:31Pahingi po sa mga kasama na a quick,

00:57:33a quick,

00:57:34uh,

00:57:36Sen Rafi, if you will allow,

00:57:38I request you and all the colleagues,

00:57:40mag one minute suspension tayo,

00:57:42a quick discussion sa ating mga senador,

00:57:44kung maaari po.

00:57:46We are suspended for...

00:57:48Mabilis lang ito ko sana, Madam Chair.

00:57:50Please, Sen Rafi,

00:57:52and at least we need to take a one minute suspension.

00:57:54Yes, Sen Rafi.

00:57:56Malala ko sa previous hearings

00:57:58ng committee ninyo,

00:58:00nabanggit yung pangalan John Patrick Samson,

00:58:02na supposed to be fixer,

00:58:04facilitate yung pagkakuha ng

00:58:06late registration,

00:58:08birth certificate, hanggang passport

00:58:10ni Miss Alice Go'o.

00:58:12Bakit di po natin siya iniimbitahan?

00:58:14Salamat, Sen Rafi.

00:58:16Actually, iimbitahin natin si J.P. Samson

00:58:19sa susunod na pagdinig.

00:58:21Bahagi po siya ng tanong ko

00:58:23mamaya-maya sa ibang resource person natin.

00:58:25So let us...

00:58:27Last na po.

00:58:29Yes, please, last na and before we suspend for a minute.

00:58:31Noong last hearing,

00:58:32merong sinulat si Sheila Go'o

00:58:34sa papel na sabi niya, Secretary,

00:58:36hindi naman yun sa executive session.

00:58:38So pwede bang may divulge

00:58:40kung sino yung dalawang pangalan na sinulat

00:58:42na hindi nabanggit sa hearing ng mga senador?

00:58:44Mamaya po ay i-divulge din

00:58:46yung dalawang pangalan iyon.

00:58:48Pero meron na pong

00:58:50isang related resource person

00:58:52sa dalawang iyon na

00:58:54nandiritong ngayong araw

00:58:56at siguradong matatanong namin.

00:58:58Thank you, Madam Chair.

00:59:00I know we are going to suspend

00:59:02the deliberation

00:59:04and I already anticipating, Madam Chair,

00:59:06what is going to happen

00:59:08when we suspend the deliberation.

00:59:10And I'm just giving one chance

00:59:12again to Alice, Madam Chair,

00:59:14because this will help me decide

00:59:17as we suspend the hearing today

00:59:21to talk about your fate

00:59:23as a resource person.

00:59:25If it is true,

00:59:27Miss Alice, ako muna.

00:59:29Miss Alice, pakinggan po ang senador

00:59:31na matatanong.

00:59:33Sinasabi mo may death threat ka,

00:59:36pero ayaw mon sabihin

00:59:38kung saan ang gagaling yung death threat mo.

00:59:40Ni ayaw mon sabihin ba sa amin

00:59:42kung ito'y tawag o sulat o text?

00:59:44Kasi kung hindi,

00:59:46hindi katotoo nagsasabing may death threat ka.

00:59:49Miss Alice.

00:59:51Sen, magsasabi po ako,

00:59:53huwag lang po in public.

00:59:55May death threat ka ba?

00:59:57Meron po.

00:59:59Sabi mo, Executive Specialist.

01:00:01I will accept that, Madam Chair,

01:00:03but ang problem kasi is

01:00:05kung yung death threat na yan,

01:00:07totoo o hindi, Madam Chair,

01:00:09dahil ayaw talaga niya magsalita.

01:00:11I will yield, Madam Chair,

01:00:13to the wisdom of the committee.

01:00:15Salamat, Sen Joel.

01:00:17Atsaka ang hirap kasi,

01:00:19ang dami mo nang sinabing hindi totoo eh.

01:00:21Tapos babalik ka dito,

01:00:23magsasabi ka na naman

01:00:25isang malaking kwento,

01:00:27pinakamalaki so far, death threat.

01:00:29Kung mong ngalingan mo ngayon,

01:00:31may bago ka naman,

01:00:33gusto mong paniwalaan namin.

01:00:35So we will suspend for 1 minute

01:00:37and then resume after 1 minute.

01:00:39Hearing suspended.

01:01:00Patuloy na hindi direct ang pagsagot

01:01:02ni Dismissed Bamban Tarlac Mayor Alice Goh

01:01:05o kaya yung mga sinagot niya dati

01:01:07ay parang hindi pa rin nagbago.

01:01:09Doon sa mga sinasabi,

01:01:11kung siya ba talaga, si Alice Goh

01:01:13o si Guo Hua Ping?

01:01:15Possible sa mga ebidensya.

01:01:17Ang problema kasi nitong resource person nila

01:01:19na si Dismissed Bamban Mayor Goh

01:01:21eh na-establish na sa mga past hearings

01:01:23noong wala siya,

01:01:25na pinatunayan ng NBI

01:01:27at iba pang mga government agencies

01:01:29na hindi totoo.

01:01:31At ngayon, noong dumating siya,

01:01:33sinasabi niya hindi totoo.

01:01:35So yung past 2 hearings,

01:01:37or several hearings,

01:01:39sinasabi niya walang katotohanan.

01:01:41So kaya mataas yung emosyon ng mga senador.

01:01:43Sa mga nanonood siguro,

01:01:45pag sinabing 1 minute suspension,

01:01:47eh 1 minute, 1 senate minute suspension niya.

01:01:49Medyo mas matagal po ng konti.

01:01:51Pero mag-abang lang po kayo

01:01:53dahil possible matapos ka agad yan

01:01:55at mag-decision ka agad yung mga senador

01:01:57kung anong susunod na mangyayari

01:01:59ng mga senador?

01:02:01Sandra?

01:02:03Yes, Connie.

01:02:05Ngayon ang ongoing,

01:02:07nag-deliberate yung mga senador

01:02:09nag-uusap-usap sila.

01:02:11Dahil so far,

01:02:13doon sa mga initial questions

01:02:15dito kay Alice Goh,

01:02:17wala sila nakukuhang direct response

01:02:19gaya noong pagkatanong ko

01:02:21sa kanya identity,

01:02:23ko siya ba ay si Goh Joaquin.

01:02:25So ngayon nag-uusap-usap ang mga senador.

01:02:26Kung siya ay sa side team contempt

01:02:28at kung ganoon niya ang mangyayari,

01:02:30isa ba ay pwedeng ilagay

01:02:32o ikulong na rin

01:02:34kasama dito si Sheila Goh.

01:02:36Pero bukod diyan,

01:02:38ay sempre gusto rin ng mga senador

01:02:40na papangit nila sa ating kanina

01:02:42na mayroon silang makuha

01:02:44mula sa kanila ng informasyon.

01:02:46So talagang pikin ko

01:02:48ye-exhaust din nila yung mga pagkakataon

01:02:50para may makuha sila pa

01:02:52nakasanutan sa mga tanong.

01:02:54Isang pwedeng option diyan Connie

01:02:56sa Executive Decibel

01:02:58bukang yun yung pinapahihwati

01:03:00nito nga si Alice Goh.

01:03:02Pero sa ngayon,

01:03:04so far itong mga senador

01:03:06gusto nila makakuha ng sagot

01:03:08na paaring mapanood

01:03:10or marinig ng publiko.

01:03:12So yan ang pinag-uusapan ngayon dito sa ngayon.

01:03:27Sinabi niya na,

01:03:29yung mga possible questions

01:03:31na pupwede nilang tanungin

01:03:33na hindi naman incriminating on her part, Sandra.

01:03:35Pero gayon pa man,

01:03:37nakita natin talagang mailap

01:03:39sa pagsagot itong si Alice Goh.

01:03:41Upol pa rin dito.

01:03:43Unang-unang narinig natin,

01:03:45dinenye niya,

01:03:47na hindi nga daw si Guava Ping.

01:03:49Dinenye din niya na si Lynn Wen Yee,

01:03:51ang kanyang nanay.

01:03:53Marami pa siyang ibang mga sinasabi

01:03:54na may mga basihan din naman yung mga senador natin

01:03:56to begin with,

01:03:58ng mga dokumento na nagsasabi otherwise.

01:04:00Sa ating mga napapanood kasi Sandra,

01:04:02medyo sa aming TV screen,

01:04:04medyo nagpipigil pa yung mga senador.

01:04:06Pero dyan ba sa loob?

01:04:08Ano ba yung atmosphere?

01:04:10Pakidescribe kayo yung atmosphere dyan sa loob

01:04:12kung saan naroon ka ngayon.

01:04:14Yes, o, o.

01:04:16Dito mismo sa loob ng pagsagot.

01:04:18Nagtahimik na tahimik naman

01:04:20dahil na narito rin mismo

01:04:22nasuumpukan yung mga senador

01:04:24at habang na sila ay nakuumpukan,

01:04:26meron na mga sarili nga pag-uusap

01:04:28yung mga abogado ni Alice Kuo

01:04:30at nakikita natin

01:04:32na sa upuan pa rin naman niya

01:04:34itong CSC Lagoon.

01:04:36At iniintay lang yung group,

01:04:38magiging ruling nitong mga senador.

01:04:40Pero alam mo Raffy,

01:04:42ipa-ishare ko lang sa inyo,

01:04:44isang insight na nakuha natin

01:04:46sa isang abogado na narito rin ngayon,

01:04:48hindi ko nalang papanganahan.

01:04:50Walang manaking video,

01:04:51kasi Alice Kuo,

01:04:53kung siya ay ikonter

01:04:55at kung sakali mang kulin ng Senado

01:04:57yung custody.

01:04:59Pero siya ay nakahulong na rin naman

01:05:01sa abogado ng CSC

01:05:03at paka nga daw,

01:05:05mas maganda pa yung kwarto

01:05:07dito sa Senado.

01:05:09Kaya ang sinasabi ay

01:05:11handa itong si Alice Kuo

01:05:13kung sakali man siya ikokonter

01:05:15ng mga senador kung walang makikita

01:05:17sa kanya.

01:05:18So obviously handa siya

01:05:20dahil hindi nga siya nagpiansa

01:05:22so willy siya magpakulong talaga

01:05:24sa kustudian ng PNP.

01:05:26But in this case,

01:05:28kapag siya na side in contempt,

01:05:30automatic diyan siya ikukulong."

01:05:48... dahil nagpasindabi na sila sa korte

01:05:50para mapa-attempt si Alice Kuo dito,

01:05:52parang ang expectation ay

01:05:54magpapasindabi rin sila sa korte ulit

01:05:56kung ano man yung susunod pa nila

01:05:58ng ka-oblay dito kay Alice Kuo."

01:06:18... parang kine-question nila

01:06:20na dapat hindi daw nagkaroon ng korte

01:06:22doon sa kaso sa Tarlac mismo

01:06:24kung saan pinamumunuan dati ni Tarlac

01:06:26bambang na Mayor Alice Kuo."

01:06:28... yan ang binanggit ni Sen. Joe Welville

01:06:30at Sen. Raffi.

01:06:33"... talagang gustong insist ng mga senador

01:06:35na ang jurisdiction dapat nasa kanila

01:06:38kasi gusto nila ipakita rin

01:06:40yung kapangyarihan ng senador."

01:06:42... bumalik na Sandra,

01:06:44nagsimula na ulit,

01:06:45pakinggan natin itong papatuloy ng pagdinig ng Senado.

01:07:16... but in any case,

01:07:18gusto kong ipaalala sayo

01:07:20na ayon nga sa Supreme Court

01:07:22in the case of the Office of Court Administrator, VU,

01:07:25the right to self-incrimination

01:07:27does not prohibit legitimate inquiry

01:07:29in non-criminal matters."

01:07:31... Alice Kuo,

01:07:38ladies and gentlemen,

01:07:40is continuing to lie to this committee

01:07:42despite glaring evidence

01:07:43that she is a Chinese national

01:07:45named Guo Huaping

01:07:47whose father, Dian Zhongguo,

01:07:49is Chinese

01:07:51based on her own declaration in this committee

01:07:53and whose mother, Lin Wenyi,

01:07:55is also Chinese

01:07:57based on her own declarations in bank documents

01:07:59by the way verified by the AMLOC.

01:08:01This is a blatant defiance

01:08:03of the legislative's constitutional power of inquiry.

01:08:07...

01:08:14I move to cite Guo Huaping

01:08:16also known as Alice Kuo

01:08:18in contempt of the Senate

01:08:20for testifying falsely and evasively

01:08:22before this committee.

01:08:23Second to motion, Madam Chair.

01:08:25Thank you, Sen. Joe Welch.

01:08:27Madam Chair,

01:08:29when we were in recess kanina,

01:08:31the pending matter was the refusal

01:08:33to give us details

01:08:35of the death threats

01:08:37that she, herself,

01:08:39brought before us

01:08:41when we were in recess.

01:08:43...

01:08:44...

01:08:45...

01:08:46...

01:08:47...

01:08:48...

01:08:49...

01:08:50...

01:08:51...

01:08:52...

01:08:53...

01:08:54...

01:08:55...

01:08:56...

01:08:57...

01:08:58...

01:08:59...

01:09:00...

01:09:01...

01:09:02...

01:09:03...

01:09:04...

01:09:05...

01:09:06...

01:09:07...

01:09:08...

01:09:09...

01:09:10...

01:09:11...

01:09:12...

01:09:13...

01:09:14...

01:09:15...

01:09:16...

01:09:17...

01:09:18...

01:09:19...

01:09:20...

01:09:21...

01:09:22...

01:09:23...

01:09:24...

01:09:25...

01:09:26...

01:09:27...

01:09:28...

01:09:29...

01:09:30...

01:09:31...

01:09:32...

01:09:33...

01:09:34...

01:09:35...

01:09:36...

01:09:37...

01:09:38...

01:09:39...

01:09:40...

01:09:41...

01:09:42...

01:09:43...

01:09:44...

01:09:45...

01:09:46...

01:09:47...

01:09:48...

01:09:49...

01:09:50...

01:09:51...

01:09:52...

01:09:53...

01:09:54...

01:09:55...

01:09:56...

01:09:57...

01:09:58...

01:09:59...

01:10:00...

01:10:01...

01:10:02...

01:10:03...

01:10:04...

01:10:05...

01:10:06...

01:10:07...

01:10:08...

01:10:09...

01:10:10...

01:10:11...

01:10:12...

01:10:13...

01:10:14...

01:10:15...

01:10:16...

01:10:17...

01:10:18...

01:10:19...

01:10:20...

01:10:21...

01:10:22...

01:10:23...

01:10:24...

01:10:25...

01:10:26...

01:10:27...

01:10:28...

01:10:29...

01:10:30...

01:10:31...

01:10:32...

01:10:33...

01:10:34...

01:10:35...

01:10:36...

01:10:37...

01:10:38...

01:10:39...

01:10:40...

01:10:41...

01:10:42...

01:10:43...

01:10:44...

01:10:45...

01:10:46...

01:10:47...

01:10:48...

01:10:49...

01:10:50...

01:10:51...

01:10:52...

01:10:53...

01:10:54...

01:10:55...

01:10:56...

01:10:57...

01:10:58...

01:10:59...

01:11:00...

01:11:01...

01:11:02...

01:11:03...

01:11:04...

01:11:05...

01:11:06...

01:11:07...

01:11:08...

01:11:09...

01:11:10...

01:11:11...

01:11:12...

01:11:13...

01:11:14...

01:11:15...

01:11:16...

01:11:17...

01:11:18...

01:11:19...

01:11:20...

01:11:21...

01:11:22...

01:11:23...

01:11:24...

01:11:25...

01:11:26...

01:11:27...

01:11:28...

01:11:29...

01:11:30...

01:11:31...

01:11:32...

01:11:33...

01:11:34...

01:11:35...

01:11:36...

01:11:37...

01:11:38...

01:11:39...

01:11:40...

01:11:41...

01:11:42...

01:11:43...

01:11:44...

01:11:45...

01:11:46...

01:11:47...

01:11:48...

01:11:49...

01:11:50...

01:11:51...

01:11:52...

01:11:53...

01:11:54...

01:11:55...

01:11:56...

01:11:57...

01:11:58...

01:11:59...

01:12:00...

01:12:01...

01:12:02...

01:12:03...

01:12:04...

01:12:05...

01:12:06...

01:12:07...

01:12:08...

01:12:09...

01:12:10...

01:12:11...

01:12:12...

01:12:13...

01:12:14...

01:12:15...

01:12:16...

01:12:17...

01:12:18...

01:12:19...

01:12:20...

01:12:21...

01:12:22...

01:12:23...

01:12:24...

01:12:25...

01:12:26...

01:12:27...

01:12:28...

01:12:29...

01:12:30...

01:12:31...

01:12:32...

01:12:33...

01:12:34...

01:12:35...

01:12:36...

01:12:37...

01:12:38...

01:12:39...

01:12:40...

01:12:41...

01:12:42...

01:12:43...

01:12:44...

01:12:45...

01:12:46...

01:12:47...

01:12:48...

01:12:49...

01:12:50...

01:12:51...

01:12:52...

01:12:53...

01:12:54...

01:12:55...

01:12:56...

01:12:57...

01:12:58...

01:12:59...

01:13:00...

01:13:01...

01:13:02...

01:13:03...

01:13:04...

01:13:05...

01:13:06...

01:13:07...

01:13:08...

01:13:09...

01:13:10...

01:13:11...

01:13:12...

01:13:13...

01:13:14...

01:13:15...

01:13:16...

01:13:17...

01:13:18...

01:13:19...

01:13:20...

01:13:21...

01:13:22...

01:13:23...

01:13:24...

01:13:25...

01:13:26...

01:13:27...

01:13:28...

01:13:29...

01:13:30...

01:13:31...

01:13:32...

01:13:33...

01:13:34...

01:13:35...

01:13:36...

01:13:37...

01:13:38...

01:13:39...

01:13:40...

01:13:41...

01:13:42...

01:13:43...

01:13:44...

01:13:45...

01:13:46...

01:13:47...

01:13:48...

01:13:49...

01:13:50...

01:13:51...

01:13:52...

01:13:53...

01:13:54...

01:13:55...

01:13:56...

01:13:57...

01:13:58...

01:13:59...

01:14:00...

01:14:01...

01:14:02...

01:14:03...

01:14:04...

01:14:05...

01:14:06...

01:14:07...

01:14:08...

01:14:09...

01:14:10...

01:14:11...

01:14:12...

01:14:13...

01:14:14...

01:14:15...

01:14:16...

01:14:17...

01:14:18...

01:14:19...

01:14:20...

01:14:21...

01:14:22...

01:14:23...

01:14:24...

01:14:25...

01:14:26...

01:14:27...

01:14:28...

01:14:29...

01:14:30...

01:14:31...

01:14:32...

01:14:33...

01:14:34...

01:14:35...

01:14:36...

01:14:37...

01:14:38...

01:14:39...

01:14:40...

01:14:41...

01:14:42...

01:14:43...

01:14:44...

01:14:45...

01:14:46...

01:14:47...

01:14:48...

01:14:49...

01:14:50...

01:14:51...

01:14:52...

01:14:53...

01:14:54...

01:14:55...

01:14:56...

01:14:57...

01:14:58...

01:14:59...

01:15:00...

01:15:01...

01:15:02...

01:15:03...

01:15:04...

01:15:05...

01:15:06...

01:15:07...

01:15:08...

01:15:09...

01:15:10...

01:15:11...

01:15:12...

01:15:13...

01:15:14...

01:15:15...

01:15:16...

01:15:17...

01:15:18...

01:15:19...

01:15:20...

01:15:21...

01:15:22...

01:15:23...

01:15:24...

01:15:25...

01:15:26...

01:15:27...

01:15:28...

01:15:29...

01:15:30...

01:15:31...

01:15:32...

01:15:33...

01:15:34...

01:15:35...

01:15:36...

01:15:37...

01:15:38...

01:15:39...

01:15:40...

01:15:41...

01:15:42...

01:15:43...

01:15:44...

01:15:45...

01:15:46...

01:15:47...

01:15:48...

01:15:49...

01:15:50...

01:15:51...

01:15:52...

01:15:53...

01:15:54...

01:15:55...

01:15:56...

01:15:57...

01:15:58...

01:15:59...

01:16:00...

01:16:01...

01:16:02...

01:16:03...

01:16:04...

01:16:05...

01:16:06...

01:16:07...

01:16:08...

01:16:09...

01:16:10...

01:16:11...

01:16:12...

01:16:13...

01:16:14...

01:16:15...

01:16:16...

01:16:17...

01:16:18...

01:16:19...

01:16:20...

01:16:21...

01:16:22...

01:16:23...

01:16:24...

01:16:25...

01:16:26...

01:16:27...

01:16:28...

01:16:29...

01:16:30...

01:16:31...

01:16:32...

01:16:33...

01:16:34...

01:16:35...

01:16:36...

01:16:37...

01:16:38...

01:16:39...

01:16:40...

01:16:41...

01:16:42...

01:16:43...

01:16:44...

01:16:45...

01:16:46...

01:16:47...

01:16:48...

01:16:49...

01:16:50...

01:16:51...

01:16:52...

01:16:53...

01:16:54...

01:16:55...

01:16:56...

01:16:57...

01:16:58...

01:16:59...

01:17:00...

01:17:01...

01:17:02...

01:17:03...

01:17:04...

01:17:05...

01:17:06...

01:17:07...

01:17:08...

01:17:09...

01:17:10...

01:17:11...

01:17:12...

01:17:13...

01:17:14...

01:17:15...

01:17:16...

01:17:17...

01:17:18...

01:17:19...

01:17:20...

01:17:21...

01:17:22...

01:17:23...

01:17:24...

01:17:25...

01:17:26...

01:17:27...

01:17:28...

01:17:29...

01:17:30...

01:17:31...

01:17:32...

01:17:33...

01:17:34...

01:17:35...

01:17:36...

01:17:37...

01:17:38...

01:17:39...

01:17:40...

01:17:41...

01:17:42...

01:17:43...

01:17:44...

01:17:45...

01:17:46...

01:17:47...

01:17:48...

01:17:49...

01:17:50...

01:17:51...

01:17:52...

01:17:53...

01:17:54...

01:17:55...

01:17:56...

01:17:57...

01:17:58...

01:17:59...

01:18:00...

01:18:01...

01:18:02...

01:18:03...

01:18:04...

01:18:05...

01:18:06...

01:18:07...

01:18:08...

01:18:09...

01:18:10...

01:18:11...

01:18:12...

01:18:13...

01:18:14...

01:18:15...

01:18:16...

01:18:17...

01:18:18...

01:18:19...

01:18:20...

01:18:21...

01:18:22...

01:18:23...

01:18:24...

01:18:25...

01:18:26...

01:18:27...

01:18:28...

01:18:29...

01:18:30...

01:18:31...

01:18:32...

01:18:33...

01:18:34...

01:18:35...

01:18:36...

01:18:37...

01:18:38...

01:18:39...

01:18:40...

01:18:41...

01:18:42...

01:18:43...

01:18:44...

01:18:45...

01:18:46...

01:18:47...

01:18:48...

01:18:49...

01:18:50...

01:18:51...

01:18:52...

01:18:53...

01:18:54...

01:18:55...

01:18:56...

01:18:57...

01:18:58...

01:18:59...

01:19:00...

01:19:01...

01:19:02...

01:19:03...

01:19:04...

01:19:05...

01:19:06...

01:19:07...

01:19:08...

01:19:09...

01:19:10...

01:19:11...

01:19:12...

01:19:13...

01:19:14...

01:19:15...

01:19:16...

01:19:17...

01:19:18...

01:19:19...

01:19:20...

01:19:21...

01:19:22...

01:19:23...

01:19:24...

01:19:25...

01:19:26...

01:19:27...

01:19:28...

01:19:29...

01:19:30...

01:19:31...

01:19:32...

01:19:33...

01:19:34...

01:19:35...

01:19:36...

01:19:37...

01:19:38...

01:19:39...

01:19:40...

01:19:41...

01:19:42...

01:19:43...

01:19:44...

01:19:45...

01:19:46...

01:19:47...

01:19:48...

01:19:49...

01:19:50...

01:19:51...

01:19:52...

01:19:53...

01:19:54...

01:19:55...

01:19:56...

01:19:57...

01:19:58...

01:19:59...

01:20:00...

01:20:01...

01:20:02...

01:20:03...

01:20:04...

01:20:05...

01:20:06...

01:20:07...

01:20:08...

01:20:09...

01:20:10...

01:20:11...

01:20:12...

01:20:13...

01:20:14...

01:20:15...

01:20:16...

01:20:17...

01:20:18...

01:20:19...

01:20:20...

01:20:21...

01:20:22...

01:20:23...

01:20:24...

01:20:25...

01:20:26...

01:20:27...

01:20:28...

01:20:29...

01:20:30...

01:20:31...

01:20:32...

01:20:33...

01:20:34...

01:20:35...

01:20:36...

01:20:37...

01:20:38...

01:20:39...

01:20:40...

01:20:41...

01:20:42...

01:20:43...

01:20:44...

01:20:45...

01:20:46...

01:20:47...

01:20:48...

01:20:49...

01:20:50...

01:20:51...

01:20:52...

01:20:53...

01:20:54...

01:20:55...

01:20:56...

01:20:57...

01:20:58...

01:20:59...

01:21:00...

01:21:01...

01:21:02...

01:21:03...

01:21:04...

01:21:05...

01:21:06...

01:21:07...

01:21:08...

01:21:09...

01:21:10...

01:21:11...

01:21:12...

01:21:13...

01:21:14...

01:21:15...

01:21:16...

01:21:17...

01:21:18...

01:21:19...

01:21:20...

01:21:21...

01:21:22...

01:21:23...

01:21:24...

01:21:25...

01:21:26...

01:21:27...

01:21:28...

01:21:29...

01:21:30...

01:21:31...

01:21:32...

01:21:33...

01:21:34...

01:21:35...

01:21:36...

01:21:37...

01:21:38...

01:21:39...

01:21:40...

01:21:41...

01:21:42...

01:21:43...

01:21:44...

01:21:45...

01:21:46...

01:21:47...

01:21:48...

01:21:49...

01:21:50...

01:21:51...

01:21:52...

01:21:53...

01:21:54...

01:21:55...

01:21:56...

01:21:57...

01:21:58...

01:21:59...

01:22:00...

01:22:01...

01:22:02...

01:22:03...

01:22:04...

01:22:05...

01:22:06...

01:22:07...

01:22:08...

01:22:09...

01:22:10...

01:22:11...

01:22:12...

01:22:13...

01:22:14...

01:22:15...

01:22:16...

01:22:17...

01:22:18...

01:22:19...

01:22:20...

01:22:21...

01:22:22...

01:22:23...

01:22:24...

01:22:25...

01:22:26...

01:22:27...

01:22:28...

01:22:29...

01:22:30...

01:22:31...

01:22:32...

01:22:33...

01:22:34...

01:22:35...

01:22:36...

01:22:37...

01:22:38...

01:22:39...

01:22:40...

01:22:41...

01:22:42...

01:22:43...

01:22:44...

01:22:45...

01:22:46...

01:22:47...

01:22:48...

01:22:49...

01:22:50...

01:22:51...

01:22:52...

01:22:53...

01:22:54...

01:22:55...

01:22:56...

01:22:57...

01:22:58...

01:22:59...

01:23:00...

01:23:01...

01:23:02...

01:23:03...

01:23:04...

01:23:05...

01:23:06...

01:23:07...

01:23:08...

01:23:09...

01:23:10...

01:23:11...

01:23:12...

01:23:13...

01:23:14...

01:23:15...

01:23:16...

01:23:17...

01:23:18...

01:23:19...

01:23:20...

01:23:21...

01:23:22...

01:23:23...

01:23:24...

01:23:25...

01:23:26...

01:23:27...

01:23:28...

01:23:29...

01:23:30...

01:23:31...

01:23:32...

01:23:33...

01:23:34...

01:23:35...

01:23:36...

01:23:37...

01:23:38...

01:23:39...

01:23:40...

01:23:41...

01:23:42...

01:23:43...

01:23:44...

01:23:45...

01:23:46...

01:23:47...

01:23:48...

01:23:49...

01:23:50...

01:23:51...

01:23:52...

01:23:53...

01:23:54...

01:23:55...

01:23:56...

01:23:57...

01:23:58...

01:23:59...

01:24:00...

01:24:01...

01:24:02...

01:24:03...

01:24:04...

01:24:05...

01:24:06...

01:24:07...

01:24:08...

01:24:09...

01:24:10...

01:24:11...

01:24:12...

01:24:13...

01:24:14...

01:24:15...

01:24:16...

01:24:17...

01:24:18...

01:24:19...

01:24:20...

01:24:21...

01:24:22...

01:24:23...

01:24:24...

01:24:25...

01:24:26...

01:24:27...

01:24:28...

01:24:29...

01:24:30...

01:24:31...

01:24:32...

01:24:33...

01:24:34...

01:24:35...

01:24:36...

01:24:37...

01:24:38...

01:24:39...

01:24:40...

01:24:41...

01:24:42...

01:24:43...

01:24:44...

01:24:45...

01:24:46...

01:24:47...

01:24:48...

01:24:49...

01:24:50...

01:24:51...

01:24:52...

01:24:53...

01:24:54...

01:24:55...

01:24:56...

01:24:57...

01:24:58...

01:24:59...

01:25:00...

01:25:01...

01:25:02...

01:25:03...

01:25:04...

01:25:05...

01:25:06...

01:25:07...

01:25:08...

01:25:09...

01:25:10...

01:25:11...

01:25:12...

01:25:13...

01:25:14...

01:25:15...

01:25:16...

01:25:17...

01:25:18...

01:25:19...

01:25:20...

01:25:21...

01:25:22...

01:25:23...

01:25:24...

01:25:25...

01:25:26...

01:25:27...

01:25:28...

01:25:29...

01:25:30...

01:25:31...

01:25:32...

01:25:33...

01:25:34...

01:25:35...

01:25:36...

01:25:37...

01:25:38...

01:25:39...

01:25:40...

01:25:41...

01:25:42...

01:25:43...

01:25:44...

01:25:45...

01:25:46...

01:25:47...

01:25:48...

01:25:49...

01:25:50...

01:25:51...

01:25:52...

01:25:53...

01:25:54...

01:25:55...

01:25:56...

01:25:57...

01:25:58...

01:25:59...

01:26:00...

01:26:01...

01:26:02...

01:26:03...

01:26:04...

01:26:05...

01:26:06...

01:26:07...

01:26:08...

01:26:09...

01:26:10...

01:26:11...

01:26:12...

01:26:13...

01:26:14...

01:26:15...

01:26:16...

01:26:17...

01:26:18...

01:26:19...

01:26:20...

01:26:21...

01:26:22...

01:26:23...

01:26:24...

01:26:25...

01:26:26...

01:26:27...

01:26:28...

01:26:29...

01:26:30...

01:26:31...

01:26:32...

01:26:33...

01:26:34...

01:26:35...

01:26:36...

01:26:37...

01:26:38...

01:26:39...

01:26:40...

01:26:41...

01:26:42...

01:26:43...

01:26:44...

01:26:45...

01:26:46...

01:26:47...

01:26:48...

01:26:49...

01:26:50...

01:26:51...

01:26:52...

01:26:53...

01:26:54...

01:26:55...

01:26:56...

01:26:57...

01:26:58...

01:26:59...

01:27:00...

01:27:01...

01:27:02...

01:27:03...

01:27:04...

01:27:05...

01:27:06...

01:27:07...

01:27:08...

01:27:09...

01:27:10...

01:27:11...

01:27:12...

01:27:13...

01:27:14...

01:27:15...

01:27:16...

01:27:17...

01:27:18...

01:27:19...

01:27:20...

01:27:21...

01:27:22...

01:27:23...

01:27:24...

01:27:25...

01:27:26...

01:27:27...

01:27:28...

01:27:29...

01:27:30...

01:27:31...

01:27:32...

01:27:33...

01:27:34...

01:27:35...

01:27:36...

01:27:37...

01:27:38...

01:27:39...

01:27:40...

01:27:41...

01:27:42...

01:27:43...

01:27:44...

01:27:45...

01:27:46...

01:27:47...

01:27:48...

01:27:49...

01:27:50...

01:27:51...

01:27:52...

01:27:53...

01:27:54...

01:27:55...

01:27:56...

01:27:57...

01:27:58...

01:27:59...

01:28:00...

01:28:01...

01:28:02...

01:28:03...

01:28:04...

01:28:05...

01:28:06...

01:28:07...

01:28:08...

01:28:09...

01:28:10...

01:28:11...

01:28:12...

01:28:13...

01:28:14...

01:28:15...

01:28:16...

01:28:17...

01:28:18...

01:28:19...

01:28:20...

01:28:21...

01:28:22...

01:28:23...

01:28:24...

01:28:25...

01:28:26...

01:28:27...

01:28:28...

01:28:29...

01:28:30...

01:28:31...

01:28:32...

01:28:33...

01:28:34...

01:28:35...

01:28:36...

01:28:37...

01:28:38...

01:28:39...

01:28:40...

01:28:41...

01:28:42...

01:28:43...

01:28:44...

01:28:45...

01:28:46...

01:28:47...

01:28:48...

01:28:49...

01:28:50...

01:28:51...

01:28:52...

01:28:53...

01:28:54...

01:28:55...

01:28:56...

01:28:57...

01:28:58...

01:28:59...

01:29:00...

01:29:01...

01:29:02...

01:29:03...

01:29:04...

01:29:05...

01:29:06...

01:29:07...

01:29:08...

01:29:09...

01:29:10...

01:29:11...

01:29:12...

01:29:13...

01:29:14...

01:29:15...

01:29:16...

01:29:17...

01:29:18...

01:29:19...

01:29:20...

01:29:21...

01:29:22...

01:29:23...

01:29:24...

01:29:25...

01:29:26...

01:29:27...

01:29:28...

01:29:29...

01:29:30...

01:29:31...

01:29:32...

01:29:33...

01:29:34...

01:29:35...

01:29:36...

01:29:37...

01:29:38...

01:29:39...

01:29:40...

01:29:41...

01:29:42...

01:29:43...

01:29:44...

01:29:45...

01:29:46...

01:29:47...

01:29:48...

01:29:49...

01:29:50...

01:29:51...

01:29:52...

01:29:53...

01:29:54...

01:29:55...

01:29:56...

01:29:57...

01:29:58...

01:29:59...

01:30:00...

01:30:01...

01:30:02...

01:30:03...

01:30:04...

01:30:05...

01:30:06...

01:30:07...

01:30:08...

01:30:09...

01:30:10...

01:30:11...

01:30:12...

01:30:13...

01:30:14...

01:30:15...

01:30:16...

01:30:17...

01:30:18...

01:30:19...

01:30:20...

01:30:21...

01:30:22...

01:30:23...

01:30:24...

01:30:25...

01:30:26...

01:30:27...

01:30:28...

01:30:29...

01:30:30...

01:30:31...

01:30:32...

01:30:33...

01:30:34...

01:30:35...

01:30:36...

01:30:37...

01:30:38...

01:30:39...

01:30:40...

01:30:41...

01:30:42...

01:30:43...

01:30:44...

01:30:45...

01:30:46...

01:30:47...

01:30:48...

01:30:49...

01:30:50...

01:30:51...

01:30:52...

01:30:53...

01:30:54...

01:30:55...

01:30:56...

01:30:57...

01:30:58...

01:30:59...

01:31:00...

01:31:01...

01:31:02...

01:31:03...

01:31:04...

01:31:05...

01:31:06...

01:31:07...

01:31:08...

01:31:09...

01:31:10...

01:31:11...

01:31:12...

01:31:13...

01:31:14...

01:31:15...

01:31:16...

01:31:17...

01:31:18...

01:31:19...

01:31:20...

01:31:21...

01:31:22...

01:31:23...

01:31:24...

01:31:25...

01:31:26...

01:31:27...

01:31:28...

01:31:29...

01:31:30...

01:31:31...

01:31:32...

01:31:33...

01:31:34...

01:31:35...

01:31:36...

01:31:37...

01:31:38...

01:31:39...

01:31:40...

01:31:41...

01:31:42...

01:31:43...

01:31:44...

01:31:45...

01:31:46...

01:31:47...

01:31:48...

01:31:49...

01:31:50...

01:31:51...

01:31:52...

01:31:53...

01:31:54...

01:31:55...

01:31:56...

01:31:57...

01:31:58...

01:31:59...

01:32:00...

01:32:01...

01:32:02...

01:32:03...

01:32:04...

01:32:05...

01:32:06...

01:32:07...

01:32:08...

01:32:09...

01:32:10...

01:32:11...

01:32:12...

01:32:13...

01:32:14...

01:32:15...

01:32:16...

01:32:17...

01:32:18...

01:32:19...

01:32:20...

01:32:21...

01:32:22...

01:32:23...

01:32:24...

01:32:25...

01:32:26...

01:32:27...

01:32:28...

01:32:29...

01:32:30...

01:32:31...

01:32:32...

01:32:33...

01:32:34...

01:32:35...

01:32:36...

01:32:37...

01:32:38...

01:32:39...

01:32:40...

01:32:41...

01:32:42...

01:32:43...

01:32:44...

01:32:45...

01:32:46...

01:32:47...

01:32:48...

01:32:49...

01:32:50...

01:32:51...

01:32:52...

01:32:53...

01:32:54...

01:32:55...

01:32:56...

01:32:57...

01:32:58...

01:32:59...

01:33:00...

01:33:01...

01:33:02...

01:33:03...

01:33:04...

01:33:05...

01:33:06...

01:33:07...

01:33:08...

01:33:09...

01:33:10...

01:33:11...

01:33:12...

01:33:13...

01:33:14...

01:33:15...

01:33:16...

01:33:17...

01:33:18...

01:33:19...

01:33:20...

01:33:21...

01:33:22...

01:33:23...

01:33:24...

01:33:25...

01:33:26...

01:33:27...

01:33:28...

01:33:29...

01:33:30...

01:33:31...

01:33:32...

01:33:33...

01:33:34...

01:33:35...

01:33:36...

01:33:37...

01:33:38...

01:33:39...

01:33:40...

01:33:41...

01:33:42...

01:33:43...

01:33:44...

01:33:45...

01:33:46...

01:33:47...

01:33:48...

01:33:49...

01:33:50...

01:33:51...

01:33:52...

01:33:53...

01:33:54...

01:33:55...

01:33:56...

01:33:57...

01:33:58...

01:33:59...

01:34:00...

01:34:01...

01:34:02...

01:34:03...

01:34:04...

01:34:05...

01:34:06...

01:34:07...

01:34:08...

01:34:09...

01:34:10...

01:34:11...

01:34:12...

01:34:13...

01:34:14...

01:34:15...

01:34:16...

01:34:17...

01:34:18...

01:34:19...

01:34:20...

01:34:21...

01:34:22...

01:34:23...

01:34:24...

01:34:25...

01:34:26...

01:34:27...

01:34:28...

01:34:29...

01:34:30...

01:34:31...

01:34:32...

01:34:33...

01:34:34...

01:34:35...

01:34:36...

01:34:37...

01:34:38...

01:34:39...

01:34:40...

01:34:41...

01:34:42...

01:34:43...

01:34:44...

01:34:45...

01:34:46...

01:34:47...

01:34:48...

01:34:49...

01:34:50...

01:34:51...

01:34:52...

01:34:53...

01:34:54...

01:34:55...

01:34:56...

01:34:57...

01:34:58...

01:34:59...

01:35:00...

01:35:01...

01:35:02...

01:35:03...

01:35:04...

01:35:05...

01:35:06...

01:35:07...

01:35:08...

01:35:09...

01:35:10...

01:35:11...

01:35:12...

01:35:13...

01:35:14...

01:35:15...

01:35:16...

01:35:17...

01:35:18...

01:35:19...

01:35:20...

01:35:21...

01:35:22...

01:35:23...

01:35:24...

01:35:25...

01:35:26...

01:35:27...

01:35:28...

01:35:29...

01:35:30...

01:35:31...

01:35:32...

01:35:33...

01:35:34...

01:35:35...

01:35:36...

01:35:37...

01:35:38...

01:35:39...

01:35:40...

01:35:41...

01:35:42...

01:35:43...

01:35:44...

01:35:45...

01:35:46...

01:35:47...

01:35:48...

01:35:49...

01:35:50...

01:35:51...

01:35:52...

01:35:53...

01:35:54...

01:35:55...

01:35:56...

01:35:57...

01:35:58...

01:35:59...

01:36:00...

01:36:01...

01:36:02...

01:36:03...

01:36:04...

01:36:05...

01:36:06...

01:36:07...

01:36:08...

01:36:09...

01:36:10...

01:36:11...

01:36:12...

01:36:13...

01:36:14...

01:36:15...

01:36:16...

01:36:17...

01:36:18...

01:36:19...

01:36:20...

01:36:21...

01:36:22...

01:36:23...

01:36:24...

01:36:25...

01:36:26...

01:36:27...

01:36:28...

01:36:29...

01:36:30...

01:36:31...

01:36:32...

01:36:33...

01:36:34...

01:36:35...

01:36:36...

01:36:37...

01:36:38...

01:36:39...

01:36:40...

01:36:41...

01:36:42...

01:36:43...

01:36:44...

01:36:45...

01:36:46...

01:36:47...

01:36:48...

01:36:49...

01:36:50...

01:36:51...

01:36:52...

01:36:53...

01:36:54...

01:36:55...

01:36:56...

01:36:57...

01:36:58...

01:36:59...

01:37:00...

01:37:01...

01:37:02...

01:37:03...

01:37:04...

01:37:05...

01:37:06...

01:37:07...

01:37:08...

01:37:09...

01:37:10...

01:37:11...

01:37:12...

01:37:13...

01:37:14...

01:37:15...

01:37:16...

01:37:17...

01:37:18...

01:37:19...

01:37:20...

01:37:21...

01:37:22...

01:37:23...

01:37:24...

01:37:25...

01:37:26...

01:37:27...

01:37:28...

01:37:29...

01:37:30...

01:37:31...

01:37:32...

01:37:33...

01:37:34...

01:37:35...

01:37:36...

01:37:37...

01:37:38...

01:37:39...

01:37:40...

01:37:41...

01:37:42...

01:37:43...

01:37:44...

01:37:45...

01:37:46...

01:37:47...

01:37:48...

01:37:49...

01:37:50...

01:37:51...

01:37:52...

01:37:53...

01:37:54...

01:37:55...

01:37:56...

01:37:57...

01:37:58...

01:37:59...

01:38:00...

01:38:01...

01:38:02...

01:38:03...

01:38:04...

01:38:05...

01:38:06...

01:38:07...

01:38:08...

01:38:09...

01:38:10...

01:38:11...

01:38:12...

01:38:13...

01:38:14...

01:38:15...

01:38:16...

01:38:17...

01:38:18...

01:38:19...

01:38:20...

01:38:21...

01:38:22...

01:38:23...

01:38:24...

01:38:25...

01:38:26...

01:38:27...

01:38:28...

01:38:29...

01:38:30...

01:38:31...

01:38:32...

01:38:33...

01:38:34...

01:38:35...

01:38:36...

01:38:37...

01:38:38...

01:38:39...

01:38:40...

01:38:41...

01:38:42...

01:38:43...

01:38:44...

01:38:45...

01:38:46...

01:38:47...

01:38:48...

01:38:49...

01:38:50...

01:38:51...

01:38:52...

01:38:53...

01:38:54...

01:38:55...

01:38:56...

01:38:57...

01:38:58...

01:38:59...

01:39:00...

01:39:01...

01:39:02...

01:39:03...

01:39:04...

01:39:05...

01:39:06...

01:39:07...

01:39:08...

01:39:09...

01:39:10...

01:39:11...

01:39:12...

01:39:13...

01:39:14...

01:39:15...

01:39:16that the birth certificate is irregular. That's why it's being cancelled in the Office of the Solicitor General.

01:39:24And then if I may just finish, Sen. Rafi, before recognizing Majority Leader and then Sen. Rafi,

01:39:31that's why the Philippine passport was obtained. I will just recognize at this point now Majority Leader and then Sen. Rafi

01:39:41and then the Chair will continue the questioning. And then each, in order of arrival, beginning with the SP Pro Temp

01:39:48and the Senate Minority Leader, Sen. Jowel et al., will have 15 minutes each per round.

01:39:54We can go to a second round if there's still time. So, Sen., I mean, Majority Leader.

01:39:59Madam Chair, just an addendum to your earlier order, citing in contempt Ms. Alice Go.

01:40:08May the Committee Secretariat be likewise directed at this instant using the fastest means of communications

01:40:19to inform Branch 109 of the Regional Trial Court based in Capa, Starlak of the said citation, Madam Chair.

01:40:30Thank you, Majo. Comsec, please do that. And please include in the communication to the good court

01:40:38what the Chair said earlier in the citation in contempt to Alice Go. That this committee will coordinate with the court ordering her detention.

01:40:48So we will coordinate with that court.

01:40:51And lastly, Madam Chair, just in that particular communication to the court, we also would like to put into the records

01:41:00how much we appreciate, Madam Chair, the confirmation of the court and the respect of the court to this committee

01:41:12to allow Gua Hua Ping to appear before us, Madam Chair. Because we wanted to put that into the records, Madam Chair.

01:41:19Thank you, Sen. Jowell. Yes, the whole committee and the Chair appreciates the request of the judge

01:41:27to allow Alice Go. or Gua Hua Ping to appear and speak to our committee.

01:41:36That's why the committee put on record the citation in contempt to Alice Go.

01:41:43And as a result, we will coordinate with the court because this is what ordered her detention.

01:41:50So Sen. Rafi and then the Chair will continue with her question.

01:41:53Thank you, Madam Chair. She's been very evasive from the get-go.

01:41:56It's like we're wasting our time arguing and it's her right not to speak and to lie.

01:42:01What's important to me here is that the syndicate is growing while we're talking here, as Sen. Loren said.

01:42:09That's what I'm trying to point out, Madam Chair.

01:42:13As mentioned in the previous hearing, the person who is eligible to obtain a birth certificate through late registration,

01:42:22we need to find out who is eligible to obtain a birth certificate through late registration in the local registrar's office in Tarlac,

01:42:36who is eligible to obtain a birth certificate, who is the mayor at that time, who is the chief of the local registrar's office,

01:42:43and how many Chinese nationals in the town of Tarlac were given a Filipino birth certificate through late registration.

01:42:55This is a big problem Madam Chair.

01:42:58There are only 1,200 in Davao del Sur.

01:43:03The foreign nationals who were given a Filipino birth certificate became instant Filipino citizens.

01:43:09Not only in Davao del Sur, but in other places in the country.

01:43:15Then the immigration itself admitted that every single year since 2000, they were caught by Chinese nationals who entered or left the country using a Filipino passport.

01:43:32We're not doing anything about it.

01:43:35For decades, nobody's doing something to break up that syndicate.

01:43:43This is it. If we don't talk about this and focus on one topic, the syndicate will expand until such time,

01:43:54we might wake up and take over by Chinese nationals. Thank you Madam Chair.

01:43:58Thank you. Thank you Sen Rafi. We will pursue those points during your question time.

01:44:04Alice, I will continue with your questions.

01:44:08There are many photos of you with Duan Ren Wu.

01:44:13This character has been identified as the big boss of the POGO in Porac.

01:44:18I am interested to know if your associates in POGO are also your associates in the media.

01:44:26Did Duan Ren Wu help you escape?

01:44:31Madam Chair, no.

01:44:33Well, if he didn't help you, it's time to set the record straight.

01:44:41Who helped you to escape to the Philippines?

01:44:47How did you escape?

01:44:51Madam Chair, my only concern is my safety.

01:44:56That is not my question, Ms. Alice.

01:44:59I am not asking you the same question that Ms. Sendoroy asked you.

01:45:05I am asking how did you escape to the Philippines, Ms. Alice?

01:45:14Madam Chair, we escaped by boat.

01:45:19By boat. Okay. How did you escape by boat?

01:45:23I heard that you escaped by a yacht. Is that correct?

01:45:32Yes.

01:45:33Ah, so you used a yacht.

01:45:37Yes, we used a yacht.

01:45:39Okay. At least it's clear. It's not just a small boat, big boat, very big boat. Yacht.

01:45:45Madam Chair, who is the...

01:45:47Yes, SB Pro Temp. Who owns the yacht?

01:45:51Madam Chair, I don't know who owns the yacht.

01:45:56Ms. Alice, actually, SB Pro Temp, this is the question to McLaren.

01:46:02First, you don't remember who let you borrow the yacht.

01:46:05It's impossible to let you borrow an expensive car, especially an expensive boat, a yacht,

01:46:11that you don't know about and escape to the country.

01:46:16The question of SB Pro Temp, who owns the yacht?

01:46:20And where did you ride the yacht? What was your route?

01:46:26Sen, I really don't know who owns the yacht.

01:46:31That is impossible. Okay. We should have cited you in contempt.

01:46:36Unbelievable, the answers.

01:46:38Madam Chair, with the permission of Sen Pro Temp,

01:46:43if you don't know whose yacht you used,

01:46:47at least you know who facilitated you to ride that yacht. Who?

01:46:54Sen, is it okay if I don't discuss it with you?

01:46:59No. No, it is not okay, Ms. Alice.

01:47:02I'm afraid. I can't say it.

01:47:04No, no, no. Who facilitated?

01:47:07The question of Sen Pro Temp, who facilitated you to use the yacht?

01:47:12Madam Chair, I really want to say it, but I can't say it to the public.

01:47:18Write it down on a piece of paper and send it to us, Senators.

01:47:23Write it down on a piece of paper, who owns the yacht and who facilitated you to ride the yacht.

01:47:30I'm not sure who owns it and who facilitated it.

01:47:35It doesn't matter. Write down their names on a piece of paper so we can read it.

01:47:42Go ahead.

01:47:47Atty. David, you better tell your client to tell the truth and allow her to write in paper the owner of the yacht.

01:48:00Ms. Alice, write it down. The paper is there.

01:48:04Where did you ride the yacht, Alice? What port?

01:48:16Ms. Alice, where did you ride the yacht and what was your route?

01:48:19Sen, if I write it down, is it okay if you don't discuss it with the public?

01:48:24Ms. Alice, please do not tell the Senators what to do with the information.

01:48:29We need to tear it to shreds. Write it on the paper and we will appreciate it when we read it.

01:48:39Unbelievable. Other witnesses need to answer verbally.

01:48:43We will allow you to write it down on paper. Please do that now.

01:48:47Other witnesses already did that in the last hearing. Please write it down on paper.

01:48:52Please write down the port where you rode the yacht.

01:48:56Please write it down on paper.

01:49:05Ms. Alice, our patience is running out. Please write it down.

01:49:10We understand you and we know what you're afraid of, the death threat you're talking about.

01:49:17You don't want to say it.

01:49:18Now, it's simpler. Write down who owns and facilitates the yacht and tell us where you rode it.

01:49:26Sen, I really want to discuss it.

01:49:29So you want to say it to us. You're getting on my nerves.

01:49:34You're getting on my nerves.

01:49:37And Ms. Alice, you're under the custody of the PNP.

01:49:41How can you be killed there? It's impossible.

01:49:44You are within the most protective institution in our country.

01:49:48You are in the national headquarters of the Philippine National Police in Camp Krami.

01:49:52Yes.

01:49:53Write down who owns and facilitates the yacht.

01:49:55Yes, Madam Chair. I know I'm safe now.

01:49:59But I'm worried about what will happen to me after the hearing.

01:50:05Let's take it one day at a time. One step at a time.

01:50:08First step, write down on paper who owns and facilitates the yacht.

01:50:15Madam Chair, I hope that Alice's lawyers will be united with us.

01:50:26Although you have a deal with your client, what we are investigating here is a syndicate.

01:50:32As Mr. Turtul said, this syndicate has been here for a long time.

01:50:36We cannot go there. There's no solution to this investigation if we cannot reach the syndicate.

01:50:43So now, if we cannot get information here...

01:50:47You will continue to watch Alice Guo's face in the hearing of the Senate on the issues of POGO

01:50:54in the live stream of the social media accounts of GMA Integrated News.

01:50:58This is Balitang Hali and we are part of a bigger mission.

01:51:01I am Connie Sison.

01:51:02Graffiti Mapo for a wider service to the country.

01:51:05From GMA Integrated News, the news authority of the Philippines.

01:51:10We will help each other because our country is in danger.

01:51:14Not only Alice Guo. Alice Guo, you can protect the PNP.

01:51:19You will not die there. So please cooperate for the Philippines.

01:51:25I hope the Philippines will get better.

01:51:27Those syndicates happened.

01:51:39For those abroad, follow us on GMA Pinoy TV and www.gmanews.tv.

Category

Transcript

Recommended