Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa Ka Justice Mansoor Ali Shah Ke Khat Ka Jawab. .. Court Reporters
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00The letter and then the reply to the letter. Complaint and then the reply to the complaint.
00:04Something like this is happening in the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
00:07Today we saw that Chief Justice Qazi Faizisah gave a detailed answer to Mansoor Ali Shah's letter.
00:13Chief Justice Qazi Faizisah said in his letter that according to the law,
00:17you cannot question which judge the Chief Justice should include in the committee.
00:22I have always been a advocate of accountability and transparency.
00:25It was said in the letter that Justice Yahya Afridi was asked to be included in the committee,
00:29but he apologized for the judges being included in the committee.
00:32I will provide the reasons why Justice Muneeb Akhtar was changed.
00:36Remember that I am doing this on your insistence so that no one gets upset.
00:41Chief Justice Pakistan has given 11 reasons why Justice Muneeb Akhtar should not be included in the committee.
00:47Practice and Procedure Act says that urgent cases will be settled in 14 days,
00:52but Justice Muneeb Akhtar refused to listen to urgent legal cases.
00:59Justice Muneeb Akhtar strongly opposed the Practice and Procedure Act.
01:03Justice Muneeb Akhtar did not care about the burden of the cases and completely ignored the heat.
01:09Justice Muneeb Akhtar behaved impolitely and inappropriately with the senior judges.
01:16Justice Muneeb Akhtar works from 11 am to 11 pm.
01:20Justice Muneeb Akhtar's fellow judges complained about his behavior.
01:24Justice Muneeb Akhtar did not allow the case to be closed by issuing an appeal on the case of Audio Leaks.
01:31I am sure that you will be included in the committee for the public while considering the matter.
01:37On your side, your words cannot change the facts.
01:48Justice Muneeb Akhtar did not care about the burden of the cases and completely ignored the heat.
01:53Justice Muneeb Akhtar did not care about the burden of the cases and completely ignored the heat.
01:56On your side, your words cannot change the facts.
01:59On your side, your words cannot change the facts.
02:05On your side, your words cannot change the facts.
02:08On your side, your words cannot change the facts.
02:13In the past, you have covered this issue in great detail.
02:17In the past, you have covered this issue in great detail.
02:23In the past, you have covered this issue in great detail.
02:29In the past, you have covered this issue in great detail.
02:32When Justice Qazi Faisal was Justice, he wrote a lot of letters against him.
02:42Recently, Chief Justice Umar Atta Bandyal also wrote a lot of letters against him.
02:47Recently, Chief Justice Umar Atta Bandyal also wrote a lot of letters against him.
02:50This letter issue is mostly from this era.
02:53In the last 2-3 years, you can say 4 years, this issue has come up.
02:57Is this a new normal?
02:59Is this a new normal?
03:01No, it is not a new normal.
03:03The reason for this is that Justice Mansoor Ali Shah's letter was about Supreme Court Practices and Procedures Act.
03:13The reason for this is that Justice Mansoor Ali Shah's letter was about Supreme Court Practices and Procedures Act.
03:17It is better to have an audience on the judicial side.
03:24It is better to have an audience on the judicial side.
03:26I think this was a good suggestion from him.
03:28I think this was a good suggestion from him.
03:30But Chief Justice Qazi Faisal did not like this letter.
03:32But Chief Justice Qazi Faisal did not like this letter.
03:34But if you put such allegations on Chief Justice Qazi Faisal, he will answer them.
03:40But if you put such allegations on Chief Justice Qazi Faisal, he will answer them.
03:42If he does not answer, people will think that these allegations are true.
03:46In fact, on Friday, 20th or 19th September, the Federal Cabinet receives an ordinance.
03:52The Federal Cabinet receives an ordinance.
03:54Then the President is sent to the court.
03:56The President signs the papers.
03:58Then a Gazette notification is issued.
04:00Then the Supreme Court goes to the court.
04:02Then the Supreme Court practices.
04:04After that, the committee is called for a hearing.
04:06These were not normal things.
04:08These were not normal things.
04:10All this activity happened within 4-5 hours.
04:12I think these questions are created by this.
04:14I think these questions are created by this.
04:16The judges sitting in the court also think what is happening.
04:18The judges sitting in the court also think what is happening.
04:20On Friday, this committee has been changed.
04:22On Friday, this committee has been changed.
04:24In this, Chief Justice has said one more thing.
04:26In this, Chief Justice has said one more thing.
04:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
04:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:20The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:22The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:24The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:26The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
05:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:20The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:22The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:24The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:26The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
06:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:20The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:22The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:24The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:26The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
07:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:20The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:22The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:24The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:26The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
08:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:20The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:22The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:24The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:26The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
09:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:20The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:22The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:24The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:26The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:28The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:30The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:32The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:34The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:36The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:38The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:40The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:42The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:44The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:46The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:48The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:50The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:52The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:54The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:56The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
10:58The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:00The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:02The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:04The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:06The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:08The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:10The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:12The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:14The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:16The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:18The letter that had reached us before it reached the journalists,
11:20It is legally valid that when the practice and procedure law comes,
11:22It is legally valid that when the practice and procedure law comes,
11:24then all the judges who are bound to follow that law,
11:26then all the judges who are bound to follow that law,
11:28they have already taken the oath that they will obey the constitution
11:30they have already taken the oath that they will obey the constitution
11:32and will follow the law.
11:34When the law says that in 14 days,
11:36an urgent hearing application comes,
11:38you file an early hearing on Nazir-e-Shani,
11:40you file an early hearing on Nazir-e-Shani,
11:42you have to complete it in 14 days.
11:44So when the law is saying this,
11:46So when the law is saying this,
11:48and you have to follow that law,
11:50and you have to follow that law,
11:52then when you do not follow it,
11:54then questions will arise.
11:56As far as I was talking about,
11:58As far as I was talking about,
12:00Muneeb Akhtar asked in the hearing of the Judicial Commission,
12:02Muneeb Akhtar asked in the hearing of the Judicial Commission,
12:04and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:06and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:08and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:10and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:12and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:14and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:16and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:18and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:20and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:22and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:24and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:26and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:28and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:30and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:32and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:34and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:36and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:38and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:40and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:42and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:44and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:46and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:48and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:50and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:52and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:54and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:56and the Attorney General did not answer.
12:58and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:00and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:02and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:04and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:06and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:08and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:10and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:12and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:14and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:16and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:18and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:20and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:22and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:24and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:26and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:28and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:30and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:32and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:34and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:36and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:38and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:40and the Attorney General did not answer.
13:42and the Attorney General did not answer.