#Suriya #Kanguva #SiruthaiSiva #GnanavelRaja #CommercialHero #ContentHero #CommercialMovies #ContentMovies #FilmibeatTamil
~PR.268~PR.53~HT.302~CA.76~ED.256~##~
~PR.268~PR.53~CA.76~ED.256~HT.302~##~
~PR.268~PR.53~HT.302~CA.76~ED.256~##~
~PR.268~PR.53~CA.76~ED.256~HT.302~##~
Category
ЁЯЧЮ
NewsTranscript
00:00Even if we take Surya's career as an example, commercial films have given him a lot of success.
00:04Commercial films have created a fan following for him as a hero in front of the audience.
00:15You said that he became famous as a commercial hero.
00:17But I don't agree with that.
00:19Even though he became famous as a commercial hero,
00:21Surya became known as a good actor among the people because of his content films.
00:25His first successful film is the film Nandha Therai.
00:31We can ignore Surya's content films.
00:33He started with Nandha Therai.
00:34He did Vidhaamagam.
00:35The films that he made in the middle are all commercial films.
00:38Peralagan, Gajnilal.
00:39The films that he made with a lot of effort.
00:41We can ignore all of them.
00:47Kanguva is not a commercial film.
00:49It is a science fiction film.
00:50We can say that it is a content film.
00:52We can't say that Kanguva is a content film.
00:54Because when we see the trailer of the film...
00:56But we can't say that it is a commercial film.
00:58If he didn't make a commercial film,
01:01he would have given a budget of 300 crores for the production.
01:09When the film 24 was released, he made an experimental film.
01:12But that film was a hit.
01:14Yes, it was a hit.
01:15Even though it was an experimental film, it was a commercial film.
01:18It was a film made with commercial elements.
01:20It is different to make an experimental film.
01:22But if he made a content film,
01:24I wonder if he would have had this kind of success.
01:28KANGUVA
01:37Welcome to the show, Ennama Anga Satham.
01:40This week, Kanguva is making a lot of noise.
01:43Kanguva has been making a lot of noise for the past 2-3 weeks.
01:46They have given a lot of hype.
01:48Not only in Tamil Nadu, but also in India.
01:51We have a question regarding this situation.
01:53If we take Surya's films,
01:55On one hand, he makes commercial films.
01:56On the other hand, he makes content films.
01:58Kanguva is releasing a big pan-India film.
02:02We can say that he is going to become a pan-India hero.
02:05Will Surya continue to make content films as a result of his growth?
02:10Or do you think it is better to go for a commercial track?
02:12I would say it is a commercial film.
02:14If we take Surya's career as a commercial film,
02:17Commercial films have given him a lot of success.
02:20If he has created a fan following for the audience,
02:24Then it is a commercial film.
02:26Only if he makes a commercial film,
02:28He can reach the audience.
02:30If he wants to be a successful actor,
02:33If he wants to be a successful hero in the industry,
02:37Then it has to be a commercial film.
02:39Because as an actor,
02:41You can give that performance in a commercial film.
02:43Even before this,
02:45Even in commercial films,
02:47Even in the film,
02:49His acting was good.
02:51That film was a commercial hit.
02:54So there is scope for acting in a commercial film.
02:57But there is also growth for him.
03:00If we take this as acting or content related,
03:06It won't reach all the audiences.
03:09It will only reach a specific audience.
03:12In a large scale,
03:14In a mass scale,
03:16His audience will let him down.
03:19I have a different opinion on this.
03:22You said that he became famous as a commercial hero.
03:25But I don't agree with that.
03:27Even though he became famous as a commercial hero,
03:29He became known as a good actor.
03:31That is his content film.
03:33His first successful film was Nandha Therai.
03:35It was a huge success.
03:37He and Bala did it together.
03:39Before that,
03:41Surya, who was a chocolate hero,
03:43Changed to another level.
03:45Through that,
03:47Surya's father, Sivakumar,
03:49He gave him a great acting.
03:51He didn't have any opening songs.
03:53He didn't have any commercial items.
03:55We will know how Bala's films are.
03:57He proved himself like that.
03:59His first successful film was Nandha.
04:01Surya became a content hero.
04:03But for a hero to grow,
04:05Commerciality is important.
04:07But Surya's nickname is
04:09Nadippu Arakkan.
04:11Nadippu Asuran.
04:13Nadippu Nayakan.
04:15Surya's performance says it all.
04:17Even though he did commercial films,
04:19I think his track
04:21will go towards content.
04:23I think it will be a strong support
04:25for his future.
04:27He does commercial films.
04:29But when it comes to content,
04:31He did a film called Nandha.
04:33It earned him a lot of fame.
04:35After that,
04:37He got a recognition.
04:39That's true.
04:41But he did a commercial
04:43content-related film
04:45If he had done a content-oriented film,
04:47He wouldn't have reached
04:49where he is today.
04:51That's true.
04:53If he wanted to do
04:55a content-oriented film,
04:57He could have done
04:59small messages in commercial films.
05:01We have seen a lot of films.
05:03Be it Vijay's or Rajini's films,
05:05They are all commercial films.
05:07But there are small messages
05:09in those films.
05:11It could be about politics.
05:13Let's do it that way.
05:15Why should it be content-oriented?
05:17That's the question.
05:19He has set a stage.
05:21By making that stage a content-oriented film,
05:23What kind of stories will he choose?
05:25Because,
05:27Can you see a person who
05:29used to be a commercial hero
05:31as a content-oriented film?
05:33No.
05:35I would say yes.
05:37Even if Surya goes towards
05:39commercial films,
05:41It is his performance.
05:43We can count Surya's content films
05:45from his fingers.
05:47Nandhala, Pithamangal,
05:49Smiles in the middle,
05:51Perelagun, Gajini,
05:53We can also include his
05:55self-sacrificed characters.
05:57Surya's Vrittukal, Jai Bheem,
05:59These films created a huge impact.
06:01On the other hand,
06:03We can count Surya's Vrittukal
06:05from his fingers.
06:07If you take a commercial film,
06:09We can find a Tamil Nadu actor,
06:11Nandha's film.
06:13We can find a supporting actor,
06:15Pithamangal's film.
06:17So, even if we count his Vrittukal,
06:19We can see that he didn't
06:21give commercial films for his acting.
06:23He gave content films.
06:25Not just the people,
06:27The entire industry
06:29sees him as a performer.
06:31He is a pan-India hero.
06:33Kanguva is not a commercial film.
06:35It is a science fiction film.
06:37We can't take Kanguva as a commercial film.
06:43If we don't take it as a commercial film,
06:45We would have given him a budget
06:47of 300 crores.
06:49Kanguva is a big budget film
06:51in Surya's career.
06:53They see it as a commercial success.
06:55Only if it is a commercial success,
06:57Let it be the producer,
06:59Let it be Surya,
07:01Let it be the director,
07:03Everyone sees it as a market.
07:05Not only that,
07:07The main reason for giving so much attention
07:09is because of Surya's acting.
07:11Even if he does commercial films,
07:13With such a big budget,
07:15He is a pan-India star.
07:17His films are released
07:19in so many languages.
07:21Beyond Tamil Nadu,
07:23If he has a big fan following,
07:25It is doubtful.
07:27That is why,
07:29When we see this trailer,
07:31The audience,
07:33To attract the audience of other states,
07:35They have added small elements.
07:37When we see the trailer,
07:39One thing is clear,
07:41It should not be a film
07:43only for the Tamil Nadu audience.
07:45It should attract the Telugu audience,
07:47Malayalam audience,
07:49North Indian audience.
07:51That is the element they are looking for.
07:53We cannot say it is content oriented.
07:55When 24 films were released,
07:57He did it as an experimental film.
07:59But that film was a hit.
08:01Even if it was an experimental film,
08:03It was a commercial film.
08:05It was an experimental film.
08:07But if it was a content oriented film,
08:09Would it have been a success?
08:11That is the question.
08:13On the other hand,
08:15Whether it is a commercial film or a content film,
08:17We will know only after the release.
08:19Surya's career was shot in a big budget.
08:21We accept that it is a big budget film.
08:23They are releasing it at the pan-India level.
08:25Now I have a doubt.
08:27You are saying that Surya can be a commercial film.
08:29A commercial film is different for each state.
08:31If a Telugu film is a commercial film,
08:33Our audience won't accept it.
08:35If a Telugu film is commercialized here,
08:37The Telugu audience won't like it.
08:39To give a commercial film to all the audiences,
08:41He is trying to do it as a pan-India star.
08:43In this situation,
08:45It is very difficult to give a commercial film
08:47that everyone likes.
08:49But if it is a content oriented film,
08:51There will be similar problems in all the states of India.
08:53How did JB become a hit?
08:55How did Surya become a hit?
08:57How did JB become a hit?
08:59JB is a big hit not only in Tamil Nadu,
09:01but also in the whole of India.
09:03Surya is giving such a performance in that film.
09:05To give a commercial pan-India hit,
09:07It is my idea to give it as a content.
09:09If we look at the content wise,
09:11If they are shooting it as a content,
09:13If it is a Tamil Nadu based content,
09:15Will it reach the Tamil Nadu audience?
09:17Or will it create a big impact?
09:19We don't know.
09:21For example,
09:23If it is a Tamil Nadu based content,
09:25For example,
09:27If we take the film Meiyazhagan.
09:29Many people like the film
09:31But people who live in the city
09:33They don't get the connection.
09:35If we make the film as a pan-India based content,
09:37How many people will be able to watch the film?
09:39There is a possibility for it to become a pan-India-based film.
09:41There is a possibility for it to become a pan-India-based film.
09:47In that case,
09:49if we do it as a commercial content,
09:51Will it reach the Tamil Nadu audience?
09:53If we take a commercial film, there are a lot of fans of Balaiah's films here in Tamil Nadu.
09:58Balaiah's commercial...
10:00They watch it only to troll in Tamil Nadu.
10:03It becomes a hit then.
10:05He has a fan following.
10:07There is a fan base for Telugu films here.
10:09Commercial elements...
10:11Surya does a lot of commercial films.
10:15That is what will make it easy for him to reach pan India beyond Tamil Nadu.
10:20There is a doubt if the content will reach all the states.
10:25For example, Meiyalagan...
10:27Did the people here have an opinion on it?
10:30Did it reach them?
10:32I think there are two things.
10:34We can't compare Meiyalagan with this.
10:36Surya's content is different.
10:38Meiyalagan is a feel-good film.
10:40We can't compare it with that.
10:42It doesn't suit the audience in the city.
10:44But Surya's portrayal of JB...
10:46It is a problem that affects all the states of India.
10:51That will connect easily.
10:53On the other hand, you said Surya is a commercial hero.
10:56Surya is a commercial hero.
10:58We can accept that.
10:59But if you ask me if he has used a commercial hero properly,
11:02I don't think so.
11:03If he has used it properly,
11:05he would have reached the top of Vijay Arjun's fan base.
11:08But he didn't fully commit to it.
11:11He didn't want to get stuck in the commercial hero pattern.
11:14He didn't want to get stuck in that.
11:16That's why he keeps making content films.
11:19This is the drawback.
11:21First of all,
11:23did he make the right decision on the track?
11:26If we are going to travel commercially,
11:29we should make commercial films.
11:31If we are going to make content-oriented films,
11:34acting-oriented films,
11:36we should have taken a track like that.
11:39Even before this,
11:41there were many actors in the film industry.
11:44Rajini, Vijay, etc.
11:46They are all making commercial films.
11:49If we take Kamal Haasan's films,
11:52he keeps trying different things.
11:55There is nothing that he doesn't try.
11:58But is he as successful as Kamal Haasan?
12:01Is he considered as a commercial hero?
12:04I don't think so.
12:06He should have taken a track.
12:08I think that's the drawback.
12:10You mentioned Kamal Haasan.
12:12Kamal Haasan is a pioneer.
12:14Surya's inspiration is Kamal Haasan.
12:17Not only Surya,
12:19even Dhanush is an inspiration.
12:21You can take Dhanush's films.
12:23He changes from one side to the other.
12:25Suddenly, he makes content-oriented films.
12:28We can say that he is a commercial hero.
12:31Rajini, Vijay, Ajith are all commercial heroes.
12:34If we take content films,
12:37Kamal Haasan, Surya, Vikram, Dhanush, etc.
12:40are all commercial heroes.
12:42They don't limit themselves to commercial films.
12:45They have to make other content films.
12:48They have to prove themselves in acting.
12:51I think Surya is an important hero in that.
12:54You mentioned Kamal, Vikram, Dhanush.
12:57They all have different styles of acting.
13:00But if we take Vikram,
13:02Vikram is also an actor.
13:04He has to play different roles.
13:07But in films like Dhool and Dil,
13:10if he had given the same kind of films,
13:13his hit list would have increased.
13:16He would have been in a different place.
13:19Vikram himself answered this question.
13:22I can make films like Dhool and Dil,
13:25but I don't want to.
13:27I can act well,
13:29but I don't want to be an actor.
13:32I can act well,
13:34but I don't want to be an actor.
13:37Vikram said this in a recent interview.
13:40Surya, Vikram, Dhanush, Kamal, etc.
13:43are the same category.
13:45They don't just entertain people.
13:48They have to give good films to people.
13:51They have to do it for the audience.
13:54Surya, even if he does more commercial films,
13:57he has to give importance to content films.
14:00His content films are what made him an actor.
14:03In my opinion,
14:05if we take Surya's list of films that he missed,
14:08compared to his current stage,
14:11he would have been in the top 4.
14:14He has missed a lot of films.
14:17Vasanth's Aasai film,
14:20that was also mentioned to him.
14:23But he said he wasn't interested in acting.
14:26He has missed a lot of films.
14:30If he had acted in these films,
14:33he would have been in the commercial top 4.
14:36If someone like him comes into the industry,
14:39he wouldn't have come with the idea
14:42of giving only content films.
14:45He would have wanted commercial success.
14:48He would have wanted to be in a stage.
14:51He could have made films that would have helped him.
14:54That's my opinion.
14:57We have discussed our opinion.
15:00You who are watching this video,
15:03whether Surya should continue his journey as a commercial hero,
15:06or as a content hero,
15:09should he make films like this?