Aduna usa ka driver sa garbage truck ang giingong nag-drive nga hubog.

SunStar Philippines

Nganong ngitngit ang Tabunok Flyover ug ang Mananga Bridge?  Aduna usa ka driver sa garbage truck ang giingong nag-drive nga hubog.  Sa laing bahin, unsa nay mahitabo sa ordinansa sa Dakbayan sa Sugbo sa pag-livestream sa bidding nga gi-veto man ni Mayor Mike Rama?  Kining tanan atong hisgutan karon sa Beyond the Headlines.

Transcript

00:00:00 (dramatic music)

00:00:02 (dramatic music)

00:00:05 (dramatic music)

00:00:08 (dramatic music)

00:00:26 (dramatic music)

00:00:28 (dramatic music)

00:00:46 (dramatic music)

00:00:49 (dramatic music)

00:00:53 (dramatic music)

00:00:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:09 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:22 Happy Press Freedom Week.

00:01:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:35 (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:39 Okay, so Luigi, aside one week celebration

00:01:52 so press freedom, (speaking in foreign language)

00:01:57 followers (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:14 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:33 (crowd chattering)

00:02:36 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:41 (crowd chattering)

00:02:45 (crowd chattering)

00:02:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:02:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:12 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:31 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:35 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:40 (crowd chattering)

00:03:46 (speaking in foreign language)

00:03:50 (crowd chattering)

00:03:54 (crowd chattering)

00:03:57 (crowd chattering)

00:04:01 (crowd chattering)

00:04:06 (crowd chattering)

00:04:21 (crowd chattering)

00:04:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:04:30 (speaking in foreign language)

00:04:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:04:46 (crowd chattering)

00:04:55 (crowd chattering)

00:05:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:05:14 (dramatic music)

00:05:38 (speaking in foreign language)

00:05:42 - The number you have dialed is incorrect.

00:06:02 The number you have dialed is incorrect.

00:06:04 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:08 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:12 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:41 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:45 (speaking in foreign language)

00:06:49 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:08 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:07:58 - But that one was exclusive to South Coastal Road.

00:08:00 (speaking in foreign language)

00:08:04 That project was for the entire stretch

00:08:07 of the South Coastal Road.

00:08:09 (speaking in foreign language)

00:08:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:08:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:08:26 (phone ringing)

00:08:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:08:52 - Hello?

00:09:11 (speaking in foreign language)

00:09:15 (speaking in foreign language)

00:09:19 - Oh, yes, ma'am?

00:09:24 - Yes, sir.

00:09:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:09:29 - Hello?

00:09:44 (speaking in foreign language)

00:09:48 Sir, 917.

00:09:49 (speaking in foreign language)

00:09:54 - Hello, engineer?

00:10:03 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:11 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:15 - Hello?

00:10:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:51 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:55 (speaking in foreign language)

00:10:59 (speaking in foreign language)

00:11:03 (speaking in foreign language)

00:11:07 (speaking in foreign language)

00:11:35 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:04 - So it's been two years.

00:12:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:09 - Ah, yes.

00:12:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:34 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:45 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:12:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:03 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:07 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:11 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:15 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:19 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:32 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:49 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:53 (speaking in foreign language)

00:13:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:14 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:41 (speaking in foreign language)

00:14:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:04 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:32 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:39 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:43 (speaking in foreign language)

00:15:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:16:15 (speaking in foreign language)

00:16:44 (speaking in foreign language)

00:16:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:16:52 (speaking in foreign language)

00:16:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:07 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:14 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:19 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:23 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:17:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:03 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:11 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:15 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:19 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:23 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:32 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:52 (speaking in foreign language)

00:18:56 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:00 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:08 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:43 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:51 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:55 (speaking in foreign language)

00:19:59 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:23 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:43 (speaking in foreign language)

00:20:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:21:15 (speaking in foreign language)

00:21:19 (speaking in foreign language)

00:21:30 (speaking in foreign language)

00:21:36 (speaking in foreign language)

00:21:40 (upbeat music)

00:21:54 (upbeat music)

00:21:57 (upbeat music)

00:21:59 (upbeat music)

00:22:02 (upbeat music)

00:22:04 (upbeat music)

00:22:07 (upbeat music)

00:22:10 (upbeat music)

00:22:18 (upbeat music)

00:22:30 (upbeat music)

00:22:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:22:51 (speaking in foreign language)

00:22:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:46 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:55 (speaking in foreign language)

00:23:59 (speaking in foreign language)

00:24:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:24:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:24:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:24:30 (speaking in foreign language)

00:24:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:09 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:45 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:49 (speaking in foreign language)

00:25:53 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:12 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:38 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:26:49 (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:09 So that means if the bidding will be aired live,

00:27:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:20 then the other government units,

00:27:22 the other local governments (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:25 have already violated the Data Privacy Act.

00:27:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:31 When you bid for government projects,

00:27:34 (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:27:41 Always of committing irregularity.

00:28:00 (speaking in foreign language)

00:28:03 Out in the open,

00:28:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:28:09 (speaking in foreign language)

00:28:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:28:37 Will they override?

00:28:51 (speaking in foreign language)

00:28:55 (phone ringing)

00:28:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:29:02 That is the process.

00:29:08 The question, will the council override the veto?

00:29:12 (speaking in foreign language)

00:29:17 (phone ringing)

00:29:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:29:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:29:31 (speaking in foreign language)

00:29:46 (speaking in foreign language)

00:29:48 So, Canisha, September 18th, today, September 18th,

00:29:53 so some officials had hoped to livestream

00:29:57 the bidding process in Cebu City

00:29:58 in the spirit of transparency and accountability,

00:30:02 but they didn't take into account the existing laws

00:30:06 that would be broken if the proposal was passed,

00:30:10 according to Mayor Michael Rama.

00:30:12 In a letter sent to the council dated September 5, 2023,

00:30:17 vetoed the measure authored by Councilor Ray Guillen,

00:30:20 which members of the city council approved in August 16.

00:30:23 This was approved, according to Councilor Guillen,

00:30:27 this was approved unanimously, so all 18.

00:30:30 Called livestreaming of the bidding process

00:30:32 of the Bids and Awards Committee of the City of Cebu,

00:30:35 it stipulated that the whole bidding process,

00:30:38 the pre-procurement conference, the pre-bid conference,

00:30:41 and the opening of bids would be livestreamed

00:30:44 from start to finish on the city's social media platforms,

00:30:48 such as YouTube and Facebook,

00:30:51 and on its official website.

00:30:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:30:55 That the measure violates Data Privacy Act of 2012,

00:30:59 supersedes the implementing rules and regulations

00:31:04 of the Government Procurement Reform Act

00:31:07 and compromises the general welfare clause

00:31:10 provided under the local government court.

00:31:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:31:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:31:38 - Bids and awards?

00:31:39 (speaking in foreign language)

00:31:42 In that case, in Ana Madigan Transparent,

00:31:45 what's the difference of airing it live?

00:31:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:31:49 What's the difference of including the public

00:31:52 (speaking in foreign language)

00:31:56 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:00 - Two COA and two members of a non-government organization

00:32:25 of which appointed by the local government unit.

00:32:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:32 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:36 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:40 - Or organizations, NGOs.

00:32:41 But even despite in Ana process,

00:32:44 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:53 (speaking in foreign language)

00:32:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:09 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:17 - It's a portal where in all contractors,

00:33:41 every time you do business with government,

00:33:43 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:51 (speaking in foreign language)

00:33:55 (speaking in foreign language)

00:34:24 - One of these days,

00:34:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:34:29 Rama's veto killed the ordinance intention

00:34:47 for transparency and accountability.

00:34:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:34:55 - The same clause the mayor used to reject the ordinance.

00:34:59 (speaking in foreign language)

00:35:03 Rama said the ordinance would have ended up

00:35:05 violating the bidder's right to privacy

00:35:08 as their personal and sensitive pieces of information

00:35:11 embedded in their technical, financial,

00:35:13 and other related documents would be read out loud

00:35:16 during the opening of their bids.

00:35:18 - But when you read out the technical details,

00:35:20 these same details are on the Philadelphia website.

00:35:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:35:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:35:32 - Pre-conference, during the entire bidding process,

00:35:35 (speaking in foreign language)

00:35:39 What if (speaking in foreign language)

00:35:56 for 100 million road project?

00:35:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:12 - Four years.

00:36:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:23 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:31 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:35 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:40 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:44 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:51 (speaking in foreign language)

00:36:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:37:07 (phone ringing)

00:37:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:37:18 - The general welfare clause (speaking in foreign language)

00:37:23 is the same clause I relied upon as author

00:37:28 to uphold the primordial right of the people to know.

00:37:31 Precisely, Mayor Mike, the people have to know.

00:37:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:37:41 You just close off the bidding to just two representatives

00:37:46 from COA and from non-government organizations.

00:37:49 (speaking in foreign language)

00:37:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:37:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:10 Let us know.

00:38:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:32 We also educate our public (speaking in foreign language)

00:38:54 as far as government projects is concerned.

00:38:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:39:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:39:05 I don't see why we should keep the bidding process secret.

00:39:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:39:18 This is the same tax payers money we're using.

00:39:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:39:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:39:30 (speaking in foreign language)

00:39:34 How long they've been in the business

00:39:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:05 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:29 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:38 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:40:56 Freedom of information.

00:40:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:41:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:41:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:41:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:41:30 Bidded in their technical, financial,

00:41:32 and other related documents would be read out loud

00:41:36 during the opening of their bids.

00:41:38 He said the individuals have yet to enter

00:41:40 into any contract with the city government.

00:41:43 (speaking in foreign language)

00:41:47 Thus, the subject ordinance clearly runs counter

00:41:59 and anathema to the explicit provisions

00:42:03 as well as the spirit intent and purpose

00:42:06 of the data privacy of 2012.

00:42:08 Consequently, it is also prejudicial

00:42:10 to the welfare of the bidders.

00:42:12 Wait, no.

00:42:14 Why would it be prejudicial?

00:42:15 I mean, again, you're entering into a contract

00:42:19 that will use people's money,

00:42:21 and therefore your information should be out there

00:42:23 in the open.

00:42:23 (speaking in foreign language)

00:42:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:42:31 No.

00:42:32 Yeah, but if you go to city hall,

00:42:33 you cannot just ask that document,

00:42:36 especially now with the freedom of information

00:42:39 ordinance now by clarifying IRR.

00:42:41 (speaking in foreign language)

00:42:45 This is a very strong word, anathema.

00:42:50 When you say anathema, excommunicable.

00:42:53 (speaking in foreign language)

00:42:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:07 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:26 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:30 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:38 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:41 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:46 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:55 (speaking in foreign language)

00:43:59 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:04 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:08 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:12 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:44 We have the right, we have the right to know.

00:44:47 So I just hope, maybe (speaking in foreign language)

00:44:52 Councilor Gellon, who is the father of this ordinance.

00:45:00 (speaking in foreign language)

00:45:12 I just hope (speaking in foreign language)

00:45:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:45:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:45:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:45:39 Which we really support of its transparency

00:45:42 and accountability in spirit.

00:45:44 What will happen now?

00:45:45 Well, as it stands now, considering that the mayor

00:45:51 already vetoed it, and it was passed during

00:45:54 the regular session as one of the items in the agenda.

00:45:58 And the Sanggunian really noted it,

00:46:00 meaning there was no intention on the part

00:46:03 of the Sanggunian to override the mayor's veto

00:46:06 by two-thirds vote, despite the fact

00:46:09 (speaking in foreign language)

00:46:13 Considering I am only one of the members

00:46:23 of the Sanggunian, which is a collegial body,

00:46:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:46:29 Okay, so (speaking in foreign language)

00:46:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:46:41 What happened to the council?

00:46:49 When you unanimously voted it, and you believe

00:46:53 on the spirit of the ordinance,

00:46:55 then all (speaking in foreign language)

00:46:58 is just a veto of the mayor, saying it violated

00:47:01 the Data Privacy Act, and then (speaking in foreign language)

00:47:06 Is the city council a rubber stamp of Mayor Mike?

00:47:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:47:18 And I have always lobbied for the greater cause

00:47:22 of the Cebuanos.

00:47:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:47:28 Platform of governance of this administration

00:47:46 has always been on transparency and accountability.

00:47:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:47:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:47:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:11 Inasmuch as I want to fight for it, Madam,

00:48:13 but (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:18 I mean.

00:48:26 (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:30 (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:34 If you are not a rubber stamp,

00:48:55 then (speaking in foreign language)

00:48:58 What is stopping you then from trying to rally

00:49:01 the city council behind you to override the veto?

00:49:04 If you are one in mind and spirit,

00:49:07 you believe in this ordinance, (speaking in foreign language)

00:49:12 I was not expecting in the first place

00:49:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:49:20 I have also consulted with my staff,

00:49:28 (speaking in foreign language)

00:49:33 issue on data privacy.

00:49:34 When one joins a public bidding,

00:49:39 (speaking in foreign language)

00:49:42 data privacy under several provisions,

00:49:45 government procurement reform act.

00:49:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:49:52 Public.

00:49:53 (speaking in foreign language)

00:49:56 legal capacity (speaking in foreign language)

00:50:01 unofficial leave, sir.

00:50:11 (speaking in foreign language)

00:50:15 I was not able to speak out about it, sir.

00:50:23 (speaking in foreign language)

00:50:27 (speaking in foreign language)

00:50:39 to the members of the city council.

00:50:41 (speaking in foreign language)

00:50:46 I believe on that regular session,

00:50:48 (speaking in foreign language)

00:50:52 I can speak for the legal position,

00:50:59 which I have relied upon on a basis.

00:51:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:51:06 I will stand on what I've believed

00:51:12 was a legal right for me to do,

00:51:15 and morally right for me to do, ma'am.

00:51:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:51:44 Yes, ma'am, official leave, ma'am, on that Wednesday.

00:51:47 (speaking in foreign language)

00:51:51 Good luck to transparency.

00:51:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:51:58 What's the chance that the ordinance

00:52:00 will be introduced?

00:52:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:52:08 (speaking in foreign language)

00:52:12 So it's considered dead and good.

00:52:21 Deads now, in a way.

00:52:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:52:26 (speaking in foreign language)

00:52:30 Supposedly, you're filing a new version

00:52:35 where we're gonna assign FOI.

00:52:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:52:41 Counselor.

00:52:43 (laughing)

00:52:45 (speaking in foreign language)

00:52:53 We're urging the office of the mayor

00:52:55 to assign information officers

00:53:00 in the departments.

00:53:03 (speaking in foreign language)

00:53:07 (speaking in foreign language)

00:53:11 List of exceptions.

00:53:13 (speaking in foreign language)

00:53:17 (speaking in foreign language)

00:53:21 (speaking in foreign language)

00:53:25 (speaking in foreign language)

00:53:28 Okay, so now if we wanted to request some documents,

00:53:54 we can direct the FOI officers, correct?

00:53:57 (speaking in foreign language)

00:54:02 (speaking in foreign language)

00:54:06 (speaking in foreign language)

00:54:10 So for example, (speaking in foreign language)

00:54:34 (speaking in foreign language)

00:54:38 Yes, ma'am, yes, ma'am.

00:54:44 (speaking in foreign language)

00:54:47 Was it March?

00:54:55 Yes, yes, ma'am.

00:54:56 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:00 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:04 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:08 We are 18 members in the council, ma'am.

00:55:19 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:33 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:37 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:43 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:54 (speaking in foreign language)

00:55:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:02 Thank you, Kaiser.

00:56:03 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:07 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:29 And unanimously, all 18 councillors

00:56:32 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:36 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:40 violate the data privacy

00:56:46 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:56:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:02 It so happened (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:12 Councillor Gellon, who is the father

00:57:17 of the ordinance on official leave.

00:57:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:24 (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:28 So what happened?

00:57:35 Technically, (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:39 transparency and accountability.

00:57:41 (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:45 (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:57:54 We're so happy that all of our council members were one.

00:58:01 Once and for all, (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:04 For transparency.

00:58:05 And then all of a sudden,

00:58:06 not a single soul to override the veto.

00:58:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:11 I don't know.

00:58:12 (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:16 (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:20 (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:26 What were you doing there?

00:58:36 Were you really, (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:38 Were you really one?

00:58:39 Were you really one spirit?

00:58:40 (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:41 You really believed in it?

00:58:42 (speaking in foreign language)

00:58:46 Anyway, today is World Water Monitoring Day,

00:59:01 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:04 September 18th month.

00:59:05 Yeah, so it's a reminder that water monitoring

00:59:07 is as important as water itself.

00:59:10 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:14 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:18 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:22 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:26 Eventually, we'll be paying for the price

00:59:50 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:54 Yes, so (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:56 Appeals of World Water Monitoring Day,

00:59:58 (speaking in foreign language)

00:59:59 2030 on target under the sustainable development goals,

01:00:02 improve on water quality by reducing pollution,

01:00:05 eliminating dumping and minimizing release

01:00:07 of hazardous chemicals and materials,

01:00:10 (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:10 proportions untreated wastewater

01:00:12 and substantially increasing recycling

01:00:15 and safe reuse worldwide.

01:00:17 (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:19 (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:23 (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:27 (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:31 (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:34 So they cannot afford to have their own

01:00:40 waste treatment. (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:41 So hopefully, (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:46 And hopefully, (speaking in foreign language)

01:00:59 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:03 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:09 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:13 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:17 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:21 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:32 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:36 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:40 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:44 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:48 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:53 (speaking in foreign language)

01:01:57 (speaking in foreign language)

01:02:01 (speaking in foreign language)

01:02:24 (speaking in foreign language)

01:02:28 (upbeat music)

01:02:52 (upbeat music)

01:02:55 (upbeat music)

01:02:57 (upbeat music)

Category

Transcript

Recommended