'Mixed legacy': Did Rupert Murdoch 'modernise journalism' or did he 'debase' the profession?
Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 More on this story, we can bring in Simon Potter, professor of modern history at the
00:04 University of Bristol.
00:06 Good afternoon.
00:07 Thank you very much for joining us here on France 24.
00:09 Now, Australia's former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull says Rupert Murdoch has left behind
00:14 a legacy of division, adding he's done enormous damage to the democratic world.
00:19 Is that a fair assessment?
00:22 I think Rupert Murdoch has certainly been a very polarizing figure in Australia, in
00:28 Britain and the US over many decades.
00:32 A lot of the response to his decision to step down reflects that polarizing reputation.
00:41 So for many people, he is somebody who's debased journalism, who has done terrible damage to
00:46 the profession of journalism and to politics.
00:49 To others, he's an extremely successful entrepreneur who's modernized journalism in many different
00:56 countries and who has in some ways sustained print journalism and kept it alive and relevant
01:04 for the last 10 years.
01:05 So he's got a very mixed legacy, I would say.
01:08 I understand some may think he's a visionary, but under his watch, some of the publications
01:15 use dubious methods to get stories.
01:20 So Murdoch has, ever since the 1960s really, been accused of using sensationalism, sex,
01:29 journalistically dubious ethical practices in the UK, the whole scandal over phone hacking,
01:34 which your report mentioned, leading to the closing down of the News of the World, which
01:39 was one of the most popular and important papers, popular papers in Britain.
01:45 These methods have been widely attacked, and the legal settlement in the US, I think, again,
01:51 reflects quite how wrong journalists under Murdoch's leadership have got it in some of
01:57 those key cases.
02:00 Let's talk about one of the things Rupert Murdoch says he wanted to do, which is taking
02:06 on the establishment.
02:07 But isn't that convenient for somebody who's a billionaire to say they want to do?
02:12 Certainly.
02:14 So in Britain, the editor of another newspaper, The Telegraph, a man called Max Hastings,
02:20 he once wrote that effectively, newspaper proprietors, they want to make money, and
02:25 they want to make the world safe for people with money.
02:28 And any sense that the Murdoch empire has stood for the little man or has been anti-establishment,
02:37 that might be there in its rhetoric.
02:39 But I think in reality, many people feel that in its treatment of trade unions in Britain,
02:45 in the way that it has tried to make money out of the misfortune of individuals, it doesn't
02:50 stand on the side of the little man.
02:52 And its record in US politics, I think, has reflected that as well.
02:57 How is it possible that Rupert Murdoch, under his whole vast umbrella of media organizations,
03:05 which he looked after, there is Fox News, there are the Sun, you know, media outlets
03:11 that push conspiracy theories, etc., what have you.
03:16 But at the same time, you also have reputable organizations like The Wall Street Journal.
03:23 So it's a very complex business empire.
03:27 Some of the commercial decisions that Murdoch has made have been very good.
03:32 Some of them have been very bad.
03:34 It's very hard to see what the short term business decisions are between some of the
03:42 strategies that it adopts.
03:44 But in the long term, some of its elite publications have generated a profit and are still quite
03:50 valuable today, as is a newspaper like The Sun.
03:53 So I think in business terms, we'd want to see that as a portfolio of investments.
03:58 But in terms of politics, I think all these different outlets, which generally people
04:03 don't read, you know, they don't read The Sun and The Times.
04:08 I want to jump in there because Rupert Murdoch is 92 years old.
04:11 He sort of signaled he wants, he will be around because he's chairman emeritus.
04:16 His son is 52 years old.
04:19 That's a significant age difference.
04:21 Will the son be more centrist than his father?
04:26 It's hard to tell because I think Lachlan has been marginalized for some years before
04:30 being brought back into the inner circle.
04:33 As a result, a lot of pundits are speculating on his politics.
04:36 They assume that he's to the right as well, particularly in US and Australian politics.
04:43 The power that he will have, whether he will have that same power as an individual dominating
04:49 the organization that Rupert Murdoch has, again, that's up for question.
04:53 Will he rather be part of a team that is running the empire on very different lines?
04:59 I think what's very clear is Rupert Murdoch was perhaps the last great newspaper magnate.
05:05 His life, his love was newspapers.
05:08 Lachlan is a different generation.
05:10 And whether newspapers will be so important to the Murdoch media empire going forward
05:14 is a big question.
05:16 In the digital age, Simon Potter, we're going to have to leave it at that.
05:19 Thank you very much for joining us on the program today.
05:21 Thank you.