UEFA Opens a Door to Russia’s Return in Soccer, and Faces a Backlash
#englishnews #uefaopen
News Article :-
European soccer’s governing body is facing angry criticism and open defiance from some of its member nations after a vote by its executive committee earlier this week partially lifted a blanket ban on Russian teams that was imposed after last year’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
The proposal to allow Russia’s teams to participate in qualifying for the European men’s and women’s under-17 championships that will be held next year, and for which qualifying has already begun, came as a surprise to many members of the governing body, UEFA. Its approval has reopened what many believed was a bitter but settled debate about solidarity with Ukraine.
Ukraine’s national soccer federation quickly objected to the vote, arguing that allowing even Russian youth teams to return to tournaments “tolerates Russia’s aggressive policy.” Several federations, including Sweden, Norway and a group of Baltic nations, noted that the conditions that had led to the initial ban remained unchanged, and they invited punishment by saying that they would refuse to play Russian opponents under any circumstances.
The tensions in soccer could be a preview of difficult discussions playing out in dozens of sports over the reintegration of Russia and its athletes into global sports ahead of next year’s Paris Olympics. And the angry reaction to the decision highlighted of the difficulty of balancing official solidarity with Ukraine — and opposition to Russian aggression in Ukraine — against the rights of athletes, even youth players, with little say in the actions of their governments.
The differences at times appear irreconcilable. A bloc of Western nations, for example, continues to lobby against efforts by the International Olympic Committee to create conditions in which Russian athletes will be allowed to participate in the Paris Games as neutrals. And sports as diverse as tennis and fencing have already seen the effects of the war provoke confrontations and snubs at their competitions.
European soccer officials, for their part, were struggling to understand why their organization’s powerful president, Aleksander Ceferin of Slovenia, had chosen to drag their sport back into the dispute. Mr. Ceferin had repeatedly said that the blanket ban on Russian teams would remain in place “until the war ends,” they were quick to note, and the competitive concerns behind the original ban — that the refusal of teams to play Russia made tournament draws unworkable and potentially unfair — had not changed.
The stage for the fight was unusual as well. Youth tournaments usually merit little attention at the leadership meetings of European soccer’s governing body, often consigned to cursory updates at the bottom of a long agenda. But this week was different.
The closed-door gathering at a hotel in Cyprus was about 90 minutes old when Mr. Ceferin spoke up and put forward a motion. He asked the committee to partially l
News Article :-
European soccer’s governing body is facing angry criticism and open defiance from some of its member nations after a vote by its executive committee earlier this week partially lifted a blanket ban on Russian teams that was imposed after last year’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.
The proposal to allow Russia’s teams to participate in qualifying for the European men’s and women’s under-17 championships that will be held next year, and for which qualifying has already begun, came as a surprise to many members of the governing body, UEFA. Its approval has reopened what many believed was a bitter but settled debate about solidarity with Ukraine.
Ukraine’s national soccer federation quickly objected to the vote, arguing that allowing even Russian youth teams to return to tournaments “tolerates Russia’s aggressive policy.” Several federations, including Sweden, Norway and a group of Baltic nations, noted that the conditions that had led to the initial ban remained unchanged, and they invited punishment by saying that they would refuse to play Russian opponents under any circumstances.
The tensions in soccer could be a preview of difficult discussions playing out in dozens of sports over the reintegration of Russia and its athletes into global sports ahead of next year’s Paris Olympics. And the angry reaction to the decision highlighted of the difficulty of balancing official solidarity with Ukraine — and opposition to Russian aggression in Ukraine — against the rights of athletes, even youth players, with little say in the actions of their governments.
The differences at times appear irreconcilable. A bloc of Western nations, for example, continues to lobby against efforts by the International Olympic Committee to create conditions in which Russian athletes will be allowed to participate in the Paris Games as neutrals. And sports as diverse as tennis and fencing have already seen the effects of the war provoke confrontations and snubs at their competitions.
European soccer officials, for their part, were struggling to understand why their organization’s powerful president, Aleksander Ceferin of Slovenia, had chosen to drag their sport back into the dispute. Mr. Ceferin had repeatedly said that the blanket ban on Russian teams would remain in place “until the war ends,” they were quick to note, and the competitive concerns behind the original ban — that the refusal of teams to play Russia made tournament draws unworkable and potentially unfair — had not changed.
The stage for the fight was unusual as well. Youth tournaments usually merit little attention at the leadership meetings of European soccer’s governing body, often consigned to cursory updates at the bottom of a long agenda. But this week was different.
The closed-door gathering at a hotel in Cyprus was about 90 minutes old when Mr. Ceferin spoke up and put forward a motion. He asked the committee to partially l
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00 European soccer's governing body is facing angry criticism and open defiance from some
00:05 of its member nations after a vote by its executive committee earlier this week partially
00:10 lifted a blanket ban on Russian teams that was imposed after last year's full-scale
00:15 invasion of Ukraine.
00:17 The proposal to allow Russia's teams to participate in qualifying for the European
00:22 men's and women's U-17 championships that will be held next year, and for which qualifying
00:28 has already begun, came as a surprise to many members of the governing body, UEFA.
00:34 Its approval has reopened what many believed was a bitter but settled debate about solidarity
00:39 with Ukraine.
00:40 Ukraine's National Soccer Federation quickly objected to the vote, arguing that allowing
00:45 even Russian youth teams to return to tournaments tolerates Russia's aggressive policy.
00:51 Several federations, including Sweden, Norway and a group of Baltic nations, noted that
00:57 the conditions that had led to the initial ban remained unchanged, and they invited punishment
01:02 by saying that they would refuse to play Russian opponents under any circumstances.
01:07 The tensions in soccer could be a preview of difficult discussions playing out in dozens
01:12 of sports over the reintegration of Russia and its athletes into global sports ahead
01:17 of next year's Paris Olympics, and the angry reaction to the decision highlighted of the
01:22 difficulty of balancing official solidarity with Ukraine and opposition to Russian aggression
01:28 in Ukraine against the rights of athletes, even youth players, with little say in the
01:33 actions of their governments.
01:35 The differences at times appear irreconcilable.
01:38 A bloc of Western nations, for example, continues to lobby against efforts by the International
01:44 Olympic Committee to create conditions in which Russian athletes will be allowed to
01:49 participate in the Paris Games as neutrals.
01:52 Even sports as diverse as tennis and fencing have already seen the effects of the war provoke
01:57 confrontations and snubs at their competitions.
02:01 European soccer officials, for their part, were struggling to understand why their organization's
02:07 powerful president, Alexander Safarin of Slovenia, had chosen to drag their sport back into the
02:13 dispute.
02:14 Mr Safarin had repeatedly said that the blanket ban on Russian teams would remain in place
02:19 until the war ends; they were quick to note, and the competitive concerns behind the original
02:24 ban a that the refusal of teams to play Russia-made tournament draws unworkable and potentially
02:30 unfair a had not changed.
02:32 The stage for the fight was unusual as well.
02:36 Youth tournaments usually merit little attention at the leadership meetings of European soccer's
02:41 governing body, often consigned to cursory updates at the bottom of a long agenda.
02:46 But this week was different.
02:48 The closed-door gathering at a hotel in Cyprus was about 90 minutes old when Mr Safarin spoke
02:53 up and put forward a motion.
02:55 He asked the committee to partially lift a ban on Russian soccer teams that had been
03:00 imposed after the invasion of Ukraine so that Russia's junior teams could return to European
03:05 competition.
03:07 Mr Safarin left little doubt about his preference.
03:10 Arguing that it was not right to punish children, he cited his own experience growing up in
03:15 Slovenia during the break-up of the former Yugoslavia and referenced a United Nations
03:20 charter on the rights of children before allowing others in the room to speak.
03:25 While most of the officials remained silent a typical in such gatherings, where decisions
03:30 are usually agreed before a formal vote a Poland's representative, the former star
03:35 player's Big Noob Ong, offered passionate opposition.
03:39 Mr Bohnke took the floor for about five minutes, pointing out that children in Ukraine, too,
03:45 continued to suffer because of the war.
03:48 He said that nothing had changed since the decision to bar Russia was made only days
03:52 after the start of the war in February 2022.
03:56 A Romanian official in the room, who did not have a vote, also spoke.
04:01 He reminded the board that Russia's war was also affecting children in other European
04:06 countries.
04:07 The war, he said, was forcing budget cuts on services in Romania to account for increases
04:13 in military spending.
04:15 The representatives from England and Wales joined Bohnke in abstaining when the vote
04:19 was taken, but the motion passed anyway.
04:22 The repercussions began almost immediately.
04:25 A handful of European soccer federations immediately said they would not play against Russian teams
04:30 should they be paired against them in qualification tournaments.
04:34 Sweden, whose representative at UEFA, Karl-Erik Nielsen, voted for the plan to allow Russian
04:40 teams to return, went further.
04:43 It said it would bar Russian players from travelling to next year's women's U-17
04:47 finals in Sweden should the team qualify.
04:51 It is unclear what motivated UEFA's decision to open the door to Russia's return.
04:56 Mr Safran's initiative was not widely shared with officials within the organisation before
05:01 the vote, something that typically happens so the organisation can game out the implications
05:06 of a decision, and the practical consequences are significant.
05:11 The qualifying draws for both the men's and women's U-17 championships were made
05:16 without Russia, and men's teams have already begun playing matches.
05:20 Women's qualifying begins next week.
05:23 If the decision is not reversed, UEFA now faces the spectre of having to take disciplinary
05:28 action against countries who refuse to play against Russian opponents.
05:32 Still, its president was unmoved.
05:35 "By banning children from our competitions, we not only fail to recognise and uphold a
05:40 fundamental right for their holistic development but we directly discriminate against them,"
05:45 Mr Safran said in comments published by UEFA after the vote.
05:49 "By providing opportunities to play and compete with their peers from all over Europe,
05:55 we are investing in what we hope will be a brighter and more capable future generation
05:59 and a better tomorrow."
06:00 Ukraine's soccer federation said the return of Russian teams to competitions in the midst
06:06 of hostilities conducted by the Russian Federation against Ukraine is "groundless" and such
06:11 that it tolerates Russia's aggressive policy.
06:15 Its unequivocal refusal to play Russian opposition was matched by a group of European federations
06:21 that included the Baltic nations, England, Wales, Norway and Denmark, whose president,
06:27 like his Swedish counterpart, is a close ally of Mr Safran and did not speak out to oppose
06:33 Russia's return during the vote in Cyprus.
06:36 The ban against Russia's senior teams will continue until the end of the war, Mr Safran
06:41 said, reiterating a position he made clear following a charity soccer game in Slovenia
06:47 earlier this month.
06:48 At the time, Serbian media quoted the UEFA president as saying "ask Putin" when he
06:53 was asked when the ban would be lifted.
06:56 For now, that question is the least of UEFA's problems.
07:00 First it has to hurriedly devise a calendar that will allow Russian teams to enter events
07:04 that have already begun, keep them away from opponents who are refusing to play them, and
07:09 do it all even as the list of potential opponents could diminish as more national federations
07:15 consider whether to heed Ukraine's call to re-evaluate the deal.