Refutation of Ikhtiyar Kulli

Nondenominational Islam

Imdad Kun,Ghaus e Azam, Farman , Ghaus, Faizan e Ghaus, Karamat e Ghaus,  Imdad e Ghaus, Maqam e Ghaus, Karamat e Ghaus, Aqwal e Ghaus, Talimat e Ghaus Shan e Ghaus, Waqiat e Ghaus,Imdad e Ghaus,Ghausiah, Waqiat e Ghausiah,Taqat e Ghaus, Masail e Ghaus, Ghussah e Ghaus, Yaran e Ghaus, Nazareth e Ghaus,Ghaus Parast,Aulia Parast,Sufia Parast, Qubur Parast, Mazarat Parast,Peer Parast, Makhdum Parast,Mushrikeen e Kichhaochha,

Transcript

00:00In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

00:30In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

01:00The Prophet could have asked for prophethood.

01:02And if the Prophet could have given prophethood,

01:04and if he had the power,

01:06then he had the power to break prophethood,

01:08to break the seal of prophethood.

01:10In fact,

01:12some objections have increased to the extent

01:14that they say

01:16that

01:18Hazrat Rabi'ah

01:20could have asked for

01:22such things

01:24that we consider

01:26to be an insult to the Prophet

01:28to say such things.

01:32For example,

01:34a person

01:36does not want to say this.

01:38And then

01:40some people want to object

01:42to the character of the Prophet.

01:44So,

01:46I am keeping this device

01:48that I have

01:50so that

01:52I can read.

01:54And this device

01:56that I am holding in my hand

01:58is being used to read.

02:00And obviously,

02:02I do not have a better way than this.

02:04So, dear viewers,

02:06do not take it the wrong way.

02:08Now listen to the debate.

02:10I will show the pages at the end.

02:12Look, the Prophet is not empty of two states.

02:14He is Mukhtar-e-Kul or he is not Mukhtar-e-Kul.

02:16If he is not,

02:18then the belief

02:20that the Prophet

02:22has the authority

02:24If the Prophet

02:26is Mukhtar-e-Kul,

02:28then he is not empty of two states.

02:30It is obvious

02:32that he does not have the authority.

02:34To have the authority

02:36means that he can either lie

02:38or not lie.

02:40If the Prophet has the authority,

02:42then the belief of Mukhtar-e-Kul

02:44is invalid.

02:46If the Prophet does not have the authority,

02:48then the belief of Mukhtar-e-Kul

02:50is invalid.

02:52The Prophet

02:54is not

02:56Mukhtar-e-Kul.

02:58Remember that

03:00if the Prophet is Mukhtar-e-Kul,

03:02then he is Mukhtar-e-Kul.

03:04If the Prophet is Mukhtar-e-Kul,

03:06then he is Mukhtar-e-Kul.

03:08Keep this in mind.

03:10It is not that one is Mukhtar-e-Kul

03:12and the other is not.

03:14If the Prophet has the authority,

03:16that is, he is Mukhtar,

03:18then in every news of the Prophet,

03:20there is a possibility of lying.

03:24In every news of the Prophet,

03:26there is a possibility of lying.

03:28Note this down.

03:30Who knows,

03:32the Prophet may have given that news

03:34to a liar and he has the authority.

03:36Therefore,

03:38this is not

03:40a firm and unwavering belief.

03:42Now,

03:44there is a possibility of lying

03:46in the Prophet's claim of prophethood.

03:48After this,

03:50there is no possibility of believing in the Quran,

03:52Ahadith, Ijma,

03:54Iman and Deen.

03:56In response to this,

03:58it can be said that

04:00the Prophet has the authority over lying

04:02but he is infallible from lying.

04:04What does it mean to be infallible from lying?

04:06The Prophet is infallible from lying.

04:08That is, the attribute of Isma

04:10i.e. lying is proven for him.

04:12So, if the Prophet is infallible,

04:14then the attribute of Isma will be proven for him.

04:16And if the attribute of Isma

04:18is proven for him,

04:20then the Prophet will be infallible.

04:22Keep this in mind.

04:24So, the attribute of Isma

04:26i.e. lying

04:28means

04:30that as long as the Prophet

04:32is infallible from lying

04:34or as long as the Prophet is infallible,

04:36lying cannot happen.

04:38It is not possible for Isma to exist

04:40and for lying to exist.

04:42This is a logical contradiction.

04:44This is a logical contradiction.

04:46It is not possible for Isma to exist

04:48and for lying to exist.

04:50It is not possible for Isma to exist

04:52and for lying to exist.

04:54It is not possible for Isma to exist

04:56and for lying to exist.

04:58It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:00and for lying to exist.

05:02It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:04and for lying to exist.

05:06It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:08and for lying to exist.

05:10It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:12and for lying to exist.

05:14It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:16and for lying to exist.

05:18It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:20and for lying to exist.

05:22It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:24and for lying to exist.

05:26It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:28and for lying to exist.

05:30It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:32and for lying to exist.

05:34It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:36and for lying to exist.

05:38It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:40and for lying to exist.

05:42It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:44and for lying to exist.

05:46It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:48and for lying to exist.

05:50It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:52and for lying to exist.

05:54It is not possible for Isma to exist

05:56and for lying to exist.

05:58It is not possible for Isma to exist

06:00and for lying to exist.

06:02It is not possible for Isma to exist

06:04and for lying to exist.

06:06It is not possible for Isma to exist

06:08and for lying to exist.

06:10If the Prophet is Mukhtar-e-Kul,

06:12then he can finish his attribute of Isma

06:14and can do Iqaul-Kizb.

06:16This is possible.

06:18As long as Isma is mentioned,

06:20it will be proven that

06:22there is no possibility of Isma.

06:24it will be proven that there is no possibility of Isma.

06:26But to finish Isma

06:28is still possible.

06:30But to finish Isma

06:32is still possible.

06:34It is possible that the Prophet

06:36has finished Isma.

06:38It is possible that the Prophet

06:40has finished Isma.

06:42It is possible that the Prophet

06:44has finished Isma.

06:46It is possible that the Prophet

06:48has finished Isma.

06:50It is possible that the Prophet

06:52has finished Isma.

06:54It is possible that the Prophet

06:56has finished Isma.

06:58It is possible that the Prophet

07:00has finished Isma.

07:02It is possible that the Prophet

07:04has finished Isma.

07:06It is possible that the Prophet

07:08has finished Isma.

07:10It is possible that the Prophet

07:12has finished Isma.

07:14It is possible that the Prophet

07:16has finished Isma.

07:18It is possible that the Prophet

07:20has finished Isma.

07:22It is possible that the Prophet

07:24has finished Isma.

07:26It is possible that the Prophet

07:28has finished Isma.

07:30It is possible that the Prophet

07:32has finished Isma.

07:34It is possible that the Prophet

07:36has finished Isma.

07:38It is possible that the Prophet

07:40has finished Isma.

07:42It is possible that the Prophet

07:44has finished Isma.

07:46It is possible that the Prophet

07:48has finished Isma.

07:50It is possible that the Prophet

07:52has finished Isma.

07:54It is possible that the Prophet

07:56has finished Isma.

07:58It is possible that the Prophet

08:00has finished Isma.

08:02It is possible that the Prophet

08:04has finished Isma.

08:06It is possible that the Prophet

08:08has finished Isma.

08:10It is possible that the Prophet

08:12has finished Isma.

08:14It is possible that the Prophet

08:16has finished Isma.

08:18It is possible that the Prophet

08:20has finished Isma.

08:22It is possible that the Prophet

08:24has finished Isma.

08:26It is possible that the Prophet

08:28has finished Isma.

08:30It is possible that the Prophet

08:32has finished Isma.

08:34It is possible that the Prophet

08:36has finished Isma.

08:38It is possible that the Prophet

08:40has finished Isma.

08:42It is possible that the Prophet

08:44has finished Isma.

08:46It is possible that the Prophet

08:48has finished Isma.

08:50It is possible that the Prophet

08:52has finished Isma.

08:54It is possible that the Prophet

08:56has finished Isma.

08:58It is possible that the Prophet

09:00has finished Isma.

09:02It is possible that the Prophet

09:04has finished Isma.

09:06It is possible that the Prophet

09:08has finished Isma.

09:10It is possible that the Prophet

09:12has finished Isma.

09:14It is possible that the Prophet

09:16has finished Isma.

09:18It is possible that the Prophet

09:20has finished Isma.

09:22It is possible that the Prophet

09:24has finished Isma.

09:26It is possible that the Prophet

09:28has finished Isma.

09:30It is possible that the Prophet

09:32has finished Isma.

09:34It is possible that the Prophet

09:36has finished Isma.

09:38It is possible that the Prophet

09:40has finished Isma.

09:42It is possible that the Prophet

09:44has finished Isma.

09:46It is possible that the Prophet

09:48has finished Isma.

09:50It is possible that the Prophet

09:52has finished Isma.

09:54It is possible that the Prophet

09:56has finished Isma.

09:58It is possible that the Prophet

10:00has finished Isma.

10:02It is possible that the Prophet

10:04has finished Isma.

10:06It is possible that the Prophet

10:08has finished Isma.

10:10It is possible that the Prophet

10:12has finished Isma.

10:14It is possible that the Prophet

10:16has finished Isma.

10:18It is possible that the Prophet

10:20has finished Isma.

10:50There is no such thing as a prophet.

10:52If someone says that prophethood is Allah's personality,

10:54and it is the gift of a prophet,

10:56then this is complete disbelief and polytheism.

10:58Prophethood over Allah is impossible.

11:00And if someone says to me that

11:02Allah's prophethood is as impossible

11:04as Allah's death over him is impossible.

11:06Because the first condition for a prophet

11:08is that he is a creature.

11:10This is the first condition.

11:12And the creation of the Creator

11:14is completely impossible and impossible.

11:16Now here I would like to tell you

11:18that there are some attributes of a prophet

11:20which can only be for a prophet.

11:22For Allah's creation,

11:24they are neither personal

11:26nor are they a gift like prophethood.

11:28So they will only be a gift for a prophet.

11:30If they are personal,

11:32then it will be disbelief and polytheism.

11:34Remember this. This is a very important point.

11:36So now I will tell you that

11:38Allah's creation

11:40is impossible

11:42because the first condition for a prophet

11:44is that he is a creature.

11:46So now

11:48in spite of this,

11:50prophethood will be a gift for a prophet.

11:52If someone believes it to be personal,

11:54then he will be a disbeliever.

11:56However, for Allah's creation,

11:58prophethood is neither personal nor a gift.

12:00In contrast, take the attribute of knowledge.

12:02For Allah's creation, knowledge is

12:04personal and for a prophet it is a gift.

12:06These are our terms.

12:08So this means that

12:10it is completely wrong to prove

12:12the authority of a prophet.

12:14I have written some techniques

12:16and I have already told you

12:18what my writing is.

12:20This is Naskh.

12:22And I have shown you this.

12:24So if you think

12:26that our terminology is correct

12:28and there is nothing wrong with it,

12:30then you should never

12:32say that the authority of a prophet

12:34is complete.

12:36Because what you are trying to prove

12:38is not complete.

12:40So how will a prophet finish his prophethood?

12:42A prophet has the authority

12:44to finish his prophethood

12:46or

12:48to finish his prophethood

12:50and make someone a prophet

12:52after him.

12:54So a snake says that

12:56Allah is not able

12:58to make someone a prophet

13:00after the Messenger of Allah.

13:02But a prophet has the authority

13:04and then he is made a prophet

13:06by the seal of a prophet.

13:08If Allah has the authority

13:10then he is not able to make

13:12someone a prophet.

13:14Now the last thing.

13:16If there is an authority

13:18then there is a power.

13:20And if there is no power

13:22then there is no authority.

13:24So when I say that a prophet has the authority

13:26then he has the power.

13:28And if a prophet has no power

13:30then he has no authority.

13:32So I hope you have understood

13:34that the belief of the authority

13:36is completely wrong for a prophet.

13:38It is wrong to say that

13:40the Messenger of Allah seals people

13:42and makes them a prophet.

13:44It is also wrong to say

13:46that the Messenger of Allah

13:48seals people

13:50and makes them a prophet.

13:52And it is also wrong

13:54to say that

13:56Bari Talha has no authority.

13:58Bari Talha used to make people

14:00without any reason.

14:02Now if Bari Talha has any authority

14:04then it is only because

14:06Bari Talha used to make people

14:08without any reason.

14:10Now if Bari Talha has any authority

14:12then it is only because

14:14Bari Talha used to make people

14:16without any reason.

14:18Now if Bari Talha has any authority

14:20then it is only because

14:22Bari Talha used to make people

14:24without any reason.

14:26Now if Bari Talha has any authority

14:28then it is only because

14:30Bari Talha used to make people

14:32without any reason.

Category

Transcript

Recommended