#islamabadhighcourt #nationalassembly #parliament #pti #haidernaqvi #chaudhryghulamhussain #hassanayub
IHC revokes physical remand for PTI MNAs | Haider Naqvi Detail Analysis
IHC revokes physical remand for PTI MNAs | Haider Naqvi Detail Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00PTI's lawyer for whom PTI is saying that he was arrested, we saw that he was presented in the court.
00:09The FIR on him was read out in Islamabad High Court.
00:14We also saw the remarks of the Chief Justice.
00:18The Prosecutor General shared the content of the FIR.
00:22The Chief Justice said that the author of the FIR is very interesting.
00:30The case is full of interesting allegations.
00:34You entered the Parliament and took over the Arkan Assembly.
00:37The way the proceedings were carried out, what is left?
00:40Then he raises the question, where did the freedom of the Chief Justice go?
00:43Where did the law go?
00:45Here we are talking about the Supremacy of the Parliament.
00:48Then he said that credit will have to be given.
00:50After a long time, he said about the FIR that he got to see a good comedy.
00:55You read the comedy.
00:56Now what to do with them?
00:58This question is very important that he asked.
01:01Now we see that the Prosecutor General in Islamabad says that Shoaib Shaheen's stick has been recovered.
01:07And on the statement of the Prosecutor General, there was a commotion in the court.
01:11And then an observation that the Chief Justice gave himself.
01:14He says that he did not let the dignity of any institution remain.
01:17What are you doing?
01:18This was his question.
01:19The story he has made is interesting.
01:22A film can also be made on it.
01:24The Speaker's National Assembly is doing its job.
01:26But the court can also see this matter.
01:29This is the most interesting remark in my opinion.
01:32Parliament is the mother of all institutions.
01:35The Chief Justice is also saying this.
01:38In Islamabad High Court, there are 8 MNAs in which the decision has been secured on the request for a physical remand.
01:47And the arrested MNAs have been sent to jail for judicial remand.
01:50And the PTI's arresting lawyer's physical remand has been annulled.
01:55Let's talk about all these issues.
01:57Hassan, I come to you.
01:59When we see that the Speaker of his own Jamaat, Tariq Fazal Chaudhary, says that he had knowledge.
02:08The Speaker says in a helpless manner that there is so much pressure on me.
02:12You have no idea.
02:13Everyone is holding me responsible.
02:15But when the court hears that the Speaker is doing his job.
02:19That is fine.
02:20He is a custodian.
02:21It is his right to do his job.
02:23But we can also see this matter.
02:26So, it is being said that the court can also see this matter.
02:32So, what can be the result of this?
02:33No, he has said that the FIRs or the arresting will be seen.
02:38But within the parliament, whether the arrest was carried out.
02:42Of course, it will be seen through a petition.
02:44No, no.
02:45Whether the arrest was carried out within the parliament or not.
02:47The court will not decide this.
02:49Courts never conduct inquiries.
02:53Inquiries are done by the investigating agency.
02:56Someone should go and file a request to the court.
02:58Even if they file a request, the court will still say that there is an investigator.
03:02Sadaf, the court has never investigated.
03:05It is not their job to investigate.
03:07So, what the Chief Justice is saying, and he is saying it very rightly.
03:11What Chief Justice Aamir Farooq has said.
03:13He has said that the arrest, the complaint filed against these people,
03:19who are the members of the parliament,
03:21or the story that he has made in the FIR,
03:26the court will take a look at it.
03:28And it is taking a look at it.
03:30In this regard, he has terminated the physical remand order of the ATCs.
03:35And he has made them judicial.
03:37And the speaker has declared all the parliament lodges as jails.
03:41So, basically, the 8 parliamentarians who are in the parliament lodges,
03:46but they will imagine that they are in jail.
03:49So, it is getting better.
03:51Supposedly, if an inquiry report comes,
03:55first, the speaker has given the minister a 7-day break.
03:58And second, his own in-house inquiry is going on.
04:02So, when both these reports will be revealed...
04:04Sir, do you agree that we all agree that the parliament is supreme.
04:11And when this happened in the Supreme Parliament,
04:13and the remarks that the Chief Justice is giving,
04:15that no institution has been allowed to remain.
04:17What do you want to do?
04:18Do you agree that this has happened because of the Chief Justice?
04:21100%.
04:22I agree 100% with these remarks of the Chief Justice.
04:27And second, if someone has come to the parliament and arrested Rukmini Parliament,
04:33then he should stand in the court of law.
04:37This is my stated position, loud and clear.
04:40There can be no other opinion in this.
04:42You cannot allow anyone to undermine the sanctity of the parliament.
04:51Haider, let me come to you.
04:53The way the FIR has been filed,
04:55the way it has been discussed in the court,
04:57and it has been made a joke that
05:00this is a very interesting story.
05:02Who is the author of this?
05:04Can you shed some light on who is the author?
05:08Look, the Chief Justice has said a very true thing about the Sanabar High Court.
05:13That the parliament is the mother of all institutions.
05:16But we live in a society,
05:19a society in Pakistan,
05:21where in majority,
05:23the father's order and the father's words are the last.
05:26So, that is one thing.
05:28The second thing is that the Chief Justice has said
05:31that the honor of an institution is no longer in jeopardy.
05:34So, now we have to see where this started from.
05:37It started from there,
05:39when you took the parliamentarians and locked them in a container
05:42because you had to take the vote of confidence.
05:47It started from there.
05:48Now you talk about the courts.
05:50So, who was the one who goes to the judge of the Islamabad High Court
05:53and threatens him that you have to take this decision?
05:55So, where this started from,
05:57and now it will take a lot of time for this to end,
05:59for this to be completely cleaned up.
06:02But, God willing, all this will be cleaned up in the state of Pakistan.
06:11Okay, we are listening to this.
06:13The SHO did all this himself.
06:16But we are talking here,
06:18the parliament, like Haider is saying,
06:20that it is the mother of all institutions.
06:22So, the father of the Greek parliament is also of institutions.
06:25So, what is this in the parliament?
06:27I don't understand.
06:28You explain a little.
06:29You were smiling at that time.
06:31Are you asking me?
06:35Yes, Haider, you do it.
06:37Look, the SHO said something in a joke.
06:41You said that there was a joke in the Islamabad High Court.
06:44In that, he said this.
06:45You said everyone was laughing.
06:47So, I also said in that joke that the parliament will definitely be the mother of institutions,
06:50but the father's decision is final in Pakistan.
06:53I said that in the same way.
06:56Look, the sanctity of the parliament…
06:59Hassan, who is the father?
07:01There is no father before the sanctity of the parliament.
07:04The parliament is the parliament.
07:06Remember this.
07:08And the creator of the institution, the mirror of Pakistan, is the parliament.
07:12And Pakistan runs under the mirror of Pakistan.
07:16So, there is a full stop before the parliament.
07:19I have said many times,
07:20the supreme court is not superior to the parliament.
07:24The parliament is superior to the supreme court.
07:27This is definitely a trichotomy of power.
07:29But the powers of the parliament are limitless.
07:33And the parliament is given the power by the people of Pakistan.
07:37So, basically, this is the rule of the people.
07:40And for that, your constitutional agreement is the mirror of Pakistan.
07:45So, basically…
07:46You say that this is not the parliament of the people.
07:48No, I don't agree with that.
07:50Neither Chaudhary, nor I, nor Haider Naqvi said that this will make a difference.
07:55You cannot compromise anything on the sanctity of the parliament.