Duniya Bhar Mein Judges Ki Taenati Kaisay Hoti Hai? Aur Pakistan Mein Kaisay ?
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00There is a lot of debate going on about the judicial system in India, in the US, in the UK.
00:11First of all, let me take you to India.
00:13In India, over the period of time, the Supreme Court's different judges, the judgments of the judges,
00:20on their basis, there is a collegium system.
00:24Chief Justice is at the top, and four senior judges.
00:28They decide all the decisions.
00:31Transfers, postings, judges, everything is in their hands.
00:34In 2014, their parliament, Prime Minister Modi's government, challenged this.
00:41And they passed the National Judicial Appointment Commission Act 2014.
00:45In this, what has happened in our country, exactly the same method has been adopted.
00:50Government control, politicians' control, they have kept it in it.
00:54In it, the Law Minister, Attorney General, everything happened exactly the same.
00:57When this issue went to the Supreme Court, they blew it up.
01:02They said that this cannot happen.
01:04And all the control was back with the court.
01:07The principle of freedom of the court was implemented there.
01:12In America, the President is directly elected.
01:18He nominates.
01:21When the nomination is done, the Senate votes on it.
01:27There is a mixture of legislature and executive.
01:31There is scrutiny from both sides.
01:36In the UK, there is an open competition.
01:41The position is vacant.
01:42It is advertised.
01:43In the commission that recruits, there are only two non-legal people.
01:50More members of the commission are determined.
01:53They are also judges.
01:55President and Deputy President of the UK Supreme Court.
01:59So, according to that, the legal minds are used more.
02:04Mr. Naqvi, you have seen the situation.
02:09Don't you think that the government has done a little injustice?
02:13You have taken everything in your hands.
02:15A little bit of bloodshed.
02:17On the other hand, there is a free and fair dichotomy of power.
02:23See, the biggest responsibility of the powerful.
02:27Now you have become powerful.
02:28You have not talked about bloodshed.
02:30The hand of the government is up.
02:32Now the biggest responsibility of the powerful is to support the weak.
02:36And after supporting them, put their conditions in front of them.
02:40And according to that, take matters forward.
02:43So, at least I understand.
02:44I am talking in response to what you said.
02:46I understand that the government is in this position.
02:49That it can make the opposition on such things.
02:53So that at least the situation in Pakistan gets better.
02:57This is one.
02:58Second, I want to request the whole of Pakistan.
03:01We will have to get out of this game of ifs and buts.
03:03If this happens, then this will happen.
03:05And if that happens, then that will happen.
03:07There are a lot of people.
03:08We have seen a lot of people on YouTube.
03:09They used to say, Justice Yaya Ahmadi.
03:11Chief Justice.
03:12Otherwise, we will not accept.
03:13And if you accept, then do not take the oath.
03:16And if you take the oath, then resign.
03:18And if you do not resign, then the decision of the busy seats will be made in the hands of the PTI.
03:23This is the most harmful for Pakistan that people are put behind the truck lights by doing ifs and buts.
03:30Viewers, there is a lot of debate about the new benches.
03:34Rana Sinawala was asked yesterday who will be the senior and who will be the junior.
03:40Because three senior most judges are present in the Supreme Court at the moment.
03:45So listen to their answer.
03:49Our senior most judges are in the Supreme Court at the moment.
03:53Justice Mansoor Ali Shah and Maree Bakhtar.
03:57The controversy that has been going on and the way it has been going on.
04:01I don't think they themselves will like it.
04:04That they should be made the head of the Constitutional Bench.
04:08So the consideration of this, although this is the right of the Judicial Commission.
04:14But my individual opinion is that this consideration should start after them.
04:22Chaudhry Ghulam Singh is very clear about his consideration.
04:25In this program, our friend, the anchor, asked.
04:31You are saying that first three have become controversial.
04:34They have also asked that since the Chief Justice will have his own vote.
04:38Therefore, he should not become a part of this bench.
04:44He should not become a presiding judge.
04:46What do you think?
04:48Will they be able to achieve the objectives of the government according to the 26th amendment?
04:55After the amendment, what did they say?
04:58Can't Mansoor Ali Shah become the head of the Constitutional Bench?
05:01Look, they are suggesting that the Constitutional Bench should be made.
05:07Rana Sinala is saying that the three most senior judges at the moment.
05:11Justice Mansoor Ali Shah, Justice Muneeb Akhtar and the Chief Justice himself.
05:18Because anyone can become the presiding judge of the Constitutional Bench.
05:25So Rana Sinala thinks that he should not become the head of the Constitutional Bench.
05:28And Justice Ameen should start working from there.
05:35This is their wish.
05:36The amendment that they have made, what do they want?
05:41That neither can he become the Chief Justice, nor can he become the next senior judge.
05:47They want us to make our own decisions.
05:51This is what they want.
05:53And the decisions that are going to be taken,
05:56the cases that are going to be investigated,
05:59and the cases that are a very serious matter,
06:02they should make them all fly in one day.
06:05Stop it.
06:06They will create more problems.
06:08I am saying from the first day that the path they are on,
06:12nobody is going to agree to their plans.
06:16I am sorry.
06:17Viewers, the biggest challenge that is going to be faced by the current Chief Justice,
06:27you know that it is your favorite subject from the first day.
06:30And that is the implementation of the decision on specific sessions.
06:35Today, Pakistan Justice has filed a petition to the Contempt of Court,
06:40that your decision is not being implemented.
06:44So call the members of the Election Commission Chiefs and ask them,