Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com
Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English
Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Douglas Herbert, our international affairs commentator, joins me on set. Hi, Doug.
00:03How are you?
00:05I'm good. Now, so this was the fourth such exchanges since the ceasefire took effect
00:10just under two weeks ago. And today, it seemed to go a lot more smoothly than last Thursday,
00:18didn't it?
00:18Look, a stark contrast with those chaotic scenes where the hostages were paraded,
00:23in many cases, in front of, you know, masked armed Hamas fighters and crowds of civilian
00:30Palestinians watching them as objects being, you know, being traded. And Netanyahu and other
00:36Israelis raised a lot of objections, what they called, you know, the severity, the propaganda,
00:40the use of the hostages as weaponized propaganda tools for Hamas, as they saw it.
00:45Look, we're entering a new phase here. Yeah, it was a smoother transfer. To date now,
00:50you've said there have been four separate batches of hostages released in the first phase. That's
00:54what it called for regular intervals of hostage releases. 33 are to be released altogether in
01:00this first 42 day phase. So far, we have seen 13 hostages released altogether, which means
01:06technically 20 remaining. It's important to note these are Israeli and Israeli foreign hostages as
01:13well, but not the Thai nationals. They're not included in this count. They were not included
01:16in the terms of this ceasefire agreement.
01:18It was on schedule.
01:19So yeah, so these are basically 20 now Israeli hostages remaining. Now, according to Hamas,
01:25eight of those are presumed dead, or they told the Israelis, eight of those are dead. So they
01:29would be bodies being returned, not living hostages. And Israel has, you know, basically
01:34not disputed that number. It believes also eight of them would be dead. So until now, we've had
01:39Israeli forces, we've had a ceasefire, but not a permanent one. We've had Israeli forces withdrawing
01:44from populated areas to border areas, but they aren't gone from Gaza by any means. And we have
01:52had a surge in aid into Gaza, flowing into Gaza, the number of trucks. What we haven't had, and
01:58this is where it's going to get tricky now, right? In the next few days, on the 16th day of this
02:03first phase, you're going to have the start of negotiations on the second phase, right? And the
02:07second phase is going to be perhaps the much heavier lift. It's going to call for not just a
02:11complete ceasefire, but a permanent ceasefire, an enduring ceasefire, unended, limitless. And it's
02:18also going to call for the remaining, all of the remaining living hostages to be returned, as well
02:25as, and here's where you could say it gets really tricky, the complete withdrawal of Israeli forces,
02:30remaining ones from Gaza, right? They've already with, they will have withdrawn from the Philadelphia
02:34corridor in the south, but Netzerim, the Netzerim corridor is the one that from which they're,
02:38they've already withdrawn, but they'd have to withdraw from everywhere, back into Israel. So a
02:44lot of tricky steps ahead. I will note that early in the negotiations, remember Biden, Joe Biden put
02:50this deal last May, late last May, began negotiating it and originally had called for, or at least
02:55Hamas would have wanted all the hostages released in one fell swoop, in one stage, in return for,
03:01you know, up to 1,900 Palestinian prisoners, all at once, one phase. The reports are, and those
03:07Netanyahu's detractors say the reason we're seeing it spread out over three phases is that Netanyahu
03:12himself pressed for this phased solution because he knew that the longer you drew it out, the longer
03:17he could remain in power, the longer he could remain in power. Remember, this is what his
03:22critics would say of Netanyahu. He obviously is going to vehemently deny that that was any such
03:26plan. But in other words, the longer he remains in power, the more time until he has to so-called
03:30in quotes, face the music, whether it's, you know, his judicial trials are also investigations over
03:35what many consider, many Israelis consider his signal failings for on October 7th, 2023,
03:41letting this happen in a sense and letting his guard down. So delaying that process of having
03:47to reckon with a lot of criticism about his handling of October 7th and also affairs well
03:53beyond in his government in general. Now, turning our eyes back to Gaza, we've seen thousands of
03:58displaced Gazans being allowed to return to the Strip. Many want to rebuild Gaza, of course,
04:05but Donald Trump, for instance, recently called on Jordan and Egypt to take them in en masse. How
04:11do we interpret his comments? Yeah, this was a suggestion what Trump did. Let's put first what
04:15he said, what Trump said. He floated the idea last month. Remember, there's about estimated 2.3
04:20million pre-war population of Gaza, right? Most of them are largely homeless right now. You know,
04:26hundreds of thousands, perhaps upwards of 2 million, 90, 95% of the population homeless,
04:32left without homes because they were destroyed, displaced, uprooted, all of that. Donald Trump
04:36has basically said he's called Gaza a demolition site. And he has said, you know, we should just
04:42basically clean out the whole thing. That was those were his words, just clean out the whole
04:46thing. So basically, considering Gaza, essentially a garbage dump of homeless human beings, and
04:53saying, get them out, push them out, and ask Egypt and Jordan to go. Now, Egypt and Jordan,
04:59but not just. We've had powerful Arab nations, Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar, Palestinian
05:07Authority, and the Arab League all saying, absolutely not. This is where they live. This is
05:11where they're staying. If they were to leave, it would put peace and stability and the hopes of
05:15coexistence and a two-state solution at risk. We are not taking any Palestinians, Mr. Trump. Now,
05:20he's holding by the plan, but we'll see what happens going ahead. He's gotten a lot of pushback
05:23in the region, not just pushback, outright rejection from the countries he wants to take
05:27Palestinians, saying that that is not going to happen. So watch this space.
05:31Of course, a rejection from the Palestinian people.
05:34And the Palestinian Authority, of course, the Palestinians themselves. They're saying,
05:36we are staying here. This is our home, our land. This is where we are.