No, the ICJ hasn't declared Israel an 'illegal state'

euronews (in English)

No, the ICJ hasn't declared Israel an 'illegal state'  The false claims have been shared repeatedly over the past few months.  READ MORE : http://www.euronews.com/2025/04/24/no-the-icj-hasnt-declared-israel-an-illegal-state  Subscribe to our channel. Euronews is available on Dailymotion in 12 languages

Transcript

00:00No, the ICJ hasn't declared Israel an illegal state.

00:08Old false claims that the UN's highest court,

00:11the International Court of Justice,

00:13has declared Israel an illegal state,

00:15have resurfaced online.

00:17Various social media posts circulating in recent weeks

00:20show a video of former Palestinian Foreign Minister

00:23Riyad al-Maliki delivering a speech

00:25in which he says that Israel's occupation of Palestine

00:28has been declared unlawful.

00:30He adds that the court declared that the occupation

00:32violates the UN Charter of Human Rights,

00:35that the ICJ has ordered Israel to cease his occupation

00:38as quickly as possible,

00:39and that Israeli settlements in occupied Palestinian territory

00:43are illegal and should be dismantled.

00:45The posts sharing the video present it as breaking news

00:48and state that this means Israel has been declared

00:50an illegal state and shouldn't be recognised as a sovereign nation.

00:54However, not only are the claims wrong, they're old too.

00:57Firstly, there's no evidence that the court has handed down

01:00any such decision in recent weeks,

01:02be it an announcement from the ICJ itself

01:04or any news reports about the supposed decision.

01:07A search on X shows that the false claim

01:09has been repeatedly shared over the past year,

01:12since the video showing al-Maliki was first published

01:15on 19 July 2024.

01:17He delivered his speech in response to a real, non-binding ICJ decision,

01:21in which the court did indeed label Israel's presence

01:25in the Palestinian occupied territories as unlawful.

01:28It also called for an immediate end to the construction of settlements

01:31and condemned Israel's control over the lands it took nearly six decades ago.

01:36However, at no point did the ICJ declare Israel an illegal nation,

01:40nor did it order other countries to stop recognising it as a sovereign state.

01:44Responding to the ruling at the time,

01:46Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said it was a distortion of historical truth

01:51and that the West Bank and East Jerusalem are part of the Jewish people's historical homeland.

01:56The West Bank and East Jerusalem are part of the Jewish people's historical homeland.

Category

Transcript

Recommended