Ayse Tajir jinka Crore's ka Revenue hai agar wo 10 Hazar Tax Nahi... Senator Afnan ullah Aalysis
#shutterdownstrike #tradersprotest #tradersstrike #pmshehbazsharif #afnanullahkhan #11thhour #waseembadami
Ayse Tajir jinka Crore's ka Revenue hai agar wo 10 Hazar Tax Nahi... Senator Afnan ullah Aalysis
Ayse Tajir jinka Crore's ka Revenue hai agar wo 10 Hazar Tax Nahi... Senator Afnan ullah Aalysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Now, PTI's Senator Humayun Mohamad,
00:02Mr. Humayun, tell us, he has explained this in full detail by Mr. Naeem Mir,
00:07which makes it clear that this is the first step to bring this class into the tax rate.
00:11And since it is practically not possible overnight
00:14to determine the monthly income of every trader in Pakistan,
00:18we all know, I'm sure you would also agree,
00:19that this mechanism cannot be made overnight.
00:21So, this imaginary income, which is adjustable,
00:23we have started with this.
00:24Now, if there is a political divide on this as well,
00:26and there is a government pressure,
00:28then how will we document the economy?
00:31What is wrong in it, Mr. Humayun?
00:58Mr. Humayun, you are right.
01:17A high-end shop is a good example of cooking.
01:19This is not how it started in the market.
01:21But, you and I are saying that
01:23we should improve the criteria.
01:25But, in principle, this approach is right,
01:27in your opinion as well.
01:29Look, in principle, direct taxation is better.
01:34But, in Pakistan, the same thing is that
01:36here, there is documentation.
01:40Secondly, we have legalized dishonesty at the government level.
01:46For example,
01:47what we call the DC rate,
01:50is basically dishonesty.
01:53Basically, you are making black money.
01:56You are legally showing a property worth Rs. 5 crores
01:58worth Rs. 2 crores.
02:00Okay, after that, let me tell you one thing.
02:02All the houses in Islamabad,
02:04all the houses in F6, F7, F8,
02:07which are of 2-4 canals,
02:10are not less than Rs. 15-20 lakhs.
02:12Go and see how much tax their owners are paying.
02:16They take cash from you.
02:19They don't pay you tax.
02:21So, Mr. Shabbar, when the government has taken a step
02:23to solve these problems,
02:24that a group of people should be brought in for taxation,
02:26and the merchants have organized a strike,
02:27and you are standing with them?
02:29No, no, no, look, the thing is,
02:31we are standing with them,
02:33that if you look at the whole package,
02:35there is dishonesty in the whole package.
02:38If you are with a merchant,
02:40I am telling you this because,
02:42in a way, I am working,
02:43I am paying tax, I am paying rent,
02:46I am doing everything myself.
02:47But, when you increase the net tax on me,
02:51they are putting indirect tax on me,
02:53they are taking advance tax from me,
02:55which later creates problems for me,
02:57so, in the end, I feel like
02:59I cannot earn anything from this business.
03:01So, what is happening is,
03:02people are going out of Pakistan,
03:04and then they are increasing the electricity bill.
03:07When you look at all these things,
03:08a lot of injustice starts happening.
03:11Mr. Afnaan, what is the solution to this,
03:13Mr. Afnaan, in government?
03:14Look, Mr. Shabbar was also saying this during the break,
03:16that we are stuck.
03:17On one hand, the merchants say,
03:19you are hitting me with electricity from here,
03:21the rent has increased so much from here,
03:22the purchasing power of the customer has died,
03:24so, the footfall has already decreased.
03:26On top of that, you are also hitting me with this,
03:28so, he is crying.
03:29The government is crying,
03:30that brother, if you want to run the country,
03:31if you have money, you will run the country, right?
03:33So, we are stuck.
03:35What is the solution to this, Mr. Afnaan?
03:39Look, the solution to this is that
03:41we onboard the merchant community with us,
03:46we review their legitimate demands
03:49and we want to take the matter forward.
03:52But you understand this,
03:54the representatives of the merchant community
03:56who were here, they said,
03:58that this number is not right,
04:00which I am telling you.
04:01They are listening to you.
04:02You tell me,
04:03how many businesses are there in Pakistan,
04:05which are in shops,
04:07which are working on cash.
04:09Millions.
04:11Where are they registered?
04:13Where are they registered?
04:16You tell me.
04:17It is happening in the air.
04:19Yes, I am saying that
04:21if you say that we are giving tax,
04:23then somewhere,
04:25it will be reflected,
04:27in the collection.
04:29So, this is what we have checked,
04:31and there is not so much tax,
04:33let me tell you.
04:35There are merchants
04:37who have revenues of crores of rupees,
04:39who do not even have such big shops,
04:41and the work of gold has been done,
04:43for example.
04:45There is a revenue of crores of rupees.
04:47If you cannot even pay
04:49a monthly tax of Rs. 10,000,
04:51then this is a matter of regret,
04:53and if you still have issues,
04:55then what can a person say?
04:57You were saying Rs. 10,000 earlier,
04:59which Mr. Javed disagreed with.
05:01I was talking to Mr. Ismail,
05:03he was saying that in Karachi,
05:05in Sindhi Muslim,
05:07every shop has been paid Rs. 60,000.
05:09If someone is fined,
05:11the tax is fine,
05:13but this is not even the final tax.
05:15In the final tax collection,
05:17if you think that
05:19your income has decreased,
05:21then you can claim tax credit,
05:23and you will get credit
05:25on the income.
05:27But the matter is,
05:29we have to take matters
05:31forward from somewhere.
05:33I also think that there is no harm
05:35in putting a point of sale.
05:37If someone thinks that
05:39they can put a point of sale,
05:41then there is no harm in doing so.