#ElectricityRelief #PPP #PMLN #bilawalbhutto #MaryamNawaz #Infilation #PPP #PMLN #PTI #pmshehbazsharif #electricity #ipps #khawarghumman #thereporters
Why is there no Permanent Relief for Electricity Instead of Temporary Relief?Hassan Ayub's Analysis
Why is there no Permanent Relief for Electricity Instead of Temporary Relief?Hassan Ayub's Analysis
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Sir, what is the reason behind the redness on your face and the smile on your face?
00:07Anyways, back to the original question.
00:09The question is, what does IMF have to do with Punjab's PSGP?
00:16The surplus budget that they have taken out from the PSGP.
00:21Can you clarify?
00:23The Provincial Government had promised to save this much money and return it.
00:28I don't see it being saved.
00:30The IMF has raised these questions.
00:32I don't think Mr. Bilawal should be involved in this matter.
00:38First of all, there is provincial autonomy.
00:40After the 18th amendment, the provinces are autonomous.
00:44Yes, the provinces are autonomous, but the provinces are autonomous.
00:47Punjab's province has its own autonomy.
00:51Where does Sindh use its own funding?
00:53The flood affected families are being given houses for rehabilitation.
01:00So, Punjab has no right.
01:02The federal government has given additional funding for this.
01:04So, Punjab has no right to question why Sindh is doing this.
01:11Because they have their own people.
01:13They know their constraints better.
01:15This is a comparative analysis. I don't understand.
01:17No, you don't understand, but I would like to explain.
01:20For clarification, you know that electricity is in the federal pool.
01:25So, they are making solar.
01:26The provincial government has a plan for Sindh.
01:28Listen to me.
01:29Electricity has gone.
01:30When a relief will be given to Punjab on the electricity bill,
01:33and if, for example, Sindh does not have that budget,
01:36KP or Balochistan does not have that budget.
01:39Sir, there is a division on the population.
01:42Sir, listen to me.
01:43This is a division on the population.
01:44Electricity is a problem for the whole of Pakistan.
01:46Electricity is a problem for the whole of Pakistan.
01:4865% of Pakistan's problem is solved, right?
01:5065% of Pakistan's problem is solved, right?
01:51100% of Pakistan's problem should be solved.
01:52God willing, it will be solved.
01:53Then the Sindh government will cut the PSDP.
01:55PSDP will be cut.
01:56The final government will go to Pakistan.
01:58I would like to say that
02:00Mariam Nawaz Sharif's governance model is her model.
02:05She will not take a dictation from Bilawal.
02:08Similarly, the chief minister of Bilawal, Murad Ali Shah,
02:13because he is the chairman,
02:15if he gives a dictation to him,
02:17then he is in the right.
02:19Similarly, Nawaz Sharif is the president of the party.
02:22He can dictate to Mariam Nawaz.
02:24Don't talk about dictation.
02:26We have a lot of dictators.
02:27They can dictate.
02:28They can advise.
02:29They can give orders.
02:30The party is the president.
02:31The party is the chairman.
02:32They will give orders.
02:33They are their workers.
02:34In the end of the day,
02:35they have become chief ministers.
02:36They will become because of the party.
02:37Mariam Nawaz Sharif...
02:38No, no, no.
02:39Mariam Nawaz Sharif is the chief minister today.
02:42If she can give orders today,
02:44if she is the chief minister today,
02:46then it is because of Nawaz Sharif.
02:48And if Murad Ali Shah is the chief minister today,
02:51then it is because of Bilawal Bhutto.
02:53Okay, okay. Nonsense, sir.
02:54It is the right of the party chairman,
02:56the party president,
02:57that he directs it.
02:59Or he will tell them,
03:00that this work,
03:01I have been told to do this work.
03:02I will have to do it.
03:03Naveen sir, I am coming to you too.
03:04But the reference that Mr. Chaudhary gave,
03:06Mr. Chaudhary,
03:07this has now become another committee in Punjab.
03:10And yesterday,
03:11I could not talk to you much on this topic.
03:13And it is that,
03:14what more has been given to the committee,
03:16that you do more work on it.
03:18And take feedback,
03:19that the people of your party,
03:20those who are affected,
03:21those who are affected,
03:22the power sharing,
03:23why is it not being implemented on it?
03:24You had a meeting,
03:25you were telling.
03:26Tell us,
03:27what are the people's party people saying,
03:28what are they talking about this?
03:30And in the coming weeks,
03:31ten days,
03:32in all the weeks,
03:33what are they seeing?
03:34That this marriage of love and affection,
03:37will it continue?
03:38Or will this marriage of convenience,
03:40end at any time?
03:41I don't know if the marriage will continue,
03:42but they are not satisfied.
03:44I mean,
03:45I am talking to one of their most important people.
03:50So,
03:51because I was not allowed to quote from them,
03:53I am not quoting.
03:54No, you are not quoting.
03:55Give a sense of what has been said.
03:57That thing,
03:58they are saying,
03:59we are stuck in very bad conditions here.
04:02Nothing is going right.
04:04And they tell us,
04:05we are talking about marriage,
04:07and they are making a big deal out of it.
04:09And they make a marriage,
04:11that suits them.
04:13According to that,
04:14they put their own man.
04:16I mean,
04:17this is an example they have given.
04:18And then,
04:19we will give you a development fund,
04:21this and that is in your pocket.
04:23So,
04:24they are saying,
04:25nothing is going anywhere.
04:27So,
04:28this kind of work,
04:29here,
04:30they are totally dissatisfied.
04:33Let's put it like this.
04:35Okay,
04:36so,
04:37Mr. Bilawal has given a reference,
04:38you know,
04:39of the old PTI government,
04:41that they did this work under pressure,
04:42wrongly.
04:43And the current government,
04:44according to Bilawal,
04:45has done this work wrongly,
04:46the overall economic situation of Pakistan.
04:48They are not able to understand the decision.
04:50So,
04:51this reference,
04:52that they have given,
04:54behind that,
04:55any argument,
04:56any argument,
04:57any need,
04:58what do you think?
04:59See,
05:00first,
05:01when you talked to Mr. Chaudhary about the committee,
05:02basically,
05:03this is not a committee.
05:04Wherever committees are made,
05:05this is not a committee.
05:06This is,
05:07come have tea.
05:08They come,
05:09sit,
05:10chat,
05:11and leave.
05:12There is no achievement.
05:13No,
05:14come have high tea.
05:15Not just tea,
05:16come have high tea.
05:17So,
05:18there can be many types of tea,
05:19right?
05:20Yes,
05:21nowadays,
05:22there is no tea without high tea.
05:23Okay,
05:24so,
05:25now,
05:26the question you asked,
05:27Mr. Bilawal,
05:28see,
05:29if Mr. Bilawal says,
05:30that the decision was made under pressure,
05:31then it is a good thing.
05:32Then,
05:33this case becomes very solid.
05:34So,
05:35the people who are in power,
05:36they should be under the pressure of the people.
05:37They should not be under the pressure of anyone else.
05:38If this decision has been made under the pressure of the people,
05:39then I think,
05:40this decision is absolutely right.
05:41Yes.
05:42Yes.
05:43Yes.
05:44Yes.
05:45Yes.
05:46Yes.
05:47Yes.
05:48Yes.
05:49Yes.
05:50Yes.
05:51Yes.
05:52Yes.
05:53Yes.
05:54Yes.
05:55Yes.
05:56Yes.
05:57Yes.
05:58Yes.
05:59Yes.
06:00Yes.
06:01Yes.
06:02Yes.