Phil is back to discuss Sunderland's 1-0 defeat to Hull City and to chat through all your questions and comments
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the latest edition of On The Whistle, where, as
00:13ever, we're going to have a chat through Sunderland's latest game. Unfortunately, in this case,
00:17for the second time this week, it's a defeat we've got to talk about. Sunderland losing
00:20their very long and very proud-to-be-fair, unbeaten home record in the league with a
00:251-0 defeat to Hull City because of an Anthony Patterson own goal. So, as ever, I'll have
00:30a bit of a chat through the game and my thoughts and reflections on it. If you want, you can
00:35go back on our channel, our previous videos, me and James giving our immediate thoughts
00:38in the press box on the final whistle, but I'm just going to have a bit of a longer chat
00:41through the next day about how I thought the game went, and as ever, I'll discuss your
00:46questions and comments. So, I think that the first thing to say is that I think, in a way,
00:52Hull were pretty good value for the win. I do think that Sunderland obviously missed
00:57some big chances in the second half and they still had a really good chance at the back
01:01post. Eliza Mienda should have scored or, I think, squared it to a team-mate when he
01:05broke through on goal not long after he came on. I also think, watching the replays back,
01:10that I do think Sunderland had a fairly clear penalty ignored in the final 10 minutes of
01:14the game, when the Hull defender, for me, the cross comes in, his arm is raised, it's
01:18not a natural position and the ball quite clearly strikes his arm. So, I thought that
01:22was a huge stroke of luck for Hull and I thought Sunderland were unlucky not to get a penalty.
01:27However, I think on balance of play, I think we all saw that this was a long, long way
01:31from Sunderland at their very best. I think, obviously, what's interesting is that we've
01:37seen a definite dip in results and performances at home recently, because Sunderland's last
01:42home game they beat Luton and that was a really important win. But before that, they were
01:47disappointing draws against Plymouth and Watford, in which both games, Sunderland could
01:50very, very easily have lost them. So, definitely, something's not quite right at home and I
01:54thought it would be interesting to chat through that a bit, because I think that what we saw
01:59from Hull is that we're seeing teams finding a little bit of a template for how to play
02:03against the Sunderland side at home and how to stop their key threats. I think you can
02:07see that what teams are very, very conscious of doing is they don't want to give Sunderland
02:11the opportunity. I've seen a lot of people asking in the aftermath of the game, what's
02:16happened to the intensity and the pressing and the energy from the start of the season?
02:21Now, I definitely think this is a big problem for Sunderland and I think we can all see
02:24in the performances that there's some definite fatigue with key players. I think that the
02:28energy has dipped from where it was at the start of the season and I think that's inevitable.
02:31We're now 34 games into the season and Regis Lebris has relied on a very small core of
02:37players to play a huge amount of football. I think we probably have seen it, especially
02:41in the last three or four years since Sunderland have gone to this model of playing really,
02:44really young players. We have seen that at this time of the season, a lot of players
02:47who are maybe in their first campaign or whatever it might be, sometimes struggle a little bit
02:53with fatigue, whether that be physical or mental or both. I think we've definitely seen
02:58some elements of that in Sunderland's performances, but I think what we're also seeing is a huge
03:01shift from the opposition in the way that they approach games at the stadium. I was
03:06actually thinking last night when I was thinking about the game about the conversation we had
03:10with Alex Neil when he was Sunderland's manager when Sunderland first came up to the championship
03:15in a press conference and it's something that stuck with me because I thought it was really
03:18perceptive. He talked about how the championship is a division where at the start of the year
03:22everyone believes they can make the playoffs, everyone believes they've got a team that
03:25can get promoted. So what happens is that everyone's going for it in every single game,
03:30everyone thinks they can get three points and you have quite open end-to-end games.
03:35I think we saw that at the start of the year, teams like Sheffield Wednesday, Sunderland
03:38finished 16th last season. I think you'd see that teams when they came to the stadium
03:41were playing quite an aggressive style, they were trying to play out from the back, they
03:44were trying to play to their philosophy and Sunderland I think caught a lot of teams out.
03:50What then happens is you get a little bit later in the season and a lot of teams realise
03:54they're in trouble and they have to completely change their approach and they have to be
03:56a lot more pragmatic and the nature of games changes a lot and I think that's what we're
04:00seeing at the stadium. Plymouth, a very, very, very direct counter-attacking style of their
04:06play to them. Remember that Hull nearly finished in the play-offs last year, they got rid of
04:10Liam Rossini because their owner wanted a more aggressive style of play, that was the
04:14reason why they hired Tim Walter in the summer. What we're seeing now is that they're in a
04:18position where they know they just have to survive and we're seeing them take a lot more
04:22pragmatic approach and so I think their style has changed considerably in terms of what
04:27they were doing last season and even at the start of this season to what they did yesterday.
04:31Fair play to them, I thought they did really, really well, I think that's the first thing
04:33to say. I don't want to be dismissive and say it was all just about low-block defending
04:39because it absolutely wasn't. I think what you saw is Hull picked the right times to
04:43press, they didn't just let someone build up and build up and build up and build up
04:47pretty much until the last 10 minutes and I think you can see that they were tired and
04:51someone did find it easy to get to the edge of the Hull box. They did press well, I thought
04:55given a lot of credit, probably similar to the Watford game, I thought they were dominant
04:59in the 1v1 duels, especially after the goal. I think they were winning the ball all over
05:03the pitch and that made it really, really difficult for Sunderland to build up any
05:06esteem and of course their defending was strong. So I think you've got to give Hull a lot of
05:11credit for the way they played and the performance they were able to produce. I think from a
05:16Sunderland perspective, my feeling is that, especially at home, I think they have hit
05:20a little bit of a wall. I think part of that is because, as I say, I think teams are adapting
05:25to them tactically and I think teams are kind of putting down a template and I don't
05:29think it's easy for any team to break down. I think that's kind of exacerbated by the
05:32fact that for me it looks like Sunderland are a team who need a little bit of freshness.
05:37Excuse me while I have a sip of my coffee.
05:41So I think moving forward, I think we have reached a little bit of a point where
05:45probably Sunderland need to think about freshening things up, they need some new
05:48ideas tactically. I think there's some players who probably could do with the rest.
05:52You know, as I said on the reaction video yesterday, it's not singling anybody out,
05:57but I think you can see that to me, Chris Ridd looks like someone who could need a rest.
06:01I think that would allow you then to give him a bit of a break, use him as an impact
06:05substitute and I think it could be really, really effective. And then maybe towards the
06:08end of the campaign, he'll be back in a position where he can push for a start.
06:11It's not criticism, we've seen it with players like Dan Neal in the past and Aserkan in the
06:16past, they've really benefited from a little bit of a break after playing so many games.
06:21So I definitely think there's a lot for Lebris to think about. Ridd's certainly not the only
06:24player in that category. I think you could argue on the right flank, you know, do we
06:27need Jad Poveda to come into the starting XI to give Patrick Roberts a little bit of a break?
06:32Again, he has played the vast majority of games this season and quite often 90 minutes.
06:36So I think we've reached maybe a little bit of a tipping point in the campaign,
06:40where yesterday's result probably, it may be a little bit extreme to say it's been coming,
06:45but I think there were some warning signs in the recent home games.
06:48And I think it's obvious that there's a few things to go away for Sunderland to think about.
06:52Before I go on to your questions, the other thing that I meant to mention at the start,
06:55but completely forgot, so apologies for that. No major update on the injury issues in the
07:00post-match press conference, other than Regis Lebris did confirm that, as Sky Sports had
07:05reported, Enzo Lefebvre had experienced some discomfort in his hamstring towards the end
07:08of the first half. Sunderland obviously just made the decision that it wasn't worth the risk and
07:13the worst thing to do would be for him to play on and potentially aggravate it and pick up a
07:16more serious injury. Dan Ballard also picked up a hamstring injury, making that quite a fantastic
07:21block on Kyle Joseph early in the second half. So both those players will be assessed today,
07:26which is obviously a big concern really, because we were just getting to the point when I talked
07:31about that theme of freshening things up, it would be such a big blow to then lose two.
07:38You do have two very, very good players who can come into the team, that's not so much of a
07:41concern. Romain Monta and Chris Meppa are very, very good players at this level and can do an
07:45excellent job. But again, it then takes two of your potentially game-changing options off the
07:50substitutes bench and it makes it really hard to combat some of those issues we've been seeing.
07:54So both those players will be scanned and assessed today, which will get an update midweek, probably
07:59ahead of the Sheffield Wednesday game and Regis Lebris' pre-match press conference. But yeah,
08:03definitely a big concern and one to watch because that's the last thing Sunderland needs.
08:07So let's go and have a look at your questions and comments and we'll have a bit of a chat
08:10about them before I wrap up. So the first one from Trish, which did give me a smile,
08:15just a big sigh, which I think probably everybody, to be honest, related to Sunderland at the moment
08:20is feeling a little bit like that, maybe even the players themselves. Yeah, I love doing these
08:26videos. It's one of the highlights of my working week, chatting through you all your questions,
08:32comments. This was one of the first ones where I thought, I wonder if I can get away with just
08:36not doing it this week. But anyway, we'll crack on. But anyway, I totally empathise with that,
08:40Trish. I think probably all the Sunderland fans do as well.
08:43Ben says, the team just looked tired today. That game at Leeds, dot dot dot,
08:47losing the last minute after a huge effort must have been, must have tainted out of them
08:50physically and mentally. I definitely think that's something that we should consider. I think it was
08:55difficult to come into a game so close after that Leeds game in which they did so much defending.
09:01I think that was a big challenge and I think you could see that the fatigue was there. Obviously,
09:05you could then raise the question, should Sunderland try to freshen it up a bit,
09:08maybe get Elias in the end in because of that potential fatigue after the Leeds game.
09:13I imagine Lebris' thought was that because so much of the performance against Leeds was pretty good
09:17that he wanted to just try and keep some consistency. But I definitely think there's
09:20obviously an argument that maybe it could have been freshened up. That is hindsight speaking
09:25after what we saw and it's quite easy to do that. But I definitely think that the challenge of the
09:29Leeds game was a factor. And as somebody else pointed out, going from playing on Monday night
09:33to Saturday morning, not ideal either. I definitely think that was a little bit of
09:37an advantage to the opposition there, albeit they utilised it really, really well.
09:45Davey says, fatigue looks a real issue now in my opinion. Robb,
09:48Rigg, Jobb, Serkin to name just three look shattered. Surely now the likes of Oleksij,
09:54Brown, Perveda should be given minutes. Yeah, I really agree with that. I think you've got to be
10:00careful. I think it's a really interesting period now because I've had some sympathy with Lebris
10:06previously because we could all see that maybe at times the team needed freshening up. Maybe
10:10you needed to give players some more experience. But some of them were right in the thick of a
10:13race for the top two and players like Perveda, who had so much time on the sideline. A player
10:19like Milano Oleksij, who is still adjusting to a new division. He's still a very young player,
10:24not a huge amount of senior experience. The risk was that by putting those players in the team,
10:29you're taking so much away from what's been doing well in the season. And if you then have a dip in
10:34results, that potentially ends your role on that promotion race. So I can kind of see why Lebris has
10:38tried as much as he can to stick with his core. But I think we've reached the point now where I
10:43agree with you, Davey, where I think that it's hard to look past the fact that quite few players
10:48on this team aren't anywhere near the level they were shown at the start of the season.
10:51I wouldn't be overly critical about that because I think it's inevitable. It's just what happens
10:55when you play so much football in such a short space of time, especially because the injuries
11:00elsewhere in the squad means that Lebris has not really been able to use the substitute
11:04spence that much. So they're playing even more football than they would ordinarily.
11:08So I definitely think that we've come to the point where Lebris needs to freshen things up a
11:13little bit. We actually asked them about this in the post-match press conference, which people
11:17might find interesting. We made this point about potentially, it feels like some teams have got
11:23a bit of a template now for playing against some other stadium alike, which you kind of agree with,
11:27especially when they take the lead. And we also asked, did he feel that given the level of
11:32performance, given the potential signs of fatigue, which he agreed with, was it time to freshen it
11:37up a little bit? And he did say that he thought that was probably the case and there would be
11:40opportunities for more players in the next few weeks and it's up to them to take it really.
11:45So I think Alan Brown is an obvious example of a player who will start to come back in now,
11:49loads of Championship experience, obviously had a few months on the sidelines, should be fresh.
11:54I think Miendo is clearly someone who needs to come in and I think you could probably put
11:58Paveda and Alexic. I think it's important you don't go too far all at once. What we don't want
12:02is this to become sort of a losing run and you don't want to, you need to help those players,
12:06especially a young player like Alexic. You want to put them in around players who are confident
12:10and into a team that's really settled. So I'm not saying that it needs to be like sweeping
12:14changes straight away. Sunderland also do have a little bit of a break till their next game now
12:18with no midweek fixtures. So some of these players will be able to recover. So I'm definitely not
12:22saying there needs to be an overhaul, but I agree with you, Davey. I think there needs to be
12:26a little bit of a freshening up because I think you can see that some players need it and going
12:32into a playoff campaign, ideally, if that is what it's going to be and it looks that way,
12:36we do need two or three extra players, I think. Question here says, any word on when Jadon Danz
12:42might be available? We need some freshening up. Does Rigg need a couple of games rest?
12:47Yeah, I agree with that. Probably not just Rigg, but I think he is the most obvious player that
12:50you would like to give a rest at this stage. On Jadon Danz, no, there isn't. It's a quite simple
12:57update. So as we've discussed previously, Danz, obviously, they discovered a relatively serious
13:04back injury during his medical. The player didn't have any symptoms. He was completely unaware of
13:10it. He was playing and in full training. It was only something that was found because he did his
13:14medical test. Sumner's view at that point was because they basically didn't really have the
13:20time to find another player because it was right at the end of the transfer window that it was
13:25best just to go ahead, do the deal. They're not paying any money for the deal while Danz is
13:30injured. So they felt that it was that it was best just to go ahead and do it in the hope that he'd
13:35be back for the run. And that's pretty much still where we stand. I think Sumner's expectation was
13:39always that first and foremost, there was going to be a period of rest and recovery at an absolute
13:43minimum. That would be a few weeks. That phase is basically still just ongoing. Danz is still at
13:50Liverpool undergoing the initial stage of his rehab. So he's not training with the team yet.
13:55He's in touch with the club. He's in touch with the brace. He was at the game on Monday night at
14:00Leeds United. So there is still the confidence and the hope that he'll be able to play in the running.
14:05That's very much still the plan. So Sumner's doing everything to try and get him in a place where
14:10when he's fit, he feels that he can come in and make an impact and that he has a little bit more
14:14connection with the club and the team. But at the moment, I don't think at this stage we'll be seeing
14:19Jadon Danz for another few weeks at an absolute minimum. So that's definitely not one that I
14:24think we're expecting a big change in the situation anytime soon. Shiny Tom says you'll
14:30struggle to mark anyone above a five for today's show and it was poor for management and players
14:34alike. We needed to be bold in both team selection and tactics, but we're neither. We need to be
14:38braver on the ball and at least match Hull in fighting endeavour, which we didn't deserve nothing.
14:42Yeah, as I said earlier at the start, I think Sumner did miss some big chances, but I definitely
14:46think Hull had the better of the game in terms of especially in the off the ball work and
14:50that I thought they were quicker to every second ball, every drill. So I don't disagree with you
14:54there. I did think that I thought that again, Trey Hulme, I thought did quite a lot of good stuff in
15:00the game, defended well. I think he's playing really well and I think you would have to say
15:03he's put a couple of brilliant crosses into the box in the second half, especially the one for
15:07Eastdoor at the back post that should have yielded a goal. So I did give him a six in my
15:12player ratings because I thought he'd put in a fairly solid display and on another day, a bit
15:15more could come from it. But with that, I do agree with you. Very, very, very few plays. It was one
15:20of those days, very, very few plays anyway, near their best. Sue Stelic says is the reason why
15:27Labreece continues to play the same start in XI and seems too reluctant to change, even though
15:31performances are different. I understand the need for some continuity, but it feels like it's coming
15:35at the detriment of the team when there are now good options waiting. Yeah, I think to be fair,
15:40I covered this in some of the other questions and comments as well. I think that Labreece has feared
15:46there'd be too much of a drop-off by button players who haven't played enough football and
15:50who haven't had a chance to show that consistency who maybe aren't experienced in the league,
15:54aren't even experienced in senior football in some cases. And I think he's felt that could
15:58lead to a dip in results, which would pretty much have ended Sunderland's top two hopes.
16:02But I think now we're reaching a point where there needs to be a little bit of a rethink because
16:06obviously the top two looks very, very difficult now. And those players who've been performing so
16:10well all season, I think there's some signs that they need a break now. So I definitely think
16:14that's something that we might well see. And as I mentioned, Labreece certainly thinks that's
16:18something we might well see change in the coming weeks. Michael says, although a poor run of form
16:24is obviously never a good thing, is it better to happen now to then hopefully regain momentum ahead
16:28of the playoffs should we finish there? I do agree with that. I think this is a really interesting,
16:33I think it's quite a big challenge for Labreece and Sunderland over the next few weeks that,
16:36you know, listen, some strange things can happen in the championship. We shouldn't totally write
16:40off the top two yet, but it looks very, very difficult. I think that's quite obvious.
16:44It's a really unusual situation to be this far out from the end of the season and basically know
16:48that you're going to finish in the playoffs. You sometimes see it where you have like three,
16:52four games to go in the season and everyone starts going, do we now rest players? Do we
16:56keep the strongest team to really go into the end of the season with some going into the playoffs
17:00with some really strong momentum? Very rare, I have sort of 12 games where you're weighing up
17:04that conundrum. It's really important you don't let the season fizzle out. I think that's the
17:08first thing and you've alluded to it there, Michael, you do want to go into the playoffs
17:12with a kind of settled team, feeling confident. So it's really, really important that, you know,
17:17we don't just limp to the end of the season. As I mentioned before, it's important that you don't
17:20just make stacks and stacks of changes every week. Everything becomes really disorganised
17:26and you lose a lot of your momentum. What I do think is it does give someone a bit of opportunity
17:30because there are so many games left to give some players a rest, to give some players some more
17:34minutes, to make some tweaks here and there so that hopefully by the time you reach those last
17:39couple of games of the season, you can really have hopefully everyone in a decent place and
17:44that can help you really attack the playoffs with some momentum. So I agree with you, Michael. It's
17:48that it would be better to have the dip now if someone can sort of now use it as a positive to
17:54freshen some players up and really find their feet again towards the end of the campaign. But
17:58it's an interesting challenge for La Brice to manage because it's not a situation I can really
18:01remember happening before. Michael says, too many 5 out of 10s today. How much worry is there about
18:08fatigue? Rig and Joe were two examples of players who in recent weeks haven't looked quite 100%.
18:12Do you think they'll look to seed the automatics and focus on the playoffs? I think it's a little
18:17bit early for that just because, as I've said before, I think there can be so many twists and
18:21turns in the championship and I think at this point you still just have to go and try and win
18:24every game. But as I've hopefully mentioned, you know, kind of addressing the video, Michael, I
18:28agree with you that I think we're at the point now where probably there needs to be a bit of
18:32freshening up moving forward. A couple of you asked about time wasting, which clearly was a
18:40massive issue yesterday. I have quite strong feelings on this, so I'll talk about it a little
18:46bit. The first thing I want to say is I'm not going to criticise Hull City. They're in a relegation
18:50battle. They're fighting for their lives. They were leading the game. The only responsibility
18:54they have is to their club and their fans and all they had to do was whatever it took to win the
18:58game and I thought they played quite intelligently. They took time out of the game but they also had
19:02some big chances on the break. That's how any team fighting relegation should play, so I'm not
19:06going to criticise Hull or their manager or their players or anything for that. They did what they
19:12had to do to win the game and fair play to them. It's up to the referees, it's up to the officials
19:16to do something about time wasting. We're consistently seeing that it doesn't happen,
19:20so what does that do? It incentivises the opposition to keep doing it. I think yesterday
19:25was a classic case of that. The first were at Yellowcard for time wasting. I think it was in
19:28the 73rd minute for the goalkeeper. By that point, they'd been going on for 50 minutes.
19:33The time that the ball didn't play yesterday for me was just ridiculous and I think the
19:37officials have got to do more. Personally, I'm incredibly frustrated that they stopped doing,
19:42if you remember after the last World Cup, they actually brought in the same thing that's
19:47happened in the World Cup where it was pretty much almost like a stop clock and it was a much
19:51more accurate depiction. At the time, it was a much more accurate reflection of how much time
19:56had actually been lost in the game. Although at times, it felt slightly far-scaled because we
20:00were playing so much football and I understood the concerns of the managers about the impact
20:05on players who were already playing too much football. I thought that was a good move for
20:09the paying public, personally, because I think that they get short-changed by the time wasting
20:13that goes on at every level of football. I think it's a real shame that we've gone backwards on
20:18that and I think yesterday was a great example of that. But again, I can't stress enough,
20:22I'm not saying that to be critical of Hull. I understand entirely why they played the way they
20:26did but I do think the officials need to rethink about it because there's got to be some kind of
20:29medium because we just can't let the game be almost ruined as a spectacle like it does sometimes.
20:37I think that's the change everybody would like to make. If Le Fay is fit, that's the big thing.
20:47We need to see how his hamstring injury develops because I don't know if he'll be available next
20:52Friday. I think if he is, I think that's the obvious change to make to give the team a fresh
20:55look. I do feel a bit responsible for what happened yesterday because I wrote an article
20:59on Friday night about how excited I was to see Le Fay and Mundell on the same team and then look
21:03what happens if Le Fay goes and gets injured the next day. So maybe that one's on me.
21:08I'm just going to end with a question that a lot of you asked, especially over on YouTube,
21:11but Andy also asked on Blue Sky, which was, does Paterson need a stint out of the team?
21:15I think he needs to work on commanding his area. Did he shout at Roberts to leave that ball?
21:19Would have and should have been an easy take. Yeah, I think...
21:25Listen, I think I chatted with Fabrice about Paterson after the game and he made the point,
21:31which I think is absolutely right. It was probably fairly similar after the Burnley game
21:34with those East Stoke penalties that, you know, it's a position of the pitch where your mistakes
21:38are completely magnified because the consequences are always severe. If you're a centre midfielder,
21:42a right back, a left back, a winger, you can make a huge mistake and not get punished and
21:47sometimes you can get away with that. If you're a goalkeeper or a striker and you make a big
21:50mistake, everybody talks about it because it has a direct consequence immediately on the game.
21:56I make that point to say that I think it underlines how over the last couple of years,
21:59the last three or four years, Anthony Paterson has made so few errors and I think that's the
22:03really important starting point for this conversation. How many times have we said
22:07that Paterson has been an obvious reason why someone have lost the game because he's made
22:10a big mistake? Very, very, very few. Yesterday was one of those occasions and having watched the
22:16third goal back on Monday night, I think it's probably something that he'll look back on and
22:19think he should have stopped as well when the cross comes in. But I think that's really,
22:22really unusual for Paterson and I think that's the first thing to say. He's definitely not
22:27in his best form and we spoke to Lebris after the game and he said that he felt that the silly
22:31mistakes across the team, not just the goalkeeper, were becoming too regular. It's happening too
22:36often where someone is making silly mistakes and he did say that it's something that he's
22:40going to have to go and ask some serious questions about. So I think it's clear he's
22:44considering changes. For me, I think at this point, I think you stick with Anthony Paterson,
22:48I think you back him. I think he's been excellent for someone for such a long period of time,
22:52a young goalkeeper who has made so few mistakes and been really, really dependable.
22:57This isn't, at the moment, the form he's in. It's not the form he was in when Sunderland
23:01got promoted from Ligue 1. It's not the form he was in when Sunderland was so good in their first
23:05season back in the Championship and he was such a key part of that. I think that's obvious and
23:09I'm not trying to hide from that. I think it's clear that he needs to improve to get back to
23:15that level. But for me, I think you have to keep a bit of faith with him and back him. This for me
23:20is one real sticky patch since he came into the team and I think it's important that the manager
23:26gives him that bit of confidence to try and work his way through it. Obviously, it's something that
23:30Lebris will need to monitor, but for me, I would stick with Paterson for now. I think he's been
23:34excellent for Sunderland. For sure, I think there's areas of his game that can be improved,
23:39as with any young player, and let's hope he can recover his confidence quickly. I think that's
23:45clearly important. We know there's an able deputy there and Simon Morton did well there
23:48in the season, but for now, although yesterday was a bad error and he's clearly not in his best
23:53moment, I think as a head coach, Lebris maybe at this point needs to back him for a little
23:58bit longer and allow him to work his way through this little dip in form. Thanks very much for
24:02your questions. It's always quite cathartic to talk through after a disappointing performance
24:07and I'll see you next week. Thanks for watching.