Constitutional Courts ka Muamla, Hukumat Ka Peeche Hatne Ka Iradah? Hasnaat Malik's Give Inside News
#constitutionalamendment #ConstitutionalCourts #pti #imrankhan #juif #maulanafazlurrehman #khabar #muhammadmalick #supremecourt
Constitutional Courts ka Muamla, Hukumat Ka Peeche Hatne Ka Iradah? Hasnaat Malik's Give Inside News
Constitutional Courts ka Muamla, Hukumat Ka Peeche Hatne Ka Iradah? Hasnaat Malik's Give Inside News
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Saudi Arabia's investment minister has come with a delegation of 130 people.
00:05The government is very happy and says that at least 2 billion dollars plus agreements will be made.
00:10The stock market has crossed the psychological limit of 86,000.
00:14They are very happy about that.
00:15The SCO is happening.
00:17They have broken the PTI, which was a procession.
00:20Mr. Gandapur has been giving clarifications for the past three days.
00:24So, a lot is happening in the country right now.
00:26But the real thing is the same.
00:27The news is that what is going to happen is the news of the constitutional amendments.
00:32Now, Mr. Kamran Murza, the JUI, cancels PTI and the rest of the JUI is a very critical thing.
00:39The government says that we have numbers, but we need Mr. Maulana to be with us for moral authority.
00:45Mr. Kamran Murza, his legal team is also in good spirits.
00:50They have done a lot of ifs and buts.
00:52This evening, Mr. Hafiz Abdullah, the senior leader of the JUI, tweeted something very scary.
00:59He said that a puppet court is being established in the name of the expected constitutional court, which will be under the executive.
01:07Then he said that the members of the judiciary have come out.
01:10It is time to fight for justice and constitutional protection.
01:12If you take silence, history will not forgive you.
01:15Perhaps the government has been given the task to end freedom of expression or go home.
01:20It is very close, but those who know Mr. Maulana say that Mr. Maulana never takes such a definitive position.
01:27He always keeps a manoeuvring room.
01:29So, these are pressure tactics because the government is giving the impression that in the coming days, they will also get reserve seats.
01:36And so far, the Election Commission has not disappointed this government.
01:40Whether it is the service after 8th February to 9th February or when the election tribunals were formed in Punjab.
01:48In the end, the Chief Justice of the Lahore High Court had to step back and the Supreme Court gave him the tribunals.
01:56Then today, when all this was going on, the Chief Justice, Mr. Faiz Issa, said a very interesting sentence.
02:05He said that instead of court decisions, the constitution and the law passed by the parliament should go to that.
02:14So, maybe if the Election Commission is listening, they will get more pressure.
02:19The Chief Justice has said that leave the court orders and follow the act passed by the government.
02:26So, things look hunky-dory on this front.
02:28So, what is happening? What is happening or not happening?
02:31In the first part of the program, we will talk about this.
02:34Mr. Asnath Malik has joined us. He is a great court reporter.
02:37He doesn't talk about right-wingers. He talks about credible things. We have invited him.
02:42Mr. Miral Kiani is with us. He is the senior leader of PMLN and MNA.
02:46We will also talk to Mr. Ali Muhammad Khan. He is the senior leader and MNA of PTI.
02:51Mr. Asnath, very quickly, what is the latest? What are you listening to?
02:55I have heard that Attorney General has met people. He has met friends. He has spoken to others.
02:59From there, it is going on that maybe the constitutional amendment is coming, but the constitutional court is not coming.
03:06I have spoken to a lot of relevant people.
03:09They have said that the work for which all the assemblies are being set up,
03:13the jewel of the crown is the constitutional court.
03:16So, it will come. What is your opinion?
03:19Look, Mr. Malik, there is a meeting of different people on the 7th of every month.
03:24In that, it is said that even if we make a federal constitutional court, it is not sustainable.
03:29There is a lot of pressure from the courts. And it will increase.
03:33The election of the Supreme Court is in the last week of the month.
03:39There are more chances of setbacks.
03:42So, it is said that the idea of a federal constitutional court should be rethinked and dropped.
03:48And then it is said that whether we make Justice Mansoor Ali Shah directly the Chief Justice of Pakistan
03:56and issue a notification or not.
03:58On this, it is being discussed whether Justice Mansoor Ali Shah's notification will be issued in the next 2-3 days or not.
04:05Another opinion is that we have to make a constitutional amendment.
04:08There are many other things.
04:10For example, the issue of appointment of judges.
04:12In that, the Judicial Commission and the Parliamentary Committee,
04:15that is, all the representatives of the Parliament and the judges will sit in one place.
04:20The second issue is that there should be a panel for the appointment of the Chief Justice in the Supreme Court.
04:25So, these are some of the things.
04:27Even if Justice Mansoor Ali Shah's notification is issued,
04:29there are still attempts to make a constitutional amendment.
04:32But it is being said in the federal constitutional court that it should be rethinked.
04:35In fact, the idea of a federal constitutional court should be dropped.
04:40Mr. Kaini, has it been dropped?
04:42Yes, in the name of Allah.
04:43Mr. Malik, thank you for having me on your show.
04:45Look, according to my information, there is nothing like that.
04:48Because other parties are still discussing.
04:52But the idea has not been dropped.
04:55No, no, no.
04:56In my knowledge, the constitutional courts are completely under discussion.
04:59On its methodology, on its details.
05:01A constitutional court, the recomposition of the Judicial Commission,
05:05which was also mentioned by Mr. Asnath,
05:07in which the parliamentary representation, both opposition and treasury are present.
05:10Now, yes, the exact limits of the constitutional courts.
05:14Now you will get the results.
05:17Now, look, the rest of the debate is still going on on the details.
05:23But the constitutional courts, as per my information, are very much still on the table.
05:27And all three main parties, JUI, PMLN, People's Party, are discussing this.
05:31As far as the matter of reserve seats is concerned.
05:33Look, the speaker of the reserve seats has now sent two letters to the Election Commission.
05:39And apart from this, you have seen that the review petitions of the Election Commission and the government
05:43are still pending regarding the main judgment.
05:47Which we still consider to be unconstitutional.
05:50Mr. D'Souza has also said that they should leave the judicial decisions.
05:54When the constitution and the law were made, the government was in control.
05:58No, look, whether it is a parliamentarian or a judiciary,
06:01it is a matter of compliance with the constitution.
06:03Even a decision of the Supreme Court, which is contrary to the constitution,
06:06cannot prevail.
06:07For example, the 63A judgment.
06:09You saw that it was a blatant rewriting of the constitution.
06:12It was a judgment of the Supreme Court.
06:14It was corrected after more than two years of delay.
06:17No, I say that you people did the right thing, but in a wrong way.
06:21I was a critic of the 63A judgment.
06:23No, what did we do in that?
06:24But the way you did it.
06:25No, we did nothing.
06:26The court corrected itself.
06:28First, you gave an order to make a bench again.
06:33Then they made a bench again.
06:35Then a five-member bench was made.
06:37One of the judges did not sit that day.
06:39Muneeb Akhtar did not get up that day.
06:41You still made a four-member bench with the judges.
06:44CJ sir did all the work.
06:46The next day, the judges also came.
06:50So there are a lot of question marks in that.
06:52There are a lot of question marks.
06:53No, there is no question mark for me.
06:54There was no direct work.
06:55No, no, in my opinion, it was a case of better late than never.
06:58Because it should have been done two years ago.
07:00So such a rewriting of the constitution,
07:02in which it is out of my understanding that there is no parliamentarian.
07:05But you have said that a constitutional court will be formed.
07:08Then I will take Ali Mohammad Khan sir as well.
07:11No, no, very quickly.
07:12I would just like to say that look,
07:14at what stage we are now.
07:16A constitutional court, Judicial Commission of Pakistan,
07:18and other cases are under discussion in a constitutional amendments package.
07:23Its details are being discussed on the basis of its various aspects on a daily basis.
07:28Working groups are working, drafts are being shared.
07:30Look, the numbers will flow from the agreement between the three parties.
07:33Once the three parties have agreed in principle two things,
07:36then there will be an agreement on a draft.
07:38So first there will be the numbers of those three parties.
07:40And then the rest of the parliamentarians,
07:42the process of calling them will be seen,
07:44how many members are required.
07:45But first it has to flow from an agreement between these three parties.
07:48It will be done.
07:49Inshallah.
07:50So your cementing bond is very strong, right?
07:53Yes, yes, it is a constitution, it is a parliament, it is a democracy.
07:56Unlike PTI.
07:57There are more bonds.
07:58Unlike PTI, which boycotted the All Parties Conference on an important matter like Palestine.
08:03What seriousness did it show?
08:04Shall I leave?